News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Game of Thrones: why hasn’t Westeros had an industrial re... by JoeAltmaier on Sunday April 06, 2014 @10:50AM (#7541115)
Just a coincidence the history of feudal systems is the history of sadists tormenting the people they lord it over? Its all fine and good as long as you are one of the people with marriages and land bonds to barter. But the vast majority of people called it serfdom and died young.
Re:Game of Thrones: why hasn’t Westeros had an industrial re... by barry-cotter on Sunday April 06, 2014 @11:13AM (#7541197)
The wealth produced by capitalism that allows rising standards of living is a historical aberration. For nearly all of human history Malthusianism was correct and most people lived on the brink of starvation.

Feudalism was no different from any other pre-industrial social structure, a parasitic rentier class taxed the peasantry to support their lifestyles. This was true from the god kings of Sumer, Mycenae and Mexico, the cultured, civilized, literate empires of China and Rome and the warlord kingdoms of Europe and India.

Most of human history was a boot stomping on a human face and if we're not very lucky this Dteamtime will end too.

[deleted]
Re:Game of Thrones: why hasn’t Westeros had an industrial re... by johnchristopher on Sunday April 06, 2014 @11:30AM (#7541256)
Parent wrote it was an historical aberration. He didn't write it was an accident.
Re:Game of Thrones: why hasn’t Westeros had an industrial re... by pron on Sunday April 06, 2014 @11:25AM (#7541239)
Feudalism is terrible for the people (well, at least more than capitalism), and I'm not suggesting otherwise (in fact, I was warning against inadvertently going back to feudalism by trying to build a "trust-less" economy). But feudalism wasn't absurd, either. It was very logical.

In fact, most systems where power is concentrated in the hands of the few, while the majority is exploited by the powerful make more sense. It is the crowning achievement of the West that we've been able to slowly and excruciatingly build large democracies based on trust in the system. While (very) far from perfect, these democracies are closer to the humanist ideal than any other system in human history.

Re:Game of Thrones: why hasn’t Westeros had an industrial re... by maxerickson on Sunday April 06, 2014 @12:44PM (#7541498)
It's easy to read In fact, it makes much more sense than capitalism and think you are talking about it being a desirable situation.

(just because much of what "makes sense" about capitalism is the situation it puts the people in, especially modern regulated markets, as opposed to the worst examples of capitalism)

Re:Game of Thrones: why hasn’t Westeros had an industrial re... by HarryHirsch on Sunday April 06, 2014 @12:04PM (#7541376)
There were several factors playing in favour of the serfs. First, there was competition between the feudal lords, if one neglected his responsibilities too much and treated his subjects to harshly they could flee and find themselves another patron. What prevented a Silicon Valley wage cartel type race to the bottom was the emergence of cities and a merchant class entirely outside the feudal system. A serf who settled in a city had no master at all. The story of the Middle Ages is the struggle between the feudal system and the forces outside it, first the church, then the cities.

Also, the church launched a peace movement, just because someone had to keep up the public peace; in 9th century Europe warlordism had spiraled out of control. Ultimately, they were successful in restricting private war between the nobility and mitigating the impact on the general population.

Living conditions for the peasantry in the Middle Ages could have been worse. They didn't have cars and flatscreens, fridges and washing machines, but they had more holidays than the American worker today. And no back-breaking commute.

Re:Game of Thrones: why hasn’t Westeros had an industrial re... by icegreentea on Sunday April 06, 2014 @11:08AM (#7541170)
You're claim has minimal basis in history. The number of sadists tormenting their serfs is surely non-zero, but also not systemic. For one thing, lords DEPEND on their serfs for their well being. Their serfs economic output is crucial.
Re:Game of Thrones: why hasn’t Westeros had an industrial re... by johnchristopher on Sunday April 06, 2014 @11:27AM (#7541245)
Just like slave merchants and slave masters depend on their slaves for their well being.

Regarding the minimal basis in history: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serfdom#Rights_of_serfdom http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Grand_Knout.gif Punishment with a knout. Whipping was a common punishment for Russian serfs.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serfdom#Slaves http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_1956_Supplementa...

Re:Game of Thrones: why hasn’t Westeros had an industrial re... by malkia on Sunday April 06, 2014 @11:45AM (#7541310)
Not directly part of any other feudal system, but Ottoman's empire has established the order of jannisaries by taking young male boys from the enslaved nation - these were trained to be the most ferocious fighters, and even the sultan had to comply occasionally with their demands.

Hardly a thing you can see in an capitalistic system.

Re:Game of Thrones: why hasn’t Westeros had an industrial re... by walshemj on Sunday April 06, 2014 @12:21PM (#7541419)
No that is the common mistake of employing mercenarys and finding out to late that have taken over as the Indian Princes found to their cost when they got to British and french to fight for them.

Then problems the Roman empire had with the Praetorians deciding who was to be emperor is a related problem

Re:Game of Thrones: why hasn’t Westeros had an industrial re... by JoeAltmaier on Sunday April 06, 2014 @11:24AM (#7541236)
Yeah like historical omnipotent despots cared about their cattle or were smart modern people who understood economics.

Every storey about feudalism is about the sadism. Why? Because its exciting I'm sure, but also because it was an absolutely common theme?