I'm not claiming tipping is certainly useless. Just questioning the argument in its favor.
[1] Not all managers are good, and so we encounter businesses that provide poor service. Sometimes the market weeds those out, sometimes not. According to the parent commenter, that's what happened at the restaurant s/he visited.
Maybe it is.
No Tips vs Tips:
Delivery:
Package/Letter (no tips): constant missed deliveries. poor to
non-existent delivery scheduling.
crushed boxes.
Food (tips): reliable delivery within the hour. delivery person
knocks on the door more than once. never found a pizza
carelessly thrown into the bushes beside my door.
Luggage handling:
Checked luggage (no tips): constantly lost.
Porter/redcap (tips): the people you go to if you *actually* want
your luggage taken care of.
Service/Repair:
Cable (no tips): only able to schedule service during inconvenient
hours a week in advance, with service windows so large
that I need to take a day off work.
Plumbing (tips/negotiable pay): I have gotten plumbers to my home in
the middle of the night.
Apartment repair guy (no tips): Ahahahahaha....
The one counter-example that I can think of is cab/uber service. There is a hell of a lot wrong with the cab industry though.- You have got to get your store's license renewed but there's a huge lag and there are many people ahead line: Pay the officer, problem solved.
- Need to renew your passport: Pay the consul officer, you get it all expedited.
- etc etc
Yes, that's exactly what you are doing. You are bribing them to do something that they should do normally. They will basically keep misplacing other people's deliveries, treat other guests bad, losing others' luggage, making others take their day off, not do plumbing in time, not fix people's flats, while they do yours because you pay them some "extra money".
Rephrase it what you want but we are talking about clear bribes here.
For the record:
Bribery, as you describe it, is alive and well in America. My brother wanted to go to the Naval Academy. In order to be accepted, he needed a nomination. How did he get a nomination? He volunteered for the reelection campaign of one of his senators.
Asking your senators/representatives for help expediting the processing of documents is fairly common too.
At least in the way John McAffee described bribery and corruption in the middle east.
I remain unconvinced that tipping culture improves service, and it's most certainly sexist, racist, and ageist.
Quoting from the article here:
http://brazilsense.com/index.php?title=Tipping,_fraud,_and_s...
it says, "The service fee when added is still considered optional. However, Brazilians do always pay it — except when the service was poor. If the service was poor, all you have to say is Eu não vou pagar esse (I will not pay that) pointing at the service fee, and then pay just the base amount. I've seen Brazilians do exactly that when the service was bad and it didn't cause a scene."
The issue could easily be bad management, bad hiring, etc etc etc.
Of course more data is better.
[1] http://blog.revolutionanalytics.com/2011/04/the-plural-of-an...
The "not data" version is saying that anecdotes are in such small numbers and uncontrolled circumstances, that even though they are data points in and of themselves, they're not rigorous enough to draw wider conclusions from. It's a different context.
e.g. I know MANY people who claim to have seen a ghost, but I don't consider that useful data supporting the existence of ghosts. Technically it is data, but it's the LEAST trustworthy form of data, hence the dismissive expression.
Here's my anecdote: I ate in a tipping restaurant in Texas. The steak was late, lukewarm, and so small it slid across the empty plate. The only thing accompanying the steak was a pot of mashed potatoes about four times the size of a thimble. After being largely ignored, the waitress at the end of the meal made a ton of excuses while looking at the wall so as to get me to still tip, and zero effort was made to make me feel better about the situation. If we're making sweeping proclamations from single experiences, then this must mean that tipping restaurants make for very much worse experiences.
I don't like tipping culture for all the usual reasons, plus a couple more. I don't like the waitstaff's arms being constantly in my dinner conversation, as they refill water or keep checking how I'm doing. I don't like that in almost every other job you can have a crappy day but still come out of it with the same wage - tipping faults people for being human. Imagine if software devs had a variable rate largely based on how they were feeling that day? I mean, code and design when you're distracted or angry isn't as good as when you're focused and content, so it stands up to the same reasoning. HN would be in furore if a tech company proposed that.
It's as simple as that. You don't get better service because of tipping, and the Linkery was obviously too far out of the comfort zone of the American workers who were used to working for tips.
Don't blame the poor service on the lack of tips until you've seen a number of tip-free restaurants fail and can attribute the failure to the lack of tips rather than poor management, and inexperienced staff.
>Back when I lived in San Diego I took my parents to the Linkery. The service was so bad it actually reversed my opinions against tipping. The servers clearly didn't care much about making us happy, messing up almost every aspect of the order. They put meat in my food - I'm vegetarian. My father got his food 20 minutes after my mother and I did. The waiter forgot one of my drinks. We called over the manager who offered us a free dessert to make up for it. Guess what? The dessert was on the bill. I'm always happy to tip 20+% for good service, but being forced (yes, we asked) to pay the service charge added insult to injury. This is just one data point, but the Linkery was infamous around San Diego for having much worse service than other places in a similar price range. I'm convinced their experiment with tipping was correlated with this.