News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by briantakita on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:17PM (#7534048)
> So Eich was in a 17 percent minority relative to the top companies in Silicon Valley.

Let's find all the heretics and burn them! j/k

I'm glad that we are beginning to have a rational discussion about the implications of internet mob justice. I hope it continues.

Please refrain from flagging rational points of view that you don't agree with. That's called censorship.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by 6cxs2hd6 on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:50PM (#7534282)
Once upon a time, OKCupid had amazing blog posts with fascinating analyses of their data.

The blog posts stopped. Match.com acquired them. And their data-centric roots seemed to have eroded badly.

The message they put up -- "If individuals like Mr. Eich had their way, then roughly eight percent of the relationships we’ve worked so hard to bring about would be illegal." [^1] -- was pretty sloppy hyperbole. As if 100% of the 8% were going to get married. As if OKCupid were marriage-oriented like Eharmony.

Although a mob has many members, OKCupid is the company that chose to crank this into a higher gear, and volunteer to be Conseja de la Suprema y General Inquisición. [^2]

Marriage equality is right. Purges are wrong. Shamers should be ashamed.

[1]: http://arstechnica.com/business/2014/04/okcupid-to-firefox-u...

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_Inquisition#Compositio...

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by scintill76 on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:59PM (#7534339)
Anyone else want to find out if OKCupid uses any Intel products, and if so, start harassing them over it? Since the data shows Intel employees had pretty strong support for Prop 8.

I feel kind of guilty about this, as it feels like fighting fire with fire, but I would hope it would illustrate that this sort of witch hunting and "six degrees of separation" will lead to absolutely stupid results if applied to the utmost degree.

P.S. Not to mention they surely use Javascript, another technology tainted by Mr. Eich himself. They harass users of "his" browser, but don't seem to see an issue with their own use of another of his projects.

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by sliverstorm on Friday April 04, 2014 @05:31PM (#7534531)
Even if they don't use any Intel products, I'm positive they use software that was developed on Intel products.

My pitchfork is itching for some action.

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by 6cxs2hd6 on Saturday April 05, 2014 @10:22AM (#7537144)
I'm conflicted. "Two wrongs don't make a right". So yes maybe the Match CEO donated to similar causes in Utah, but do we really want to go down that road? I don't.

What I would like to see happen -- not vindictively, but out of a sense of basic fairness and justice -- is a resignation at OKCupid. Also resignations from Mozilla board members, such as the chair, and whoever was on the executive search committee. The resignations would be not due to political beliefs, but for very poor judgement and lack for competence.

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by vertex-four on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:40PM (#7534207)
The question is, exactly which behaviours would you suggest we not engage in? Should we not use our right of freedom of speech to criticise others? Should we not use our right of freedom of association to choose not to associate with people and organisations which do not support our moral beliefs, and what we see to be our human rights?

The only thing I can think of is that Mozilla are to blame for firing him, except that Mozilla has a (limited) freedom to choose their employees. As far as I can tell, even in the UK, where we have rather far-reaching employment discrimination law, companies have the right to fire people for political actions, although not for pure philosophical beliefs[0] or being a member of a political party. I could be wrong there, however.

So the question is, exactly who acted in the wrong and exactly how, in a way which does not lead to a slippery slope?

[0] http://www.pureemploymentlaw.co.uk/2011/05/19/what-is-a-phil...

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by kenjackson on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:25PM (#7534092)
Unlike most other politicized topics, I don't think there is a rational position on opposing gay marriage in the US. At least none I have heard yet.
Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by danudey on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:37PM (#7534179)
This is an important point that I've been bringing up whenever someone tries to discuss this: what reason is there to prevent someone else from getting gay married?

The only reason that I've seen is 'my beliefs say it's not okay, so you're not allowed to do it even if you don't share them'. Which comes across as spite, more than anything. 'I'm going to prevent you from getting married even though it costs me nothing to allow it', and in fact it cost Eich a thousand dollars to try to prevent it.

I can't imagine spending a thousand dollars to prevent someone from doing something they wanted to do if it wasn't going to affect me in any tangible way. That's why Eich seemed like an untrustworthy choice for CEO: this doesn't seem like a rational decision for a person to make.

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by gyardley on Friday April 04, 2014 @05:01PM (#7534353)
I've heard people say something like "it's far too soon to tell what impact if any this rather dramatic change to the traditional definition of marriage will have on society, so perhaps we should take things slow and not rush to implement it everywhere simultaneously."

This seems like a reasonable enough position to me -- although I don't share it because I think the injustice to the individuals affected outweighs any potential drawbacks I can come up with, sometimes the law of unexpected consequences surprises us in interesting ways.

I've also heard people say "judge-made law causes resentment and entrenchment in a minority of the populace and leads to long-term conflicts (see, for instance, Roe vs. Wade). Therefore, while it'd be nice to have gay marriage everywhere simultaneously, we should wait to introduce it in a jurisdiction until we have an electoral majority there."

Again, this seems like a reasonable enough position to me, although not one I personally share.

Brendan Eich would be just fine as CEO in a more civil society where people are capable of separating personal opinions and professional actions. My personal dislike of his 'resignation' comes from a desire to have that (sadly imaginary) society instead of the one we've got. If I can work peaceably with a bunch of left-wing people, y'all should be able to work just fine with Brendan.

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by sliverstorm on Friday April 04, 2014 @05:34PM (#7534541)
This seems like a reasonable enough position to me -- although I don't share it

You have just blown thousands of collective minds. Such a stance is possible?

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by mkr-hn on Saturday April 05, 2014 @07:05AM (#7536675)
Being able to understand how someone arrives at a view while not also holding that view is an important part of being empathetic.
Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by ljoshua on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:58PM (#7534335)
Let me try and suggest an explanation.

In a democracy, you work to make your opinion heard and effective. If you have the opinion, whether based on religious or other grounds, that homosexuality may damage the overall morality of a society, then you would work to protect that society from what you would view as a potential issue. You would also support laws that would be a means to that end--the goal not being to put somebody else down but to uphold it. Therefore a person that holds such beliefs would support enacting a law that prevents something, even if it didn't constrain them in any way.

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by briantakita on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:58PM (#7534332)
Trust in cultural intelligence. The population of people who's only argument is their beliefs will dwindle. It's only a matter of time.

In the mean time, treat them with respect, just as you want to be treated with respect.

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by vezzy-fnord on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:57PM (#7534327)
a) Opposition to all marriage.

b) Insistence on having marriage be concretely defined as "one man and one woman" and potentially introduce similar but differently named unions for non-traditional couples. This actually has some basis, as marriage used to be widely defined as such (even in dictionaries) until the debate of gay marriage led to a shift in terminology.

Those are two that I can name of. Note that I personally belong to argument A. Not that it's a vehement opposition, just a personal view on the futility of it.

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by protomyth on Friday April 04, 2014 @05:10PM (#7534411)
I can tell you the position of some of the churches that funded Prop 8[1]. It has very little to do with the rights of others. It is basically the fear of the chain that goes from: suing a wedding photographer and cake designer who did not want to be involved in a wedding that violated their religious beliefs[2]. The attack on Catholic Family Services and other churches providing adoption services. Next, Catholic Nuns and other church organizations being forced to buy healthcare that provides for abortions. With the thought it will lead to a church being sued to allow a marriage that does not meet their doctrine.

The churches have learned a great deal from the ACLU given its constant suing of any religious display. They know you fight every inch of the way and don't compromise, since your opponents won't. They are fearful of the state forcing doctrine on them. The 1st amendment is very fragile given what has happened to the 4th, 5th

1) once again, I don't believe in state sponsored marriage of any type beyond basic contractual law between 2+ people meeting certain biological conditions (no possible inbreeding). I also have some problems about lack of consideration for the situation of conjoined twins and current rules given our ability to allow them a healthy life will exceed our ability to separate them in vitro.

2) an artist is a different discussion then a restaurant, motel, hospital, etc.

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by bashinator on Friday April 04, 2014 @07:13PM (#7535066)
The thing about the wedding photographer and cake designer who did not want to be involved in a wedding that violated their religious beliefs, is that the United States has already been there on a wide scale. Go back fifty or sixty years, and you'll find vast numbers of businesses that refused to serve non-whites, often for sincerely held religious reasons.
Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by protomyth on Friday April 04, 2014 @08:28PM (#7535381)
I have no dispute on restaurant, motel, hospital, and other public establishments, but wedding photographer and cake designer are artists. What about goldsmiths, painters of portraits, and software developers? Can you be compelled to work? What about priests then? This is the slope that fuels the money.
Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by Crito on Friday April 04, 2014 @10:57PM (#7535794)
You cannot be compelled to work. Hell, you can't even compel a restaurant owner to serve black people.

There is legal recourse when a restaurant owner refuses to serve black people, but forced labor is not on the list of possible outcomes.

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by protomyth on Saturday April 05, 2014 @09:46AM (#7537056)
Once again, I know the history of restaurants and public establishments you down voters[1]. You are wrong about a restaurant since they can be compelled (as it should be since they are a public establishment and licensing takes care of that). We already have a case of forced labor in a photographer which is why the churches are worried about being compelled to perform by the state.

1) don't ever think that it didn't happen to others

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by Crito on Saturday April 05, 2014 @03:59PM (#7538231)
No, they cannot actually be compelled to work.

They can be offered the choice, "Do it, or suffer the legal ramifications.", but if they choose "suffer the legal ramifications" standard legal ramifications are the extent of what happens. You can't actually legally force them to do the work, they can choose to not do the work and accept the consequences instead.

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by protomyth on Saturday April 05, 2014 @04:35PM (#7538348)
First you state untruths about what restaurants are required to do and now you misstate what actually was ruled by the New Mexico Supreme Court on the photographer: http://www.nmcompcomm.us/nmcases/nmsc/slips/SC33,687.pdf

"Accepting the consequences" is a nice way to say the law makes it illegal and you will be punished. So, yes, you can be compelled to do work. In the case of a hospital or restaurant that is a public place and licensed as such, this is a very good thing. Forcing artists (which the ruling acknowledges get no exceptions) is another and leads to the reason why churches and others will spend the money campaigning (see my original post).

I think it is important to understand the law before posting foolishness and twisting the meaning of words.

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by paulhodge on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:39PM (#7534195)
Instead of bloviating you could always look up what the arguments in favor were: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_8_(2008)...

And for any proposed law change, there's always some annoying folks who agree with the overall spirit of the change, but oppose because they disagree with some specific details. Like, maybe the new law doesn't go far enough, or doesn't have the right wording. Or maybe they just object to the process by which it was created or campaigned for.

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by aaronbrethorst on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:51PM (#7534288)
OK, will do:

    Proponents of the constitutional amendment argued that
    exclusively heterosexual marriage was "an essential
    institution of society"
Totally baseless assertion. So was the right to vote only belonging to white male landowners at the end of the 18th century.

    [T]hat leaving the constitution unchanged would "result
    in public schools teaching our kids that gay marriage
    is okay"
In my 13 years of public schooling I don't remember any of my teachers ever discussing marriage.

    [And] that gays "do not have the right to redefine
    marriage for everyone else."
If you don't like gay marriage, you don't have to get gay married. You're more than welcome to get married to a member of the opposite sex, like I—ostensibly—will do at some point.
Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by Karunamon on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:45PM (#7534237)
From your link:

heterosexual marriage was "an essential institution of society", that leaving the constitution unchanged would "result in public schools teaching our kids that gay marriage is okay", and that gays "do not have the right to redefine marriage for everyone else."

Apparently the prop 8 argument is basically a massive appeal to tradition fallacy?

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by bashinator on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:54PM (#7534311)
Let's do look at those arguments you referenced.

> Proponents of the constitutional amendment argued that exclusively heterosexual marriage was "an essential institution of society."

This is not an argument, it's a statement of opinion. I'd be interested in seeing what facts back it.

> that leaving the constitution unchanged would "result in public schools teaching our kids that gay marriage is okay"

This is making the presumption that gay marriage is not okay, which again, is an opinion without any backing facts.

> and that gays "do not have the right to redefine marriage for everyone else."

This is a non-sequitur - gays are not trying to redefine marriage for everyone else. Nothing pertaining to hetero marriage would be changed in the slightest by allowing gays to participate in the institution.

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by hippoman on Saturday April 05, 2014 @02:36AM (#7536194)
There isn't a rational position on opposing marriage between siblings, yet it's still illegal in the US. Of course there are reasons about damage to children, bullying of children, etc but fundamentally people are just repulsed by the idea so they don't want anyone to do it and it's still illegal. Gay marriage is only one of various types of marriage that are unfairly discriminated against. Fortunately gay marriage might now allow a father and son to marry each other, which may help open the minds of the mob.
Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by 001sky on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:29PM (#7534130)
kenjackson 14 hours ago | link | parent |

Anyone with half a brain knew that Obama did not really oppose gay marriage. When he switched views no one was really surprised... At least of those with half a brain.

Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by kenjackson on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:33PM (#7534155)
Can you explain what that is supposed to mean?
Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by snowwrestler on Saturday April 05, 2014 @03:43PM (#7538182)
It's very easy to think that the other side of an issue does not hold a rational position. We use the same brain to hold hold our own opinion, and to evaluate the opinions of others. In situations outside the scientific method there is little way to objectively know which is the "right" or "rational" position.
Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by sliverstorm on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:24PM (#7534087)
No no, it's only censorship if I agree with the message! ;)
Re:How Rare Are Anti-Gay-Marriage Donations in Silicon Valley? by lucian1900 on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:26PM (#7534098)
Finding all the "heretics" sounds good to me. Someone that hateful deserves public shame.