Likewise, the more esoteric forms of finance (CDS) and the people who made them and continue to game the system greatly contributed to the recent recession without suffering any of its ill effects.
And furthest down the chain of societal damage are photo sharing sites and chat services, which mostly just waste time and supplant the revenue of film/phone companies.
If you're implying that considering HFT's societal worth is as silly as examining photo sharing services, you're mistaken.
I agree, I think a robust conversation about the pluses and minuses of electronic trading are of value, and there is nothing sacred about electronic trading activities that means they are a natural right. That conversation needs to be an informed one though, and discussions about HFT never are.
"Likewise, the more esoteric forms of finance (CDS) and the people who made them and continue to game the system greatly contributed to the recent recession without suffering any of its ill effects."
This is a point that is most aggrevating about the narrative that Michael Lewis is pushing about HFT. The people being "hurt" in his hypothesis, are in fact the people who create esoteric forms of finance. The big institutions are upset by HFT because it has cut into their profits, not because it is unfair.
"And furthest down the chain of societal damage are photo sharing sites and chat services, which mostly just waste time and supplant the revenue of film/phone companies. If you're implying that considering HFT's societal worth is as silly as examining photo sharing services, you're mistaken."
WhatsApp was sold for 19 billion dollars. That is about exactly what the entire HFT market was worth in it's very best year if you believe very inflated stats.
Yes, this was definitely glossed over in the article. But some of those large investors are things like pension funds, which hold ordinary people's savings. I'm not sure to what extent that trickles down though. Also, what about the flash crashes?
As for flash crashes there are 2 answers to that question 1) they correct so fast that they impact very few people. 2) if exchanges would stop busting trades during crashes the practices that lead to them would stop.
2) Straw man.
3) Yes, while we're at it let's change the subject to photo sharing websites instead. That sounds reasonable.
Edit:
[1] Again referring to the technically legal version of "front running" as used by Michael Lewis where HFT abuse buy/sell orders arriving at different times at the exchanges.
Having a speed advantage over other market participants and using that advantage to pull your quotes on another exchange is not front-running! It's just sensible market-making, of the kind that has been doing on for hundreds of years. It's no better or worse than sending a pigeon over the English Channel in 1815[1], or using the Transatlantic Telegraph to outpace ships in 1866.
Also, shouting "straw man" is not actually an argument.
[0] http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/front_running#English
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nathan_Mayer_Rothschild#Legend
To make an analogy: my boxing coach is obligated to give me good advice and he's a jerk if he doesn't. The other boxer is not being a jerk if he feints and then punches me in the face.
There is little opportunity to front-run in this case since a) no one on ETrade moves large blocks b) ETrade wants to make sure the ELP program is full of benevolent market makers and c) fill rate requirements. You can always opt out of these programs (turn off "smart routing" or something similarly named), but most people don't since they typically reduce your costs.
The question: "does Facebook spying on teenagers to help Abercrombie & Fitch sell them crap they don't need add social value commensurate with how much money they make doing it?" isn't an attempt to change the subject, but rather a glib attempt to criticize the structure of the question. Since when do we judge compensation based on value added to society, and if that's what we do, why don't we apply that approach beyond finance?
It's not a legitimate argument because it can be used to derail any conversion that criticizes one particular aspect of society.
It goes without saying that there are moral questions to be raised about facebook acquisitions and compensation in fields outside of finance. But it's not part of this conversation.
In other words, he disagrees with the premise that compensation need bear some relation to economic value created. Empirically, that's a premise that we as a society reject.
When we have that debate I'd like it to be informed about what does and does not actually happen with HFT and not bogeyman scare stories. I'd also like that debate to consider the pro's and con's of the system it replaced and the unintended consequences of any regulation we introduce.
We apply it in finance for a couple reasons. Securities exchanges are high regulated entities, at least since the Great Depression brought our country to its knees. Ever heard of the SEC, which exists to protect investors? There is no reason for HFT to be allowed at all unless it is creating a net benefit for society. Or said another way, if HFT provides a benefit only for the people doing HFT, and has a negative effect on others, then there's no reason to allow it. (An aside: My understanding is that studies have shown markets to have plenty of liquidity without HFT.)
This is only an issue if your order is large enough to take out the entire liquidity of one of the exchanges. If that is the case, by definition you are not a retail investor, you are an institutional investor and part of the value add you are supposedly adding is your ability to operate in a complex market.
"2) It's a universal truth that people who are better informed are harder to rip off. So that's not very persuasive. You can't reasonably expect regular people to know in which situations they'll be paying a premium for a liquidity service they may not even want."
So informed market participants should subsidize ignorant ones?
"3) It's completely fair to ask ourselves as a society if HFT groups are making a contribution to society that warrants the money they make. And if transparency with regard to HFT trading strategies leads regular people and sophisticated investors to make different decisions, then that means that the lack of transparency worked in favor of HFT. Therefore, it's reasonable to assume much of the HFT profits are just an externality. The decline of HFT is in part because investors are getting wise to the shenanigans."
Agreed. We should also have that discussion around dark pool operators, hedge funds, and investment banks. While we are at it, lets talk about photo sharing websites and internet chat services as well.