I don't know. Everybody knows HTML. It's pretty easy.
> If people input with HTML then you're going to need to filter which tags you do and don't want to pass through.
That's a solved problem¹²³.
> Markdown just gets rid of stuff like that.
And you can only use a subset of HTML. I guess there are pros and cons.
> Not to mention automatic paragraphing.
<p>...</p>
¹https://code.google.com/p/owasp-java-html-sanitizer/Little things like <em> or <i>, and browsers being very tolerant of appalling HTML, mean that a lot of people only sort of know HTML.
I do wosh that BBCode or Markdown had better standards.
Absolutely. You could've stopped there without any further caveats. The comment above I think is HN arrogance, assuming that the rest of the web is at a certain minimum level of tech literacy.
So many people post facebook updates or online comments and don't what what HTML is. I know someone (relatively young, uses the internet daily) who doesn't know what a browser is.
That aside, if given the choice, I would voluntarily use Markdown for comments all day long, no contest. For example a bullet/unordered list[1] needs so many awkward tags, whereas a Markdown list is much simpler, and much more intuitive for those who don't know HTML[2].
[1] http://www.w3schools.com/tags/tag_ul.asp
[2] http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/6ewgt/reddit_mar...
How about the other 0.1%? Well, why not a WYSIWYG editor (similar to that on Stack Overflow) that generates HTML? I mean, what are we, barbarians?!
I'll note that the source to your Reddit article is 322 lines long! That'a lot to remember!
I'm learning Python, I don't expect to learn all the features, hopefully I will learn a small subset, enough to be dangerous!
> Well, why not a WYSIWYG editor (similar to that on Stack Overflow) that generates HTML?
Absolutely, this is a good solution also. I personally like knowing the markdown features, I guess, but that's just me ;-) There is an extremely similar feature in the RES addon which allows live preview, not possible on a smaller screen though. It even includes a helpful list of markdown features for the newbie.
...OK, an exaggeration. But it's much simpler than HTML. If people input with HTML then you're going to need to filter which tags you do and don't want to pass through. Markdown just gets rid of stuff like that. Not to mention automatic paragraphing.