They used to have factory jobs. These have been automated.
Agriculture is increasingly automated.
We are finding ways to build our systems around fewer and fewer people. More capable people are fighting further down the food chain.
Do we just throw people who can't adapt on disability? That's what we did for the group below them, after all. (Who themselves, mind you, we're once capable of being functional members of society, even if they needed help and we're often exploited.)
These people will not suddenly be able to get jobs in IT.
Now, I'm not saying that automation is bad, but I am saying we have a structural unemployment situation on our hands and we are going to have to figure out something.
The whole point of technology is to increase production output. To do more with less.
This might open up new areas but it doesn't follow at all either. And unless you can point to something like the semiconductor revolution it's hard to see what you are referring to.
Job A gets replaced by Automation 1.0. Automation 1.0 required the labor of Jobs B, C, and D to become a reality. Now, not only can Jobs B, C, and D become greatly automated but Automation A is going to eventually lead to Automation 2.0 which led to Jobs E, F, and G being created. Within one generation of the death of Job A, six other jobs were created.
You're arguing that specialization isn't opened up but someone specialized in something enough (robotics, AI, mechanical engineering, chemical engineering, something) to lead to the automation in the first place.
You could have jobs for everyone if you just gave them 50 cent an hour so no that is not question as it's missing the point.
I find the continued apologetic nature of your and some others argument amazing. Technology does not create more jobs than it destroys it help create new markets.
But at the same time it removes jobs from the middle class and leaves only either high tech jobs or Wallmart like jobs in the US (and europe)
If you think that is a sustainable model and proves that the market works just fine I think you are mistaken.
What you have seen is new markets getting liberalized and that made it look like technology would just open up new industries that everyone could get into. In reality that is not the case.
It's all part of a spectrum where specific jobs die but "jobs for people to have" more or less stay the same, if they don't actually increase.
Those that are still around outside the Wallstreet/Tech scene are becoming less and less valuable wallmart being a great example.
Everything else is just a poor attempt to rationalize our way out of that reality.
We teach people to go to school and to get a job and to hold onto that job for as long as possible. That used to be playing it safe but it's playing it pretty not safe these days.
If these opportunities don't exist, it's not the death of the job who is to blame. It's the system that failed to provide for opportunities when the job dies (as it is likely to do).
You are hanging on to some unrealistic notion of it's just a matter of changing your skill-set. Many of these people can't.
I agree that a low-skilled worker is at a disadvantage, but assuming that a tech/finance slanted world offers no low-skilled jobs seems incorrect to me.