Natural language can be used with precision, and this is an important skill for engineers. Being able to identify ambiguity and inconsistency is an important part of that skill so yes, noticing it within a question should count in favor of the candidate. Dismissing it as being pedantic is the wrong response, because if you are working on something critical (secure communications software, for example) you need to handle ideas with precision.
Sure, it tests whether you can write a set of statements a computer can understand.
But it also tests whether you can understand the intent behind a set of statements a human would make, without going on a diatribe about how the definition is not good enough.
After all, if English was a formal strict language where only one right way existed to express something, we wouldn't need programmers, would we?
If you just solved the fact that one meaning can have many expressions, we'd still need programmers (and, more relevantly, system analysts) just as much.
The relevant problem is that English isn't a formal strict language where a particular expression can only have one meaning (and, more importantly, that, people don't use it that way even when it superficially seems to be.)
That is, the problem that requires specialized work to develop unambiguous requirements for the implementation of (among other things) information systems isn't that English maps (many expressions) -> (one meaning), but that it maps (one expression) -> (many meanings).
> After all, if English was a formal strict language where only one right way existed to express something, we wouldn't need programmers, would we?
This is very off-topic, but I'm not sure I agree with it. You're assuming that it would be easy to find the one unique way to express a given computation such that anybody could write it down. Even if English had this uniqueness property, I don't think that would be true at all.
> If the number is divisible by 3, print Fizz instead of the number. If it’s divisible by 5, print Buzz. If it’s divisible by both 3 and 5, print FizzBuzz.
In a strict interpretation, the first two sentences could be seen as incorrect. If a number is divisible by 3, you cannot just print 'Fizz' and move on. You also have to check if it's divisible by 5.