It's a tactic to get the company into the 'no-shop' stage of a deal, where they've agreed (and probably signed legal paperwork) to say that they won't talk to other investors. Once in that stage, the investor is free to begin renegotiation of key terms. Valuation is rarely the only item on the table. Consider, board seats, liquidation prefs, change of control, etc. there are myriad ways that a company can end up (inadvertently) screwing itself.
i'm having some trouble believing the entire Andreessen rant. if companies get screwed during the no-shop period because major pre-agreed terms are broken, the company/founders are free to go to other investors. something doesn't add up, I wished Andreessen was a bit more explicit in his complaint.
The whole point of Andreessen's comment is that companies would have little choice. It doesn't follow that valuation, the biggest term, would be magically exempt from this renegotiation tactic.
No, it's really not. If someone offered me a sky-high valuation but demanded 15 board seats I would be pretty foolish to blindly accept. I'd have just given up control of the company. Or what about the specifics of any anti-dilution provisions?
> "The whole point of Andreessen's comment is that companies would have little choice. It doesn't follow that valuation, the biggest term, would be magically exempt from this renegotiation tactic."
If valuation is not the most important term to the investor, then it's it's not the one they have to play hardball with. It's possible that the companies are simply blinkered by the vanity around huge numbers and not paying attention to the other factors.
In any case, if I want to later on assume more control of the company I can offer a ridiculous (and unsupportable) valuation and then exploit other mechanisms via a subsequent down-round to attain a larger share for myself. Some people might call this unethical, others might call it business-as-usual.
If his claim is true that non-Silicon-Valley investors are applying unethical leverage, why are the valuations still sky high?
This claim would make more sense if there were a bunch of companies taking non-SV investments at strangely low valuations. Or are there hidden unfavorable terms that Andreessen is hinting at? Is there any evidence of that? Exempt evidence I would assume the default position that this is advice calculated to reduce competition with Silicon Valley VCs.