News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Fervent Defense of Front-running HFTs by tptacek on Monday April 07, 2014 @10:56AM (#7546793)
David Einhorn is a hedge fund manager, not a mutual fund manager. Vanguard, one of the world's most reputable mutual fund managers, is on record as saying that HFT has improved their cost to trade.

That was an easy point in your comment to respond to. The rest of it doesn't appear to have been based on Chris Stucchio's post at all; you could just as easily have posted it in every thread on HN about HFT. I must be missing something; what is it?

Re:A Fervent Defense of Front-running HFTs by yummyfajitas on Monday April 07, 2014 @11:06AM (#7546872)
My attempt at a charitable interpretation of Jalopy's post is that he is saying it's actually a bad thing to transfer wealth from informed traders. This is because David Einhorn has demonstrated great competence at trading, and if HFTs predate him it reduces his incentive to continue transmitting useful information to the markets.

I find this to be an argument I can't dismiss easily.

I've added a link to your comment to the original post. It's important to spread this idea as well.

Re:A Fervent Defense of Front-running HFTs by jalopy on Monday April 07, 2014 @11:12AM (#7546911)
Thanks - you captured a good part of my argument. I'd make a small correction though. I don't consider it "trading" as much as "investing".

As a former quant trader and a current (and forevermore) value investor - there is a big difference.

Re:A Fervent Defense of Front-running HFTs by ochowie on Tuesday April 08, 2014 @01:36PM (#7554831)
You find this is an argument you can't easliy dismiss? David Einhorn is personally worth $1.25 billion and Bill Ackman is worth a similar amount and you think that they're going to pack it in over an HFT making it slightly more difficult to place an order? The rise of HFT hasn't stopped Bill Ackman from making huge bets on companies like Herbalife and JC Penny. I won't even get into the fact that he probably paid less to execute that large order than he would have in the previous pit trader environment.
Re:A Fervent Defense of Front-running HFTs by harryh on Monday April 07, 2014 @02:44PM (#7548436)
I think the counter-artument to jalopy's point is to compare the relative degree of investment by "informed traders" vs "efficiency providers" (market makers, HFTers, etc). I think you'll find that investment by the former vastly outweighs the latter indicating that investment in efficiency providers is very unlikely to be too high.
Re:A Fervent Defense of Front-running HFTs by dllthomas on Tuesday April 08, 2014 @07:49PM (#7556807)
Why should we expect the investment in the two to have any relation to each other?
Re:A Fervent Defense of Front-running HFTs by klochner on Monday April 07, 2014 @11:01AM (#7546825)
If we're all going to cite Vanguard, we should at least get the quote right:

There are literally hundreds of strategies that are high-frequency trading, ranging all the way from those that really perform much of a market-making and liquidity-providing function to perhaps some on the opposite end of the spectrum, where they are abusive and trying to manipulate the market, " he said.

Obviously, we need to get rid of those types of high-frequency traders, but I think the bulk of them are creating liquidity and reducing spreads for us, which has dramatically reduced costs.

Re:A Fervent Defense of Front-running HFTs by crdoconnor on Monday April 07, 2014 @11:45AM (#7547155)
They said the same thing about the mortgage market abuses - "Oh, it's just a few bad apples."

No. No it fucking isn't. Furthermore, letting the bad behavior go unpunished means the 'good' behavior gets driven out: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gresham%27s_law

"Good" HFT strategies are nowadays obvious by one very salient fact: they're not very profitable. Most market making now, for instance, is simply cover - noise trading, basically - designed to disguise the real bad behavior (that the OP conveniently states is just 'very rare'... heh).

HFTs aren't dumb. They know that any regulator or prosecutor will find it very hard to dig through the trading data and discern evidence of illegal behavior from individual trades.

Re:A Fervent Defense of Front-running HFTs by jalopy on Monday April 07, 2014 @11:09AM (#7546894)
Yes, but Greenlight Partners (Einhorn's fund) is a Limited Partnership that can include Pensions, school endowments, etc, in addition to "other rich people".

Vanguard's CIO (Gus Sauter) has mentioned in a CNBC interview (see http://www.cnbc.com/id/49434073) that the liquidity providing aspects of HFT tech are valuable - ie, the tools that help the real market makers fill orders on the other side. In the same breath he says the abusive practices (predatory trading) need to be reigned in.

Chris Stucchio's post seems to be defending the "predatory" side of HFT's as "spreading around" the information advantage conferred by hard work and due diligence into the workings of a company.

I'm refuting that by describing the actual effort that goes into attaining the information advantage obtained by Einhorn, Ackman, etc he describes and contrasting it with the effort involved in HFT predatory trading.

Which effort is more important and should be rewarded?

Re:A Fervent Defense of Front-running HFTs by hundt on Monday April 07, 2014 @11:32AM (#7547064)
Do you deny the article's claim that the predatory trading is part of what enables them to keep the spread low? Or do you think it would be worth the bigger spread (and the associated costs to retail investors) to better reward the big investors?