News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bullies can be stopped, but it takes a village by fauigerzigerk on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @04:18PM (#756267)
That's a very strange account of how bullying works. The impression I get from what people tell me and situations I have witnessed is that the lonely male bully described here is a very rare exception.

The typical situation is a group of people led by a smaller sub-group acting against an individual in pretty obvious ways. The victim is sidelined and ridiculed openly so everybody knows. Teachers always know.

The authors describe the bully as some kind of genius who always selects the right victims and always chooses occasions wisely. That's complete nonsense.

People who become victims are completely random. Take any closed situation where people can't leave at will, like schools, military camps, prisons, the workplace, and anyone can be made a victim. No need for the bullies to choose wisely.

There's just no way anyone can defend himself against a socially dominant group who decides to bully them. The only right way to react is to leave instantly. Victims can be harmed for life if left in a situation like that. That's what I learned from someone very close to me who was a victim of bullying and researched the whole thing extensively later.

If you have kids who are being bullied, just take them away from the bullies immediately!

Re:Bullies can be stopped, but it takes a village by philwelch on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @04:24PM (#756282)
"People who become victims are completely random. Take any closed situation where people can't leave at will, like schools, military camps, prisons, the workplace, and anyone can be made a victim. No need for the bullies to choose wisely."

This is patently untrue: it's always some particular subgroup that's bullied. School bullies usually target smaller kids, "nerdy" kids, or unpopular kids with poor social skills. Prison bullies usually target small, young, white prisoners who are not members of prison gangs.

Re:Bullies can be stopped, but it takes a village by fauigerzigerk on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @05:27PM (#756466)
I think you are wrong, but I guess we'll need some statistics to resolve that one.

However, the point I was trying to make has nothing to do with the share of nerds among the victims. The point is that it's unnecessary to select particularly weak people because anyone targeted by a determined group of bullies becomes weak and most of the time there's no way to turn the situation around.

It's a mistake to think that anyone could be strong enough to do that, nerd or not.

Re:Bullies can be stopped, but it takes a village by philwelch on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @05:48PM (#756516)
Did I ever say nerdy schoolboys and white prisoners were particularly weak people? No. But here's your assertion:

People who become victims are completely random.

They're not. People who are gang members don't get bullied in prison because the other members of their gang will retaliate. Popular kids don't get bullied in school because their friends will retaliate. And while smaller kids may be weaker targets than bigger kids, nerds or white prisoners are usually bullied because the bullies don't like them.

Re:Bullies can be stopped, but it takes a village by fauigerzigerk on Wednesday August 12, 2009 @01:45AM (#757385)
Did I ever say nerdy schoolboys and white prisoners were particularly weak people?

Yes you did. Nerdy, unpopular with poor social skills, that's what I would call weak in exactly the social sense that's relevant here.

If you bothered to research this matter you would be surprised how much what you are saying is a cliche.

I'll concede, though, that the victims are probably not completely random in a formal statistical sense.

[Edit:] Sorry, our posts crossed. I didn't mean to change mine while you were replying

Re:Bullies can be stopped, but it takes a village by philwelch on Wednesday August 12, 2009 @01:57AM (#757414)
"there is a much broader group of people who become victims than most people think"

True, but if that was your point why didn't you just say it in the first place? In any social context that has bullies, the bullies predominantly belong to some social subgroups, and predominately victimize other social subgroups. Don't make it sound like you're disputing that fact when you're saying something much more mundane and agreeable.

"that's what I would call weak in exactly the social sense that's relevant here"

Sorry, I thought you meant weak in the sense of "less able to put up a fight".

Re:Bullies can be stopped, but it takes a village by fauigerzigerk on Wednesday August 12, 2009 @02:21AM (#757444)
I did say it in the first place but "completely random" was a bit of an exaggeration (even though part of it is really chance). What I dispute is that popular, strong, successful, socializing people never become victims or that they can turn the situation around (short of joining a gang maybe).

They may have friends, but not, for instance, at that new workplace or at that new school. In many cases it's not the victims' character that makes them vulnerable.

Re:Bullies can be stopped, but it takes a village by sethg on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @04:29PM (#756297)
I don't think the authors are claiming that bullies are geniuses. You don't need to be a genius to know who you can get away with bullying. You just need to know that if you abuse X then the only people who might witness the abuse are people who are highly unlikely to snitch.
Re:Bullies can be stopped, but it takes a village by fauigerzigerk on Tuesday August 11, 2009 @05:38PM (#756495)
There are way too many witnesses for that argument to hold water. Usually everyone knows who is being bullied and who is doing the bullying.

When confronted the bullies will present a long list of reasons why the victim deserves to be a victim. Of course violent attacks are kept semi private if you can call it that considering those "happy slapping" pics that are being posted on the internet and sent to people's phones en-masse.

Re:Bullies can be stopped, but it takes a village by sethg on Wednesday August 12, 2009 @08:20AM (#757850)
Of course everyone knows, but if the people who actually witness the offense aren't willing to come forward (because they think that the victim deserved it or because they want to stand with a fellow student against Authority, or whatever), then standard disciplinary processes can't do anything.

The analogous adult case is when a crime syndicate or a terrorist organization assassinates one of its enemies in broad daylight in the middle of a crowded street, and the police can't find anyone to testify that they witnessed the hit. If you don't change the priorities of the bystanders, you can't change anything else.