Re:Torn and weary (on Brendan Eich and Mozilla)
by Fice on Saturday April 05, 2014 @09:26AM
(#7536997)
Being in opposition to same-sex marriage does not make one a homophobe (even some gays are against it). If Eich did not express any aversion or hatred towards homosexuals, it is not justified to label him as a homophobe.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Torn and weary (on Brendan Eich and Mozilla)
by tomelders on Saturday April 05, 2014 @10:25AM
(#7537154)
Some black people are racist towards black people. They're a minority though, so we don't let it muddy our definition of what racism means because that wouldn't be productive.
The same holds true here. Homophobic is as homophobic does.
Re:Torn and weary (on Brendan Eich and Mozilla)
by Fice on Saturday April 05, 2014 @10:47AM
(#7537208)
Did I say anything about homosexuals who are also homophobes? My point is that being against same-sex marriage is not necessarily homophobic.
Re:Torn and weary (on Brendan Eich and Mozilla)
by tomelders on Saturday April 05, 2014 @12:57PM
(#7537594)
So what does this sentence mean then?
Being in opposition to same-sex marriage does not make one a homophobe (even some gays are against it).
What's does the "even some gays are against it" mean?
Re:Torn and weary (on Brendan Eich and Mozilla)
by Fice on Saturday April 05, 2014 @01:20PM
(#7537680)
Even some gays are against same-sex marriage. And that does not mean that they are also homophobes.
Re:Torn and weary (on Brendan Eich and Mozilla)
by tomelders on Saturday April 05, 2014 @02:50PM
(#7538017)
Are you saying that being opposed to SSM can't be homophobic because some gays are also opposed to SSM?
Re:Torn and weary (on Brendan Eich and Mozilla)
by Fice on Sunday April 06, 2014 @02:25PM
(#7541959)
That remark (which I put in brackets because it was not integral to my main argument) was meant to hint that even within LGBT community there are different positions on SSM.
A position against SSM does not imply homophobia because it is not necessarily based on hatred or aversion towards homosexuals. For instance, there is no justification in calling Eich a homophobe.
What bothers me is a tendency of LGBT activists to put a homophobe label on everyone with an opinion they do not like. That is a witch hunt.