Re:Most StartSSL certs will stay compromised
by sparkie on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @05:17PM
(#7562475)
The business model an practices of the company are completely irrelevant to the people concerned in this case though - the users of the web browser. They never signed up for shit, and they have no incentive to trust a business which refuses to invoke compromised certs because people are unwilling to pay.
Yes, this doesn't make them untrustworthy as a business, since their business model was known - it does make them untrustworthy as a party which is meant to be securing the web though - because they'll be failing at it spectacularly.
Again: I never signed up to shit, and their business model means shit to me too - I just want some degree of security when browsing.
Re:Most StartSSL certs will stay compromised
by MereInterest on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @07:32PM
(#7563253)
I am not their customer. At most, I am their customers' customer. Why do I have any obligation toward StartSSL? If StartSSL is free to choose a business model, then others are free to make judgment based on that business model.
Should the customers of StartSSL pay the revocation fee? Yes. Should StartSSL be required to give free revocations? No. Are either of those at all relevant to whether or not I should trust StartSSL certificates, given that they are less likely to be revoked when they need to be revoked?
There are tons of SSL certificate providers out there. Their business model was not a secret when folks signed up.