It's a complicated issue, but I think the simplified version is: Reduced liquidity results in larger volatility.
Shorting is an easier example to look at: When a stock drops, folks with short positions cover their bets ("I've made enough money off this position, it may be near the maximum I'll make") they buy. Others notice that there is buying interest etc. However, when shorting is banned, those buys do not arrive and you would intuitively expect the stock to drop further before buyers believe there is money to be made. You could witness this dynamic during 2008-9, when the SEC banned shorting of banks.
The trade clearing systems themselves create all the liquidity that anybody needs.
If anything, they insititute a tiny tax on larger trades, such that there is a tiny deadweight loss to the market every time they front-run somebody. It isn't enough to be very noticeable on a single asset, but it is a positive and nonzero amount that is destroyed each time, and that can add up. To what, I have no idea.
Then why are people buying it?
This comment doesn't make any sense?
You also might want to switch to Vanguard. They do a good job and realize that HFTers have dramatically lowered costs for them and their clients: http://www.cnbc.com/id/49434073
HFTs do not see your buy order before it reaches the market and then buy them ahead of you to sell them back to you.
Your understanding of the stock markets and HFT is inaccurate and you are spreading incorrect information.
It has always been the case that a market maker could look at orders coming in and bet that it was the tip of a large order flow and thereby adjust the prices he was offering. It's just that gut instinct, good ole boy networks, and luck have been replaced with network infrastructure, systematic engineering and analytics.
This is a sincere question, because I really do not understand how HFT "creates liquidity" when they are just buying low and selling high.