Re:What Happened to the Hominids Who May Have Been Smarter T...
by joe_the_user on Friday April 11, 2014 @10:16PM
(#7576686)
And another possibility is that the large brain size just didn't result in greater intelligence or a larger amount of the right kind of flexible intelligence. One could guess that humans need a properly designed brain to behave as we do, not simply any old larger brain.
Cf. the "Starchild" skull that conspiracy theorists still love to speculate about, long after it was shown to be the skull of a hydrocephalic individual.
It's not impossible that this was a lineage of large-brained hominids, distinct from our own. Evolution favors local optima; it does not follow a teleological pattern. If big brains weren't advantageous to the local circumstances, they wouldn't have survived. But the big-brained, distinct-species theory speculates quite a bit on very little evidence.
[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_cranial_deformation