Except that the HDD manufacturers are going to keep doing what they've been, and it'll just create more confusion among consumers. "What's the conversion factor between GB and GiB?"
> Even worse, if you created a 300 gibibyte drive to compete with the 300 gigabyte drive, consumers would probably not realise that the 300 gibibyte drive is bigger
One manufacturer could just start using phrases like "300 REAL gigabytes!" and market it aggressively. "7% more storage than the competition! Finally a drive that stores the amount you paid for!"
As for why the -bi- binary prefices haven't caught on, I think one of the biggest obstacles is that they just sound hilariously stupid...
Ironically, my spell checker shows a little red squiggly under gibibyte. Even the developers don't believe it's a real word.
They're really not. SI still doesn't define any units relating to information quantity, so BIPM isn't relevant. This is one issue where an appeal to authority really doesn't fly. The relevant authorities (IEC, ISO, IEEE, JEDEC, etc.) didn't try to address the ambiguity until the late 90's, after it had spread into the general population.
It's not a mistake. In a living language, weight of usage trumps prescriptivism.
> However, in common usage we now have the pretty awful scenario where, if a person says "a megabyte", the actual number of bytes they're talking about can change depending on where the data is stored! A megabyte of RAM is not a megabyte of hard disk space.
That's not correct. A megabyte of RAM and a megabyte of HD are both 1,048,576 bytes, one megabyte. Again, usage trumps prescriptivism.
I agree that the hard-drive-manufacturer thing is not a "conspiracy;" it's simple false advertising that slips through the cracks of the law because of, again, a foolish belief in prescriptivism on the part of the enforcers.
If ram manufacturers do not want to advertise in gib but on gb, use thecorrect number. 0.987 or whatever gb instead of 1gb.
I can't sell liquor in 750ml bottles and advertise as 1L "just because i like rounding L instead of mL"
Mistakenly? How? The new terms with the "bibis" in them were invented because of the misuse of the original terms by storage vendors.
300GB hardrive becomes 300 10^9 bytes or 3 10^10. 32GB or memory becomes 32 2^30, or 2^35.
No ambiguity at all, and if you're spending hundreds of dollars for hardware, you should at least be able to grasp exponentiation.
However, in common usage we now have the pretty awful scenario where, if a person says "a megabyte", the actual number of bytes they're talking about can change depending on where the data is stored! A megabyte of RAM is not a megabyte of hard disk space. The solution would be to standardise on binary prefixes, since we pretty much have to talk about RAM that way, and a consistent measurement across different media is eminently sensible.
The "hard drive maker conspiracy" story is driven by the fact that manufacturers have no real incentive to switch to binary prefixes, because that would make their drives look "smaller". Do you want the 300 gigabyte drive or the 279.4 gibibyte drive? Aside from the fact that hardly anyone knows that a gibibyte is, in the absence of any more information the larger number is probably better. Even worse, if you created a 300 gibibyte drive to compete with the 300 gigabyte drive, consumers would probably not realise that the 300 gibibyte drive is bigger. It's not exactly a conspiracy, but it is a suboptimal arrangement that results from the manufacturers' incentives.