Re:Google Wave is the new X-Windows
by cpr on Monday August 10, 2009 @01:05PM
(#753428)
One critical question is whether Google will successfully define the Wave client/server (GWT-based) protocol in an open fashion, or at least open enough that people can implement their own.
Otherwise, the whole thing will be dependent on the quality of their client/server, and people will still be locked into a single implementation.
And, the other issue is just how extensible their data model can be, for other clients to do more than just their simplistic pidgin-HTML document rendering model. I.e., can another client/server pair use a more sophisticated document model but still have the document maintained by other implementations? (Not talking about robots or gadgets here, but a more fundamental question of document extensibility.
On these questions (and others) hang the whole general utility of the collaborative document editing facility.
Otherwise, the whole thing will be dependent on the quality of their client/server, and people will still be locked into a single implementation.
And, the other issue is just how extensible their data model can be, for other clients to do more than just their simplistic pidgin-HTML document rendering model. I.e., can another client/server pair use a more sophisticated document model but still have the document maintained by other implementations? (Not talking about robots or gadgets here, but a more fundamental question of document extensibility.
On these questions (and others) hang the whole general utility of the collaborative document editing facility.