I was just trying to call out that the cost of supplies and facility fees are paid by Medicare separately.
The physician fee is separate from these payments.
For those looking in, ASP is how medicare reimburses outpatient drugs. The physician practice buys the drugs up front, then bills Medicare the "average sales price" + 6%. The issue at hand is that Lucentis runs $2120 per injection. If you have a decent or large sized macular degeneration patient population, you'll be doing a lot of these injections. However, the number the practice collects is $320. Out of that number, you have to pay overhead / office staff / supplies etc.
The other thing to remember is that if it did include ASP reimbursement, ophthalmologists wouldn't be at the top, oncologists would. If a cancer doc saw 200 HER2 positive breast cancer patients in one year (16/month), treating them with Herceptin alone would cost $14,000,000. Most docs I've spoken to see 100-200 cancer patients per month (of course not all get treated with expensive drugs).
Unfortunately, I don't have a good source. The above is merely my speculation.
http://www.cms.gov/Research-Statistics-Data-and-Systems/Stat...
(link goes to the overview download page with context, not directly to the ZIP)
Here's a good overview of the limitations of the data:
http://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2014/04/09/300857727/dos...
Figure malpractice insurance at $50, and he's netting $650k. Figure 10% for billing and business expenses, accountant, etc, and he's netting $600k/year.
Is that still unreasonable for a highly specialized surgeon?
But anyway I don't think any of the numbers are unreasonable. These are ballpark estimates, and I'm pretty sure my tympanoplasty was a relatively boring procedure for him, compared to stuff like cochlear implants and other basal skull surgery that he does sometimes. My main point was that I don't think it's unexpected at all for some surgeons to bill several millions to Medicare in a year. They can easily clear several millions already with a very light schedule and, depending on the specialty, some or most of that may be from Medicare patients. Honestly I think there is no story here.
For example, I just had a surgical procedure last week to have an otologist repair my eardrum. The breakdown in cost is:
Now, the surgeon is very good at what he does and I feel he certainly deserves that $7000. His surgical schedule has him doing procedures twice a week, probably some more complicated than mine, and I'm sure he easily brings in several million dollars to his practice, some non-trivial amount of which comes from Medicare. Other specialties (like oncology and ophthalmology) are obviously going to make up a bigger share of the amount paid by Medicare because they are disproportionately treating older patients.Until we know more, I think it's silly to be outraged about this.