Apps enabling multiple scanners - again assumes multiple smartphone ownership in the house in order for everyone to use it vs just having a single dedicated scanner that (as Amazon suggests in their site) hangs on your refrigerator.
I'm not even sure the average consumer is sufficiently trained yet about opening apps. I heard a segment on NPR recently where multiple callers (and the host) referred to a company's mobile-optimized website as an "app", many normal people don't really know what an app really is. I'll dig out the Pew Research study on mobile phones that said something like 20% of smartphone owners don't install any apps on their phones beyond those that came with the device (perhaps because they're fuzzy on the concept).
UPDATE: http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/tech/news/story/2012-01-30/sm... - 17% of smartphone owners don't use any apps at all according to Pew.
I think people who think their phone can replace a dedicated barcode scanner should be forced to stand in a busy super market where all the checkout counters are forced to use an app to scan everything.
Dedicated devises definitely have their uses, and this one is one of them.
2) If you're cooking and your hands are occupied/covered, you're going to have a hard time using a phone with your hands. Phones aren't typically waterproof, and touchscreens don't typically work well with water on them.
3) If you use a screen lock on your phone, any app is immediately inconvenient given #2
This device seems to be designed specifically for the job, and has a low per-use setup cost.
Not to mention the credential waltz you'd have to do in a hypothetical app, in a home of more than 1 person/device, but served by 1 amazon fresh on a single amazon account. [1]
Or 1 person/device who travels between multiple places that are each potentially served by their own Amazon Fresh accounts. [2]
It makes much more sense to just strap one of these to the door of the refrigerator/pantry that it stocks.
[1] Entering/maintaining your amazon credentials on N devices, each having potentially-separate amazon credentials for other services. Good luck keeping that straight.
[2] Home, Work, Weekend Non-profit, Dorm, Family Cabin, etc. A college kid with divorced parents would be a nightmare usability scenario.
I'd argue though remembering where you put this thing, or "oh hey the wifi password got changed why isn't the food scanner working?" adds lots more complexity than hitting an app icon. The app route also enables you to have multiple scanners - since the target audience of such a product is probably already heavy on tech, and most probably have multiple cell phones.
I guess that last line might be the issue. It isn't really a cell phone, it is a capacitive touch computer with a microphone and speaker, but that is something we haven't yet conveyed well.