In my experience well written C++ has a lot less security issues vs. similar C code. We've had third party security companies audit our code base so my statement has some anecdotal support in real world systems.
"New" is a thing of the past, along with the need to even see T *.
These days good code in C++ is so high-level, one almost never sees a pointer, much less an arbitrarily-sized one. This is of course unless you're dealing with an ancient library.
Another thing of importance:
If you're working with collection iteration correctly (which tends to be the basis for a lot of these out of bounds errors), there is no contesting the beginning offset, or the end offset - much less evaluating whether that end is in sight. Even comparisons missing stronger types showing "this thing is null terminated vs that is not" can be eliminated if you just create enough definitions for the type-system to defend your own interests. If you're coding defensively, these shouldn't even be on the menu. One buffer either fits in the other for two compatible types, or you simply don't try it at all.
It'd be amazing what standard algorithms can leave to the pages of history, if they were actually put to good use.
Python has some nice high-level concepts with their "views" on algorithmic data streams that show where modern C++ is headed with respect to bounds checking, minus the exceptions of course :)
Or you have the cargo cult programmers, who don't know the language very well, so just pick up idioms from random internet postings or from some old part of the codebase that's been working for a while, so it must be a good source of design tips.
Remember, any time you talk about the safety of a language, you have to think about its safety in the hands of a mediocre programmer who's in a hurry to meet a deadline. Because that's where the bulk of the problems slip in; not when people are actively and deliberately coding defensively.
- Stricter type checking than C, (e.g. an error to add a centigrade value to a Fahrenheit value without casting)
- Bounds checked arrays and strings
Turbo Pascal added:
- Selectively turn off bounds checking for performance
- Inline assembler
- Pointers and arbitrary memory allocation
I don't think there's anything you can do in C that you can't do in TP. For example, it was easy to write code that hung off the timer or keyboard interrupts in MSDOS, which is pretty low level stuff.
The important thing is that the safe behaviour should be the default, you have to mark unsafe areas of code explicitly. This is the opposite to how it works with C.
Wow, that sounds scary. Do you have any references or further reading about this?
Now, combining pointers and STL is not a good idea. In fact, using raw pointers in C++ is not a good idea, at least IMO (but you've seen I am a bit concerned about memory safety). However, this is perfectly supported by compilers, and not even seriously discouraged (some guides tell you to be careful out there). I've seen difficult bugs produced by this, in my case, in a complicated singleton object.
Not just your opinion; it's become the "standard of practice" in the C++ development community.
They're trying to get it that between STL, make_shared, C++14's make_unique, etc., that you won't actually be using "naked new"s in any but the rarest cases. For the rest of memory management you'd use types to describe the ownership semantics and let the compiler handle the rest.
I wish godspeed to Rust and any other language which doesn't expose the raw underlying computer the way C/C++ does, which is IMO insane for application programming.