News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Corporate Tax Rate Is 2nd Highest in Industrialized ... by eli on Monday August 10, 2009 @02:17PM (#753611)
OK, we can debate different ways of averaging and whatnot, but the effective tax rate is the the thing we're debating. I think most people would agree that it is more relevant how much you actually paid in taxes last year than in how much you could have paid had it not been for various deductions and credits.

And, surely you're aware that the "35% corporate tax rate" number is a bit of a statistical creation as well? We have a progressive tax code in the US, so small businesses that make less money are taxed at a lower rate. In no way is it accurate to argue that entrepreneurs making under $100k pay 35% federal income tax -- even if we ignore deductions, credits, and everything else.

Indeed, according to the Small Business Administration, sole proprietorships -- i.e. the mom & pops -- faced the lowest effective tax rate of any group last year: 13.3%. I'm not a statistician, but I don't think it's just the Tycos of the world skewing the stats.

Re:U.S. Corporate Tax Rate Is 2nd Highest in Industrialized ... by DanielBMarkham on Monday August 10, 2009 @02:32PM (#753645)
But you see the point, right? The discussion begins with the question of legal tax rate on startups and corps. When you redefine the terms such that we're talking about some statistical artifact, you're basically saying the tax system is too complex to talk about it terms of what it actually says. Which is basically saying that discussion on the effects of tax rates can't take place at all because there isn't such a thing as a "tax rate"

I can't argue with the fact that the tax code is so complex as to make discussion useless, but I would like to point out that discussion has to take place around something. And I wouldn't pick average dollars paid as that something -- seems like a silly number.

Where do we go from here? A detailed discussion on survey methodology? Cherry-picking authoritative sources? A discussion about how early-stage businesses lose a lot of money? Or how income can be deferred using various accounting techniques?

But you see, the meme has accomplished its goal: we are no longer talking about what the law says about what corporations should pay, which is the only high-level, simple concept that we have a chance to reach some conclusions about. After this its all just down-in-the-weeds, wonkish stuff.

So no thanks.