Re:Contributing to the F# Language, Library and Tools
by gecko on Friday April 04, 2014 @09:15AM
(#7531124)
Lots of them, but two key ones:
You also lose some things, two of which that are most poignant to me:
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Contributing to the F# Language, Library and Tools
by profquail on Friday April 04, 2014 @09:48AM
(#7531325)
Mono's SGen garbage collector is a massive improvement over the older, non-generational GC. SGen still may not be as a good as the GC in the .NET CLR on Windows, but the performance difference is much smaller now (especially since Mono 3.2.x).
Re:Contributing to the F# Language, Library and Tools
by gecko on Friday April 04, 2014 @10:53AM
(#7531734)
Have you tried with F# specifically? Even the old collector generally did fine for C#, but F# tends to allocate a tremendous number of very-short-lived objects, which is where Mono's old GC got unhappy. I actually do fully expect that SGen likely fixes that entirely, but I haven't had a chance to meaningfully benchmark it.
Re:Contributing to the F# Language, Library and Tools
by profquail on Friday April 04, 2014 @05:40PM
(#7534576)
Yes, I have tried it specifically with F#. In fact, I contributed some minor patches to the SGen GC so it'd work correctly on FreeBSD, just so I could run F# on FreeBSD using Mono/SGen. SGen is a significant improvement over the older GC for any program running on Mono, but especially for F# programs.
Re:Contributing to the F# Language, Library and Tools
by girvo on Friday April 04, 2014 @09:30AM
(#7531215)
I've been looking at doing something crazy like building a toy kernel + lisp to sit on top of it for the RPi, and I've been looking at OCamL to do it in. Thoughts, as someone who's used it?
Re:Contributing to the F# Language, Library and Tools
by avsm on Friday April 04, 2014 @12:07PM
(#7532319)
OCaml works great for systems programming (its runtime is orders of magnitude simpler than F# and the CLR). See http://openmirage.org for a bunch of libraries that may be of use to you, such as TCP/IP in OCaml (or https://github.com/mirage)
Re:Contributing to the F# Language, Library and Tools
by girvo on Saturday April 05, 2014 @02:45AM
(#7536207)
Brilliant! Cheers :)
Re:Contributing to the F# Language, Library and Tools
by shadowfox on Friday April 04, 2014 @06:21PM
(#7534819)
Feature-wise you also lose a few more things like OCaml modules and functors (and OCaml style objects, which is not a great loss). You gain integration with .NET (and its classes and objects).
Re:Contributing to the F# Language, Library and Tools
by untothebreach on Friday April 04, 2014 @09:22AM
(#7531164)
Thanks, the multithreading is definitely a compelling reason