News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Tim Ferriss acting like an asshole? by SwellJoe on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @06:07PM (#756556)
So, now that I've actually read the article I feel like ranting a bit.

The thing about these kinds of contests is that they serve a niche that very much wanted filling: Low budget design projects that "real" design firms wouldn't touch.

Large clients already get ideas on spec from those design firms...this "contest" process just makes it possible for small companies to get the same treatment. Yes, it comes from less experienced designers, and it comes with some additional problems (like the unpredictability of follow-on work, which may or may not be of reasonable quality and may or may not be available from the same designer at all). But, for one-off design work, like a logo, it's simply the best way for a small business to get design work done quickly and cost-effectively.

When times get tough, as in a recession, folks often start looking for people to blame for their own reduced income. Some folks blame immigrants, and this is just an indirect version of that...blaming foreigners for working too cheap and cheapening their trade by accepting these contest terms. Because the reality is that most of the designers taking part in $250 contests are overseas.

The funny thing is that software shops have historically gotten some flack for using design contests and such...but the fact is software development was among the first to experience this pressure from cheap overseas white collar human resources. We hackers have been dealing with it far longer than designers, and though a few among us belly-ache and bitch and moan, most of us have embraced the differences and compete on quality and taste rather than price.

In other words: Tim Ferriss, while possibly an asshole on other occasions and for other reasons, is not acting like an asshole by holding a design contest.

Re:Is Tim Ferriss acting like an asshole? by tonystubblebine on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @06:32PM (#756615)
Thank you. I would be interested to hear a designer's take on what the downsides to spec work are for me. But everytime I read an anti-spec rant it includes accusations directed at me that are patently false, like that I ran a spec contest because I don't value or respect the work of designers. No, I ran a spec contest because it was the only thing I could afford.

The second, and most obvious criticism of anti-spec arguments, is that the designers on the other end are choosing to engage in them. If the anti-spec crowd can't convince designers who participate in spec contests, why should we pay them any attention?

For people who feel so passionately about a topic, I wish they would at least put the time into creating a more compelling argument.

Re:Is Tim Ferriss acting like an asshole? by potatolicious on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @06:35PM (#756624)
> Large clients already get ideas on spec from those design firms

No, this is not the same. Large clients get little bits of spec work done for them which, on the whole, are not very useful in an of itself. To actually get the work done they will still need to pick a winning bidder and pay them fairly for the work.

In other words, the invested effort vs. the potential reward is pretty favorable for the design firm. For one thing, you're not competing against 50,000 other people on the interwebs, and secondly there's no danger of the client "stealing" your work - since they themselves would have little use for what amounts to an insignificant portion of the grand project.

That's a pretty key difference - in this case Ferriss has not promised a contract to the winning bidder, and what he is asking for is complete work directly. This strikes me as unfair. Where the traditional spec-work model is supposed to be a "try before you buy" thing, Ferriss is simply asking for a bunch of free, final copies to be produced for him gratis.

Re:Is Tim Ferriss acting like an asshole? by SwellJoe on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @07:14PM (#756718)
For one thing, you're not competing against 50,000 other people on the interwebs

You're always competing with lots of other people; and there will be more to compete with tomorrow than there are today. That is the reality of the ever-shrinking world in which we live. The good news is that those same people entering the market are also consumers of goods and services, and thus grow the total value of the market, making humanity as a whole richer.

Anyway, if you don't want to compete, you shouldn't be in a competitive customer-facing industry. You should work for someone else, far away from the sales and marketing process. Design is pretty much always tightly coupled with marketing; them's the breaks.

there's no danger of the client "stealing" your work

This is a wholly orthogonal issue.

There's always danger of clients not paying, checks bouncing, promises not being kept, people stealing art from the web. It goes both ways: I've had designers flake on me and not keep promises and deadlines. This is not relevant to the discussion at hand. Theft of design work happens, but it's not exclusive to the design contest model (and I've never even heard that it's a major problem with the model, but I don't follow it very closely; but, I think the very act of putting up the contest indicates the client would rather buy art than grab something off of the Internet and re-purpose it for free). And, we are specifically talking about someone for whom stealing $250 worth of work would do dramatically more damage to his reputation than a measly 250 bucks. I don't think Tim Ferriss would steal $250 worth of design work.

Where the traditional spec-work model is supposed to be a "try before you buy" thing, Ferriss is simply asking for a bunch of free, final copies to be produced for him gratis.

What a tyrant. Good thing you can decline the offer.

Re:Is Tim Ferriss acting like an asshole? by run4yourlives on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @06:44PM (#756648)
>for him gratis.

No, not for free - for trade. He's offering all the publicity that he can generate as a return gesture. If you think that is a worthy trade, great. If not, great too.

Stop forcing people to negotiate their deals on your terms. It's called a free market for a reason.

Re:Is Tim Ferriss acting like an asshole? by potatolicious on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @06:49PM (#756658)
> He's offering all the publicity that he can generate as a return gesture.

No he's not. The author of the article addresses this specifically - he's saying that too many people looking for spec work promise this ephemeral, vague notion of "exposure", which really isn't worth as much as the client thinks it is.

And he brings up the Harry Potter example. EVERYONE has seen the cover to the Harry Potter books, but does anyone here actually know the designer's name?

> Stop forcing people to negotiate their deals on your terms. It's called a free market for a reason.

I wish the real world can be as black-and-white as yours. There are certain types of behaviour that is, in the long run anyway, a net negative for nearly everyone in an industry. There is nothing wrong with being in opposition to these things. It's not like we're hiring thugs to beat up people who are willing to do spec work.

Re:Is Tim Ferriss acting like an asshole? by run4yourlives on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @06:55PM (#756671)
No he's not.

Yes, he is.

which really isn't worth as much as the client thinks it is.

That's a completely different argument, and I addressed this in my first post.

a net negative for nearly everyone in an industry.

Um, except for the kid who turns around in a week's time and can say: You know that new Tim Ferris book? I designed that.

Clearly, not everyone.

I'm always concerned when people start talking about benefiting industry. In almost every case, the "benefit to the industry" is at a loss to the consumer.

It's not like we're hiring thugs to beat up people who are willing to do spec work.

No, but you have no problem publicly vilifying them, do you?

Re:Is Tim Ferriss acting like an asshole? by potatolicious on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @07:12PM (#756713)
> No, but you have no problem publicly vilifying them, do you?

Please to not be putting words in my mouth? Kthx.

Seriously though, I don't have a problem with people willing to do spec work at all - I see it as a symptom of a systematic problem that is encouraged by people abusing the spec work model.

As I've said before, the concept of spec work originally is so that the client can "try before they buy" - given that designers have such a high variance, and the product is hardly a commodity. You do a bit of leg work, show off your chops, and the rest of a sizable job is yours.

The problem here is when people start soliciting complete work for commercial purposes. This is not a try-before-you-buy, this is just give-me-stuff-for-free.

Material benefits (and lack thereof) aside, I think this model reeks of disrespect for the design community (disclosure: I am a coder, not a designer). I've issued these design contests myself in the past, and I no longer do so - and every single time I did, I felt like a jackass, since clearly I was trying to get something for nothing. I was trying to gain ownership for a volume of work that is worth far more than what I paid for it (in cash, "exposure", etc). This is not an equitable trade, and I knew it the entire time - and I think a reasonably smart guy like Ferriss knows this too.

By the way, since I saw a post somewhere in this thread... I issued the contests because I was too poor to pay for real design work - but that's a justification to myself and myself only, and does nothing to change the fact that I the trade was still not equitable.

Re:Is Tim Ferriss acting like an asshole? by tptacek on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @06:40PM (#756635)
Are you saying Ferris is "stealing" work from his submissions, or did you just mention theft to further muddy the waters?
Re:Is Tim Ferriss acting like an asshole? by potatolicious on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @06:53PM (#756668)
Well, he did mention that even non-winning entries now belonged to him. This strikes me as overreaching - why would you want the rights to something you didn't pay for, and allegedly have no intention of using?

The point of the argument stands. If someone asked you to do a week's worth of work for free as a trial for, say, a 5-year contract, that strikes me as a pretty worthwhile deal.

Now if someone asked you to do a week's worth of work for free as a trial for, say, another week's contract, that strikes me as abusive and lacking in respect for my work. Worse if it's just working gratis for the possibility of another contract.

Re:Is Tim Ferriss acting like an asshole? by mechanical_fish on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @07:20PM (#756740)
why would you want the rights to something you didn't pay for, and allegedly have no intention of using?

It is absolutely essential, for legal reasons, to get a signed waiver of copyright from any person that you accept spec work from. Otherwise, when Ferriss' book cover comes out, and it is red and blue with a muscular-looking guy on it, every single person who submitted a red-and-blue-muscle-guy cover will sue him for copyright infringement. There could be hundreds of them.

This is why screenwriters are told to never, ever send unsolicited manuscripts to movie studios. The studios will send them back unopened, encased in slightly larger envelopes, because even opening the envelope will create legal risk: If your script for Transformers 3 has been opened, your lawyer will be able to claim that the studio has seen it, and that the giant metal Cuisinart that appears in the final movie was obviously inspired by the giant metal Kitchenaid that appears in your script, and that they owe you $1 million.

Re:Is Tim Ferriss acting like an asshole? by tptacek on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @07:18PM (#756730)
What would I call it if someone asked me to do a week's worth of work for free as a trial for a contract?

Tuesday.

This is what sets me off about the NO!SPEC drama: this idea that lawyers and engineers would never give their time away for free. Of course, they routinely do. I've gotten multiple hours of free consult from two different top law firms, without even any expectation of any immediate work.