I personally think this is silly.
I agree! Thankfully, that's not actually what Fog Creek does. Let's separate two aspects of this process, because they deserve different treatment: 1. *Going to recruiting sessions.* Going to recruiting sessions
is expensive and time-consuming, as Liz noted. To go to
recruiting sessions, therefore, you have to optimize your bang
for the buck, and *that's* where the selective schools show up:
Fog Creek simply did get a better pool of applications when
going to selective institutions. There are other things that Fog
Creek can do to optimize for candidates who actually build things,
and it turns out they do those things, too (sponsoring intern events,
sponsoring OUTC, and so on). But career fairs at selective schools
can be enormously effective, and are a bit easier to come by.
2. *Evaluating applicants.* When Fog Creek does résumé screening, a
whopping *one out of seven points* is awarded for going to a
selective institution. Everything else--having a portfolio, having
passion, demonstrating follow-through, etc.--has absolutely nothing
to do with where you went to school. And that's *only* used for the
résumé screening. Once you get your foot in the door and talk to
a human, it never comes up ever again, in any context. (When I joined,
Fog Creek even did double-blind interviews to enforce that!)
So yes, only recruiting students at selective schools is stupid. But that's not what Fog Creek does.Outside of that, school selectivity has been only a mediocre predictor for individual candidates. You shouldn't ignore it outright, but you shouldn't be entranced by it. We've had MIT candidates who couldn't really program and a guy whose school I don't even remember who killed it.
If you have zero time to weed a large pile down to a small one and thus no other choice, I can see this being a logical step. However, if you're hiring for any engineering position and the application form doesn't ask for a link to something the candidate has built (be it on Github, Sourceforge, or just on the web in general), you're likely missing out on the most important metric.
The other turnoff in this was the weeding out of candidates based on resumes. We hired an excellent employee out of a batch of horrid resumes- what a great hire, though.
Rutgers is The State University of NJ[2]. It is a very old institution (8th oldest), and that may be where the confusion comes from, since all the other Ivy's came from that time period.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivy_League#Members [2] http://www.rutgers.edu/
I personally think this is silly. If you want to be selective just focus on applicants who actually build things. If you look at collegiate hackathons at places like university of michigan, UIUC, or Purdue it's clear that there is a lot of talent in the midwest. Just because someone wasn't born on a coast or with a connection to an ivy league school doesn't mean they don't make a cut for selectiveness.