News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google, once disdainful of lobbying, now a master of Wash... by jejones3141 on Sunday April 13, 2014 @02:01PM (#7582155)
If the government were confined to its proper function, companies would not have to attempt to influence it.
Re:Google, once disdainful of lobbying, now a master of Wash... by dragonwriter on Sunday April 13, 2014 @02:05PM (#7582178)
If the government has any function, actors subject in any way to its authority, whether individuals in their personal capacity or collections of individuals acting for a common purpose like companies, will retain an interest in influencing how it performs those functions.

Not to mention that if government is confined in its function by some external constraints, those same actors will have an interest in influencing whomever is imposing that constraint -- which, in a very real sense, is the most powerful part of the real government, even if goes by some other name -- to align the constraint with the actors' interests.

Re:Google, once disdainful of lobbying, now a master of Wash... by crusso on Sunday April 13, 2014 @02:13PM (#7582217)
Well, I'd revise that to say: If the government were confined to its Constitutional restraints, companies would have much less reason to even want to influence it.

It's the very size and scope of the government and acceptance into all aspects of our lives that gives it power. That power is what lobbyists broker for companies.

Re:Google, once disdainful of lobbying, now a master of Wash... by rayiner on Sunday April 13, 2014 @08:38PM (#7583872)
If we held the federal government to strict constitutional constraints, we'd just do all this at the state level.
Re:Google, once disdainful of lobbying, now a master of Wash... by crusso on Sunday April 13, 2014 @09:11PM (#7583991)
Not at all. If, say, healthcare were not being taken over by the Federal government, it doesn't mean that all states would attempt to completely take over healthcare within their borders. They certainly weren't doing so before 2008.

Bottlenecking all of that power in Washington DC just makes it a more attractive target. If lobbyists had to maintain control across 50 states, the bar would be raised. In many cases, states would decide on ethical restraints upon lobbyists that would allow us to experiment with ways to control the damage that they do.

Re:Google, once disdainful of lobbying, now a master of Wash... by rayiner on Monday April 14, 2014 @08:49AM (#7585785)
The state governments don't do these things because the federal government sucks the air (and tax revenue) out of the room. But people want these things, as evidenced by the fact that they keep voting for them. If the federal government was small, the state governments would be bigger and have higher taxes.

Having the power centralized in Washington does make it a more attractive target, but also subjects it to more scrutiny. In practice, state and local governments are far more corrupt than the federal government.

Re:Google, once disdainful of lobbying, now a master of Wash... by crusso on Monday April 14, 2014 @10:17AM (#7586262)
state governments don't do these things because

We already know that even within the context of "things that states can do", there is a tremendous amount of diversity amongst the states. This would continue even if states felt that they needed to fill some voids left by a defanged Federal Government. Federalism is a good thing. We see New York panicking and considering policies (like the "tax free zones/hiatus") they never would have in a vacuum because of revenue/brain drain to states like Texas that are more business-friendly.

In practice, state and local governments are far more corrupt than the federal government

They're corrupt in their own ways, but they don't have access to the levels of corruption of the Federal Government. State representatives can't legally inside trade on US stock exchanges. They can't even give themselves that kind of power. State representatives can't distribute national ethanol subsidies. State representatives can't bail out their buddies on Wall Street. The list of what States just don't have the power to do is really long.

Re:Google, once disdainful of lobbying, now a master of Wash... by declan on Monday April 14, 2014 @01:03AM (#7584619)
Except federalism.
Re:Google, once disdainful of lobbying, now a master of Wash... by snowwrestler on Sunday April 13, 2014 @02:41PM (#7582364)
If you look at nations around the world, there is no consistent correlation between the powers of a central government and its state of corruption. For example the Afghan government is very weak, yet is still very corrupt.
Re:Google, once disdainful of lobbying, now a master of Wash... by brc on Monday April 14, 2014 @01:13AM (#7584639)
I take the original comment to mean : if you limit the size of the government, you limit the ability for people to abuse it's power for their own purposes. That's not the same as corruption. A government can still be powerful, but limited in the spheres in which it has power.
Re:Google, once disdainful of lobbying, now a master of Wash... by hackuser on Sunday April 13, 2014 @10:00PM (#7584117)
>If you look at nations around the world, there is no consistent correlation between the powers of a central government and its state of corruption. For example the Afghan government is very weak, yet is still very corrupt.

I would expect, without looking at data, that the relationship is the reverse: More corrupt governments are weaker. This data seems to bear it out:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_Perceptions_Index

Re:Google, once disdainful of lobbying, now a master of Wash... by snowwrestler on Monday April 14, 2014 @09:36AM (#7586020)
That was my thinking as well but Russia breaks the correlation-- very strong government, high perception of corruption.