Re:A group of 3,000 citizens is making better forecasts than...
by AJ007 on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @04:16PM
(#7518649)
I think the only thing to conclude from the article is that normal people can beat CIA analysts. This is similar to the story about monkey stock picking. (near useless FT story url http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/abd15744-9793-11e2-b7ef-00144...)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A group of 3,000 citizens is making better forecasts than...
by nzp on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @08:44PM
(#7520095)
Hm, I wouldn't say normal people, but subpopulations of normal people (i.e. not individuals but groups). It's an important distinction in this case. But it depends on how CIA analysts' estimates are aggregated if at all. In fact it would be extremely interesting if CIA normally got predictions by averaging multiple analysts' estimates. That would mean normal people with open source intel are beating trained analysts with confidential intel! In that case, we could say normal people beat CIA analysts. But to me this article implies analysts' estimates are not taken as averages. Any CIA analysts here to set the record straight? :)