Passionately loving the domain is a double-edged sword. Sure, it can drive you to make something awesome. But it can also drive you to make something awesome for you personally, but that nobody else gives a shit about. Or, more subtly problematic, it can lead you to make the software equivalent of quirky indie movies that are, at best, marginally profitable.
I also think passion is something you can develop over time. I've worked on a number of things where I had no initial interest. But I do like making users happy, so I get excited about the domain via seeing what gets users excited.
LOL, yes I agree that my writing was a bit dry. But we all play charades, and are passionate about it. That said, I think there are enough examples as well of startups that have succeeded where the founders themselves were not part of the primary target user community, but they developed a deep enough understanding of the users needs to build a successful product.
Incidentally, I OH this on Facebook: We tend to underestimate long term impact of reason and short term impact of passion.
In some sense it is almost better if the founder is not too attached to the idea. I don't see how one user (the founder) being super excited translates to a viable MVP - but I could see how it could lead them to ignore the results of their experiments and the actual data.
Re:What We Learnt From a Failed MVP
by raverbashing on Saturday April 12, 2014 @05:18PM
(#7579253)
"I don't see how one user (the founder) being super excited translates to a viable MVP "
Less excited people simply won't bother building it.
It's that simple.
Re:What We Learnt From a Failed MVP
by carrotleads on Saturday April 12, 2014 @07:39PM
(#7579608)
Less excited people won't know what makes some problems acute and some not so much.
To me, it seems like the best products are the ones that served the creators' wants and needs. Github was created because the founders wanted to share code more easily. Facebook was created as a better way to (eventually) get laid as a college student.
If you really love playing charades, and more importantly, love playing charades so much that you'll do it online, even with strangers, then the path to a viable MVP seems clear. As it currently reads, the OP's analysis seems sound, but without much of the passion that seems needed to drive a product.