News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How many people does it take to colonize another star sys... by rbanffy on Monday April 07, 2014 @10:54AM (#7546779)
First of all, we need better engines. We need better engines and better probes to be able to investigate candidate systems up close. We won't send humans before we have thoroughly evaluated the environment and ensured it's, if not safe, habitable. It's OK if they take centuries to arrive, but it would be really great if they didn't. They could also be accelerated and decelerated at much more than 1G, something we would prefer not to do with a live payload.

Second, we need better engines, better robots and better manufacturing technology. Once the right planet is found, we'll send supplies and robots that can build the colony mostly from local resources. Hopefully, all that can withstand much greater accelerations than humans would.

Only then we can send humans, with human-rated engines (we can't do much more than 1G for any significant part of the trip) and a complete habitat that can sustain the population for the duration of the trip (as seen from the passengers - relativistics may apply, depending on our progress with the all-important engine thing)

So, before we have better engines (and get rid of the bureaucratic problems with nuclear reactors in space), it's really a waste of time to think about how large the crew should be. We can have that data if we build marginally better engines (yes, they are key) and colonize other planetary surfaces and asteroids. Eventually, some populations may opt to isolate themselves.

Also, don't forget we may end up learning a lot about genetics well before we can build a relativistic engine. It's perfectly reasonable to imagine we could reintroduce (or introduce, or remove) any genetic trait we want in the population at any time we need to.

Re:How many people does it take to colonize another star sys... by dm2 on Monday April 07, 2014 @11:12AM (#7546913)
250,000 kph isn't fast enough for you? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helios_probes

DARPA and NASA are working on it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hundred-Year_Starship

What's needed is either a faster-than-light drive or the ability to cryogenically freeze people and bring them back once the spacecraft arrives. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faster-than-light and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcubierre_drive

If we can't bend space-time (using something like a worm-hole) or travel faster than light then there will never be any communication between the 2 civilizations.

Wouldn't it be much easier to just mine the planets we have already and build artificial planets or massive space structures out of existing planets and resources within our own solar system? Yes, the sun will eventually burn out but that's not an issue that our generation will face more than likely.

Where should we go? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nearest_terrestrial_exo...

Re:How many people does it take to colonize another star sys... by ufmace on Monday April 07, 2014 @11:44AM (#7547149)
250K kph is nowhere near fast enough, by several orders of magnitude. That gives us a 4k year journey to the nearest star system, which AFAIK is not thought to have any habitable planets.

And that's a tiny probe, close in to the sun. Leaving the solar system with that kind of velocity is a whole different problem. Voyager 1 is leaving the system, doing about 17 kph, reportedly. As far as I know, we don't have anything right now that can do much better than that.

According to everything I've read, sending anything at all out of the solar system at a high enough velocity to get to another star system is way beyond any kind of engine technology we even have on the drawing board. We could probably build a fission engine if we really wanted to, but even that's still orders of magnitude less than we need. Much less propelling an actual starship, meant to contain hundreds or thousands of humans and keep them alive and happy for the journey, at those speeds.

I do believe that we'll do it someday, but it's going to require propulsion technology that we can only imagine right now. Anything like FTL or wormholes or whatever is pure hand-wavyium at this point.

Re:How many people does it take to colonize another star sys... by dm2 on Monday April 07, 2014 @11:54AM (#7547219)
Voyager 1 is traveling at about 57,000 kph. http://solarsystem.nasa.gov/missions/profile.cfm?MCode=Voyag...

The 250k being fast enough remark was just a joke.

Yeah, space is inconceivably massive, that's why my main recommendation was that we focus on staying in our solar system for now. Autonomous robots can mine and build huge structures in space for us to expand to, or I guess we could build them on Mars, either way.

Many NASA scientists don't think that a warp drive is impossible http://www.space.com/17628-warp-drive-possible-interstellar-...

http://www.space.com/9882-warp-drives-wormholes.html

We can make antimatter, we can see trillions of miles away, we can talk to people on the other side of the planet instantly, we have computers that can simulate nuclear weapons, we have nuclear weapons, we can connect and talk to the human brain, and we can even theorize with pretty good certainty what happened to start the universe, a warp-drive or worm-hole isn't completely impossible in the near future.

Humans are not too far off from becoming gods. We can create life, we can put life on other planets, we can even improve ourselves by fusing with machines, shits crazy these days. [0]

Re:How many people does it take to colonize another star sys... by ufmace on Monday April 07, 2014 @12:10PM (#7547332)
That site is awfully vague about exactly when it was travelling at that speed. Every link I can find says that the speed of Voyager 1 right now, having left the solar system, is 17kph. It was travelling faster earlier, but getting away from the sun eats up velocity.

That is an interesting link about Alcubierre drive work, but as far as I know, we still don't have any idea how to get the exotic matter required for it.

Re:How many people does it take to colonize another star sys... by dm2 on Monday April 07, 2014 @12:15PM (#7547379)
17 km per SECOND, not hour, if any site says hour then it's wrong.

Here is Voyager 1 and 2s official website, you can see the distance being updated live, you'll notice that it increases very fast. http://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/

Make sure you are looking at distance from the sun, not Earth, the earth travels faster than Voyager 1 so sometimes it will actually be getting closer to earth.

We do know how to create antimatter, just not how to create amounts large enough to be used (the LHC generates it I think). I'm not optimistic about traveling faster than light anytime soon, but it isn't 100% out of the question.

And if an alien civilization captures one of our spacecraft: http://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/spacecraft/goldenrec_more.html

Re:How many people does it take to colonize another star sys... by ufmace on Monday April 07, 2014 @11:23PM (#7551268)
Ah, looks like I misread things. 17kps makes a lot more sense - 17kph is like bicycle speed.

We can create anti-matter all right, but AFAIK, that isn't the exotic matter required by an Alcubierre drive. Anti-matter could in theory be used to create the most efficient rocket drive possible, but apparently even that isn't all that great. According to this http://www.nasa.gov/centers/glenn/images/content/84509main_w... sobering chart, even a theoretical anti-matter rocket would require 1 million kg of propellant to send a small capsule past the Centauri cluster in 900 years, without counting stopping. Going back to chemical rockets, there is apparently not enough mass in the entire universe for that rather underwhelming plan!

I don't know that FTL is out of the question, but apparently it is impossible to have it without time travel. I'm not looking for any of that to happen tomorrow, and I don't think anybody alive now has a clue when anything like that might be ruled in or out for sure, but with the right theoretical breakthrough, a lot of interesting stuff could potentially happen very fast.

Re:How many people does it take to colonize another star sys... by rbanffy on Monday April 07, 2014 @11:21AM (#7546973)
> 250,000 kph isn't fast enough for you?

No. 250K kps would be more adequate. Faster == better (but we'll need good ablation shields).

> What's needed is either a faster-than-light drive or the ability to cryogenically freeze people

If you manage to get close to the speed of light, you will, from the crew's perspective, be FTL without inventing new physics. Freezing the crew is also an option, but keeping everything going for very long periods of time is challenging in itself.

> there will never be any communication between the 2 civilizations,

We still have radio. No way to phone your friends, but, still communicate, share news, share knowledge etc.