News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:49PM (#7533478)
The NYSE has always required market makers continuously buy and sell the stocks they specialise in. They must do this in all market conditions, even if it means running a loss. In exchange, they get privileged access to order flow information. This is why those seats are valuable. NASDAQ challenged that model by removing the physical trading floor. Instead of humans standing in a pit there were humans sitting behind screens. But in both cases there is an institution guarding access to the market's nerve centres. Barriers to entry were raised and the incumbents protected.

HFT takes the abstraction one step further. Democratised is that access to privileged order flow - anyone who can pay can get it. Lost is the role of a designated market maker - HFTs can pull out when markets get rough. This is a valid debate.

But don't confuse yourself. The order flow privileges being criticised have always accrued to institutional market makers. It is no surprise that those incumbents are the ones driving the present lobby.

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by AndrewBissell on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:59PM (#7533544)
> The NYSE requires designated market makers to buy and sell the securities they specialise in. They must do this even in violent market conditions

This "mandate" tended to break down when tested by actual market panics. Bids dried up in 1987, and histories of the 1929 crash often mention clerks and floor runners who entered stink bids at $0.01 for stocks that had recently traded at $30 or $40, and got filled because the specialists had abandoned their posts.

Whether human or computer, market makers know better than to stand in front of a freight train.

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 04, 2014 @03:07PM (#7533595)
Market makers can declare "self help" in the event of technical difficulty. Exchange rules prohibit declaring self help to avoid adverse market conditions. In practice, self help declarations have a peculiar habit of cropping up in rough markets. Nevertheless, "guarantors of market liquidity" remains a rallying cry for traditional market makers.