News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by tptacek on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:07PM (#7533208)
If HFT GUARANTEES profits, why are the profits to HFTs declining so sharply, and why do HFT firms make such a small fraction of what the buy-side firms make?

Much more discussion here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7531429

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by ajtulloch on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:10PM (#7533230)
I think the somewhat sparse academic research on this topic is quite interesting - "The High-Frequency Trading Arms Race: Frequent Batch: Auctions as a Market Design Response" by Budish et. al at Chicago (http://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/eric.budish/research/HFT-Fre...) is one such paper.

The key results in this paper are that:

- market correlations 'predictably' break down at high-frequency horizons

- these correlation breakdowns create a winner-takes-all speed arms race to exploit these opportunities

- a theoretical model can be built to explain the investment in speed as a function of these opportunities

- this model reduces to the prisoner's dilemma from game theory

- the equilibrium state of this model is an environment higher spreads and thinner markets than is socially optimal (without the arms race).

It's a very interesting and readable paper, peppered with interesting market observations and theoretical insights.

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by 001sky on Friday April 04, 2014 @03:48PM (#7533867)
Along these lines, a note on so-called latency arbitrage:

http://web.eecs.umich.edu/srg/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/ec3...

But in a study last year, University of Michigan professor Michael Wellman and I developed a model across two exchanges. We examined a strategy called latency arbitrage, which utilizes advantages in access and response time to exploit price disparities caused by fragmentation across those dozens of competing venues. HFTs employing latency arbitrage examine current market information to predict immediate price movements, essentially computing the best prices available before the exchange has even had a chance to update its price quote.

What we found may be even scarier than Lewis's book-selling punchline: it's not simply a matter of the HFT crowd taking profits away from regular investors. Predatory strategies like latency arbitrage have the potential to reduce trading gains for all market participants – high-frequency traders and Average Joes alike.

Their solution was to go to periodic call structure.

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by kasey_junk on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:22PM (#7534069)
This is actually a very good paper and I heartily recommend it if you are into wonky market arbitrage.

You don't mention it, but they actually recommend a centralized discrete call market. How is that to be implemented? They don't say and they don't count the additional added cost/risk of adding a centralized monopoly player into the market (in fact they completely ignore transaction fees). We moved away from centralized markets in the first place because those costs were non-trivial.

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by aet on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:19PM (#7534057)
Lets say we go to a call structure. Will there be competitive pressure to go back to a continuous market? For example, lets say you demand all U.S. exchanges go to a call structure. Would there be reason for me to go to London and open up a new continuous market?
Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by 001sky on Friday April 04, 2014 @08:18PM (#7535333)
You're illustrating regulatory arbitrage. The answer to that question is always: it depends. Not helpful, I know.

But IMHO the issue is not so much here understanding all of the -N- ways to regulate the problem. It's helpful in the first instance to have clear articulations of the problem you need to consider. Market micro-structure is like taxes. It's almost impossible to generalize an answer. An "actual answer" will entail a level of detail and laywers fees that is prohibitive to discuss "for fun" =D. We can apply this critique to all of these academic papers too: they are abstractions and model-markets. The actual particulars of any given order routing...etc.

So what is the purpose of this even being posted? It is simply to illustrate how sub-optimal outcomes are possible on a whiteboard. The general takeaway is there is a problem (worsening equilibrium) and a solution (improving one) that relate to tweeking the variables (timing/trade sequencing) discussed upthread. Those are not purely neutral or unrelated to welfare outcomes.

It helps to have someone else spell it out sometimes. Both to save the brain damage of spelling it out in HN comments, and also to provide some fresh voices to the dialogue.

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by wglb on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:26PM (#7533339)
So let's try an experiment to see what happens: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7532584
Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by mayukh on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:24PM (#7533314)
Declining profitabilities caused by increased competition. What market risk are the scalp-style of hft strategies (not all hft's are scalping) taking ? If they can cancel orders at abandon and make pennies if they win the race (against other hft's), but can simply x out of their order if the price doesnt go their way is as close to a riskless profit as it gets.

virtu's prospectus as a case in point. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1592386/000104746914...

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by jarrett on Friday April 04, 2014 @03:02PM (#7533562)
There is still risk. Even if you never lose money on a trade, your firm can lose money. You're paying fixed costs such as colocation. It's conceivable that all your trades are profitable, yet the sum of all those profits is lower than your fixed costs.

That becomes more likely for any given firm as the competition increases. Spreads get smaller; there's more competition for any given trading opportunity. For each firm, that can mean declining profits per trade and declining numbers of trades made. When the product of those two numbers gets too low, you're in the red.

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by foobarqux on Friday April 04, 2014 @03:07PM (#7533600)
Or you can blow up like Knight.
Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by wglb on Friday April 04, 2014 @03:43PM (#7533832)
Knight had test code that got flipped into production.

Worse, they ignored many alarms as the company was sinking.

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by fr0sty on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:23PM (#7534082)
> Knight had test code that got flipped into production.

This is not correct. Read the SEC report on the incident if you have time, it is pretty in depth: http://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin/2013/34-70694.pdf

The short-version is that they re-used a parameter from an old feature and one of the production machines was not updated so the re-used parameter re-activated the old feature instead of the new one. Furthermore, A refactoring of the code had left the old feature on the wrong side of the share accounting code so the system was not keeping track of the orders it was putting out.

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by wglb on Friday April 04, 2014 @06:05PM (#7534727)
Thanks for that.

But still it was not any kind of market or trading risk that blew them up--just a litany of control failures and bad code.

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by lrm242 on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:30PM (#7533359)
Manoj Narang of Tradeworx has stated their average holding time is up to 10 minutes. Is he taking risk?

http://washpost.bloomberg.com/Story?docId=1376-N2CB0F6TTDTQ0...

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by mayukh on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:33PM (#7533382)
'Average' holding times don't help understand the issue. You could have one position that was a long-term bet

edit: I did not imply that none of the hft strategies were taking market risk. The ones that scalp certainly seem to.

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by tptacek on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:43PM (#7533444)
This is the second time you've used the word "scalp", as if all liquidity on the public markets for the last century weren't funded by "scalping".

In the absence of "scalping", trading in stocks works like trading in houses. There are lots of buyers. There are lots of sellers. In the majority of cases, they disagree materially on the correct price. Therefore, it (a) takes forever to enter or exit a position, and (b) often forces people to accept terribly unfavorable pricing.

The "scalp" market makers take is the market price for always having a counterparty willing to trade with you at a price near the true market value of the trading instrument.

If you want the markets to work more like the real estate market, you can do that: place limit orders. The fact that market orders carry a premium price isn't a subtle detail of the market; it's trading 101.

All things being equal, you want the "scalp" to be as thin as possible. The wider the spread, the closer the scalping blade comes to the skull. Liquidity has a price, and investors want that price to be as low as possible.

So now, an exercise for you: at the height of HFT profit-taking, was the price of liquidity (a) lower or (b) higher than it was during the 1990s?

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by dllthomas on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:59PM (#7533541)
Though houses also have the additional complication that they're not (at all) fungible.
Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by aet on Friday April 04, 2014 @03:15PM (#7533658)
Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by wglb on Friday April 04, 2014 @03:45PM (#7533851)
I know of one HFT firm whose hold times, averaged out over a year, came to Zero. This firm accounted for a significant fraction of all stocks traded.
Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by lrm242 on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:37PM (#7534181)
Did Knight take risk?
Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by wglb on Friday April 04, 2014 @06:06PM (#7534736)
I am not referring to Knight.

[Edit] I am referring to another firm; it seems if you are in the trading business, you are taking risk. This certainly has multiple meanings. You can measure risk against a position you hold relative to holding nothing. If you are a Market Maker HFT, then you risk the market collapsing out from under you when you are legally obligated to stay in.

Re:The Idiot's Guide to High Frequency Trading by foobarqux on Friday April 04, 2014 @03:06PM (#7533592)
You can "guarantee" profits but still be revenue constrained.