Funnily enough, we feel the same way about people who don't want to pay $20/year for their email address, given that it's the primary method of identifying yourself online.
As with any business expense though, you only want to pay for value - if you spend $1000/year for exactly what you could have got for $100 year, that's wasting money.
And we're satisfied that Gandi know us now! Overall they've been really good - they just missed this one thing when they added 2FA. I bet they're not the only site.
Security is one of my top concerns, which is why I don't need much storage at FastMail. My email is deleted from FastMail's servers in less than 180 days after receipt because the USG considers email over 180 days old to be abandoned and will access such email without a warrant.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_Communications_Priva...
You're also paying for multiple replica copies and backups and all that good stuff. By the time you add RAID, search, metadata, etc - there's pretty much a 10:1 ratio between quota usage figures and raw disk used.
Then there's development effort - we're not just installing a couple of packages and then sitting back and letting them run.
http://reports.internic.net/cgi/whois?whois_nic=google.com&t...
That said I think appeal to authority is quite useful in this situation.
But I would have said the same about mit.edu and they got reassigned about a year ago. Obviously not for long, but the damage someone well-prepared could do by owning google.com for just 30 minutes is scary.
I think the idea behind these services is, they're not just a registrar. Broadly speaking, their business is "know your customer". They're boutiques. They protect large companies against the vagaries of DNS hacks, expired domain registrations, typosquatting, etc.
E.g. a (long) while ago Microsoft failed to renew hotmail.co.uk, just like they previously forgot to renew passport.com. But today, Microsoft can't forget to renew microsoft.com, because that's now MarkMonitor's job. Similarly, renewing passport.com is now the job of (according to whois '=passport.com'):
Corporation Service Company(c) (CSC)
The Trusted Partner
of More than 50% of the 100 Best Global Brands.
The bad part is if CSC screws up, quite a few companies could be in a world of hurt.This is different than a registrar lock in that a registrar lock is managed by the registrar (GoDaddy, Tucows, etc) but a registry lock is managed by the registry themselves. It requires personal contact with specific individuals to enable and disable the lock, making attempts to steal domains more difficult (but not impossible since social engineering is still feasible).
I've never used MarkMonitor before, but I did handle the registration for a hugely popular domain at one time. They decided to move to MarkMonitor but in the meantime they requested a registry lock set up on their main domain. This turned out to be very good idea since the registrar at the time was social engineered into changing the credentials for the account (with forged letter head similar to the fastmail.fm attack). The attackers were able to change the nameservers for little used domains but their main domain could not be modified.
http://thenextweb.com/facebook/2014/02/06/uh-oh-syrian-elect....
Of course if it was hacked it wasn't necessarily MarkMonitor's fault; it could be Facebook's (though good security would anticipate that some customers will have poor security).
(If that post looks familiar, yes I'm reposting from a few days ago when someone made a similar comment. I'm hoping someone knows more about it.)
The problem with their system is that it has the right amount of human intervention to be fallible to social engineering.
It also ensures that your registrar has the resources required to guarantee a very high level of verification and due process to ensure that everything is done correctly, with lots of extra human review (in addition to all of the automated safety checks, not instead of)
I've heard good things about https://www.markmonitor.com/ when it comes to managing domains (among other things)