Atoms and keysets both have pretty much the same caching semantics, though: they get repeated over the wire with pretty good locality, and don't have conflicting terms busting the cache in-between. That's not really true for anything else, which makes me guess that an arbitrary term-branch cache would be pretty useless.
The idea of having arbitrary subtrees is to support an efficient compression scheme. But you are indeed right that a keyset cache would be extremely effective at limiting the size of maps.
But the rule of the Ericsson OTP team is to get it correct before making it fast.