Re:Distrusting StartSSL
by tptacek on Saturday April 12, 2014 @08:18PM
(#7579677)
The business model animating Start's terms is clear to both of us (we've both sold software long enough to see it). Start doesn't make money selling ads and they don't make money reselling personal information. And yet they give something valuable away for free. There's pretty much one model left for them to avail themselves of: upselling.
The Start deal is obvious: you can have an SSL certificate for free now, but that certificate is inappropriate for (for lack of a better term) "serious business" (actually, any business, as stated in their terms, but I digress). The idea behind the offering is that once you realize you actually get value out of the thing they gave you, you'll convert to a paying customer.
Revocation is, as is clearly stated, one of the points in their customer acquisition process at which window-shopping free SSL cert users convert to paying users.
This isn't a complicated analysis. It is the idea behind the offering. People revoking their certificates are demonstrating that they value them. Like most people who value their certs already did, they should simply pay for the new certificate. Failing that, they can (a) accept the minimal risk that their keys were compromised, or (b) change hostnames, kill the old hostname, and start up with a new certificate.
What's at stake here isn't the fate of the Internet. It's the convenience of "customers" who have a revealed $0 preference for security.
I'm guessing that neither of us like the CA cartel, but we deal with the world as it presents itself to us, not as we wish it to be. Support TACK! It's a step in the direction of less dependences on for-profit central authorities.
The Start deal is obvious: you can have an SSL certificate for free now, but that certificate is inappropriate for (for lack of a better term) "serious business" (actually, any business, as stated in their terms, but I digress). The idea behind the offering is that once you realize you actually get value out of the thing they gave you, you'll convert to a paying customer.
Revocation is, as is clearly stated, one of the points in their customer acquisition process at which window-shopping free SSL cert users convert to paying users.
This isn't a complicated analysis. It is the idea behind the offering. People revoking their certificates are demonstrating that they value them. Like most people who value their certs already did, they should simply pay for the new certificate. Failing that, they can (a) accept the minimal risk that their keys were compromised, or (b) change hostnames, kill the old hostname, and start up with a new certificate.
What's at stake here isn't the fate of the Internet. It's the convenience of "customers" who have a revealed $0 preference for security.
I'm guessing that neither of us like the CA cartel, but we deal with the world as it presents itself to us, not as we wish it to be. Support TACK! It's a step in the direction of less dependences on for-profit central authorities.