Auction theory is all about achieving that for simple, single round auctions. Why not redesign the stock market in a similar way as well? I suppose it could make for a nice PhD thesis (or several).
I don't see why this is so. If I have decided through some analysis that I am going to sell X shares at some date, why shouldn't that information be private? Front-running my behavior is essentially front-running my analysis. It would be unethical to hack my computer and read my analysis for yourself, so how is analyzing my behavior to get at that same information any different?
Why is the market entitled to knowledge that I'm currently in the process of making a big order? This knowledge being disseminated clearly doesn't benefit me. Should I not be entitled to the sole benefit of my reasoning in deciding to make a big order? Furthermore, how does this knowledge being disseminated mid-order rather than after the full order has completed benefit the market as a whole?
Your knowledge that you're placing an order of size X, and why you're placing an order of size X, is always going to be more precise than what's gleaned from observing your behavior, and thus you'll still have an advantage.
"Furthermore, how does this knowledge being disseminated mid-order rather than after the full order has completed benefit the market as a whole?"
For a large enough order in a sufficiently illiquid market, "after the full order has completed" could be days later. More things being priced in means more accurate prices, and that seems to be of some benefit to "the market as a whole." Though to be sure, the longer time frame isn't terribly relevant to the "predatory traders" across exchanges that Chris had been discussing.
Edited to add: Also, the market doesn't learn anything about you in particular - orders are anonymous. What we learn directly is "a trade happened for X lots at $Y", along with possibly which side was the aggressor (depending on the exchange).
Suppose we had no weather forecasts and meteorologists hoarded the information. And suppose store owners could only adjust prices each morning. Before a hurricane, meteorologists could buy up every last emergency supply within an afternoon from the stores and then sell them the next day after the hurricane at 10 times the original price. Is that fair?
For your meteorology example, if such information didn't have life or death consequences, I might call it fair. But the contexts of the two scenarios are different. The stock market is inherently a bet on future prices, and so using information obtained by yourself through your own efforts cannot be seen as unfair--it is an expected property of the system. Using HFT techniques to profit off of frontrunning your demand is unfair. The "market" for items needed for survival isn't analogous.
On the other hand, I can imagine there being a trivial limit as far as the wider economy is concerned, but still eliminating the benefit that colocation gives HFT firms. Do you disagree?
They think that HFT makes them materially worse off when it, in fact, does the exact opposite. We should just cave to that misconception?
Misconceptions should certainly be eliminated, but the fact that HFT firms require colocation does not pass the smell test of fairness. No amount of explanations can eliminate that.