Over the past 8 years, I've taught programming to people from ages 6 to 50, of all genders and cultural backgrounds. Female students have generally related more to my female colleagues, just like black students generally relate more to my black colleagues. Which is perfectly fine, and why you want a diverse set of educators in the first place.
My point being that I don't actually believe that people need to be the same gender (or skin color or etc) to be relatable as role models.
I think making role models less demographically binned would be an important and positive step.
.
"Female students have generally related more to my female colleagues"
Do you have any reason to believe that this isn't because every time they're getting started someone carefully creates that situation, as is being created here?
Measurements are frequently measurements of effects, rather than of causes.
.
"Which is perfectly fine"
How can you be sure that refusing demographic cross pollination by intent is not a negative thing?
It has been proven that our society is full of gender and racial biases, and to fight them we need to accept this fact so we can have a sensible plan of attack. Apparently we can't just make those biases disappear by wishing them away. It is easier to dismantle them by first fighting the symptoms. If you just tell people to ignore their biases, you will ask them to ignore their personal day-to-day experience, and that's asking a lot. It's hard for people to believe one thing if what they see around them goes against that belief. To change beliefs we must first change the experience.
All for what? a social experiment to fight biases with "positive discrimination"? The hope removing half of every possible role model is worth getting a female role model over a male role model?
In the end its the parent that decide and it might be worth if there is already plenty of male role models, so long one is aware of the costs.
I don't. I don't need french onion soup either, but it's sure a nice treat on occasion.
> isolating female students from male teachers
Her current math teacher is male, her science teacher is a woman and former pilot of helicopter gunships. I'm her dad, and I help her with her math and science at home. One of our good friends in the neighborhood is a PhD biostatistician who is the CEO of her own research firm.
But why ask for what's common? Within my social circle, half the guys are engineers. Heck, I can arrange for her to get a trip to SpaceX. I don't need the megaphone of Hacker News to get that. In fact, the mom of my son's best friends (twins) is an environmental engineer. So "female engineer in San Diego" is actually a tractable problem within my social circle.
Finding women in each of the many STEM careers is quite another thing. And for that, I tossed it out to Hacker News. When I post things to Hacker News, I generally don't expect a big response. Most of my posts die in /new. This didn't, which I'm grateful for.
> why carefully structure inequality in?
Because equality is often an unstable equilibrium. So exerting a force opposed to the instantaneous natural tendency may be the right response at any given time. In fact, the system may have to be permanently pre-stressed to change from unstable to stable.
.
"But why ask for what's common?"
I didn't say ask for what's common. I asked why to ask for something uncommon. They're quite different and they aren't the range of possibilities. Another possibility entirely is to just not limit it.
When talking about mentors, "because a mentorship is a many year relationship that can have a significant impact on a person's life, and I'm not sure why you would only search half the space available to you for the best person for the job."
.
"Because equality is often an unstable equilibrium."
Not in the case of human gender.
.
"So exerting a force opposed to the instantaneous natural tendency may be the right response at any given time."
I don't see any instantaneous natural tendency to select for male either, and I'm still looking for a supporting cause for that "may be" which isn't a vague reference to an unstable equilibrium.
I'm not even sure what equilibrium you might mean, unless you mean how many people are in each gender, and expect that to change.
.
"In fact, the system may have to be permanently pre-stressed to change from unstable to stable."
As that stress has been applied, beginning in the late 1970s, the division in gender in technical roles has increased dramatically. Indeed, it appears that since women's mentorship in tech has been steered towards other women, the number of women in tech has dropped dramatically.
It's important to take a look at the data before taking a position on hypotheticals, in case the data suggests exactly the opposite of what the suspicion suggests.
How would you respond if it turned out that giving a child a mentor of the opposite role, meaning they were used to a broader range of gender roles than otherwise, increased diversification? Would that change your mind about the right thing to do?
.
Lastly (and sorry it's out of order, but it's to me the dividing point):
"So "female engineer in San Diego" is actually a tractable problem within my social circle."
It's not clear to me what makes this the problem to solve, yet.
I'm not arguing with you, or saying you're wrong; I don't understand the reaction I'm getting.
I'm just trying to understand why you are cutting away the vast majority of the available mentors.
If there are ninety Xs and ten Ys available, and if Xs and Ys are fundamentally equal quality, but if both groups have individual variation, then it is strongly statistically expected that the best available individual is an X, because of the variation of individuals and the larger sampling pool.
People don't get several mentors.
I don't understand why the choice is in any terms other than finding the single best available individual.
I just want to understand the data driving your choices. I'm not arguing.
Kids are very perceptive. This girl sounds lucky to have parents who encourage her in STEM topics, but that doesn't shield her from media/misguided school teachers/councillors/other kids telling her these things aren't for her. Having a female role model is a powerful thing.
I believe that choosing to limit one's role models by gender is a problem.
This is not true for women. This guy's daughter might be the only girl in her class who feels comfortable expressing an interest in engineering. She might go on to be one of a tiny (and steadily decreasing) number of women in an overwhelmingly male university-level engineering program. Can you imagine how it might be nice to at some point be able to meet and learn from someone whose life experiences more closely match your own, and learn from the experiences that they have (or will have) in common?
I mean I genuinely do not understand why this is actually helpful. The lady engineers I talk to are either all pandering to me, or are as confused as I am.
I don't understand why we're presuming that a girl can't have a good, positive male role model, just like I, a boy, had a good, positive female role model.
.
"She might go on to be one of a tiny (and steadily decreasing) number of women in an overwhelmingly male university-level engineering program."
So, as we bucketted women out of the mainstream and told them they could only learn from people like themselves, their global participation began to drop.
I mean really, the data you're recommending seems to suggest that what we're doing is destructive.
It was not the case, in Elizabeth Cady Stanton's work, that the newly liberated woman was expected to learn only from other women. They're supposed to be equal.
The supporting claims seem to be assertions of better-ness with no supporting data or logic other than an intuitive feeling that the child's recognition of similarity is somehow more important than the child's early exposure to diversity (something most data backed child rearing studies disagree with.)
I do understand that your opinion is that a girl will have an emotional need to only learn from women.
Do you have any data to defend this? This seems bizarre and offensive to me, as it does to the female engineer who spoke up elsewhere in this thread.
I think that, just like men, women can learn from anyone, and should choose the best source, not the most similar source.
You can't create an inclusive society by educating explicitly exclusively, in my viewpoint.
I would love to see actual data, rather than beliefs or opinions, which suggest that learning from a demographically similar role model produces better results than learning from the best available role model, or that taking a role model from what you claim is an extreme minority, rather than building bonds and understanding with the majority, leads to more inclusion, despite that you also claim that inclusion is decreasing, despite that this sort of like-only mentorship is increasing.
It seems like your own data contradicts you. Maybe I'm misunderstanding.
That is not what is being said, it is that it may be useful for a girl to not only learn from men.
No one is talking about limiting to one kind of role model. Indeed, since women in STEM are not as represented as men, it may be limiting to not allow a student to seek out a role model who is a woman as they may never encounter one by happenstance. Having a role model you identify with, esp. with a trait that is a minority in some group, is one of the ways people can counteract imposter syndrome.
Yes, the post saying "I need a woman for a role mode" is limiting one's role models by gender.
Having a woman for a rolemodel does not exclude also having a man as a rolemodel.
Consider it like getting an advice on getting into a good college from someone who got in using Affirmative Action vs someone who didn't.
A better analogy would be considering someone getting into a good college because of their connections & wealthy parents vs someone who didn't.
In that case, isn't it absolutely imperative to start making those connections, by not demographically binning mentors?
Connections don't just spring out of nowhere.
I don't want to go too far down the rabbit hole here because I know where this is leading to from past experience on HN, but....
I think in the tech-scene(probably society in general) some of those connections are easier made(and sometimes come as default) depending on gender/race.
You don't want to make those connections early by arrangement, because they would be more difficult to make later on voluntarily?
Not every individual's parenting decision needs to be treated as an overall trend to be analyzed and correct.
Sometimes it's actually perfectly valid to politely ask someone why they think something.
For the record, I'm a female engineer who moved to the USA from Ghana when I was a smaller. I can't stand this ridiculous patronizing attitude there is towards female engineers, as if we need "extra help" or something. Even worse are the feminists creating us-vs-them politicization of the issue.
When I was learning to code, ride a bike, tie my shoes or something, I never thought "gosh I can't do that since none of the role models are female". In fact, if there are no role models of the same gender or race, its usually even more inspiring as you want to be the first one.
Nobody is saying women engineers need extra help. Wanting to meet someone who you identify with as a woman in STEM is not necessarily easy and it is totally legitimate to seek someone out. As for feminists and feminism, I don't know of anything that would suggest an us vs. them attitude, generally feminist leaning groups look to increase participation of women in STEM through a variety of ways.
> When I was learning to code, ride a bike, tie my shoes or something, I never thought "gosh I can't do that since none of the role models are female". In fact, if there are no role models of the same gender or race, its usually even more inspiring as you want to be the first one.
This may be true for yourself and others, but we know that this is not true on a larger scale. People can and do internalize messages about the kind of people that exist in certain professions and this can be self limiting in both conscious and unconscious ways. I'm not speaking for any one person about that, but it is legitimate to find a role model that you identify with esp. when you are a minority status in a group.
You can read more about stereotype threat here: http://www.reducingstereotypethreat.org/definition.html
Thanks for this. That's why I said she could use some inspiration. And not all the messages come from men. Women and friends provide powerful messages as well.
Also, I'll add another +1 to the people who are saying it's nice to see someone like you. There are questions that it is safer to ask someone who has faced similar struggles in the past. For example, I would love to meet more female professors who have managed to find a balance between family/R01-level research/service.
I draw great inspiration from people who do not have my gender, my race, or several other role model limiting demographic factors.
I feel very sad for people who are set up to not have the advantage of looking up to everyone of value.
===========
Edit: why is this being downvoted? Is it disagreeable to say "I have learned from people unlike me?" Are we now saying it's bad to argue for inclusion?
It's a polite, friendly comment, stating a positive opinion that says "I think people of every gender, race, etc are of value and should be available."
I feel like people are using downvote to show personal frustration.
People have value, but we can't deny that for some people finding someone like themselves in a particular field is very difficult. Those people certainly can and do learn from others, but finding someone that has faced the same issue and challenges as themselves is very helpful in not only exploring an issue, but also in counteracting stereotype threat.
This reads to me like
"You are being downvoted because your opinion doesn't address the original question you asked."
I have been polite, friendly, and reasonable. You guys are punishing an opinion about increasing inclusiveness because it goes against your norm.
Except your original post said:
"I don't understand why we all talk about the gender problem in engineering, then continue it by isolating female students from male teachers."
The gender problem in STEM isn't that women have a hard time finding men as peers and role models, its that women have a hard time finding women as peers and role models. You started out by misidentifying the problem in the first place, this is why your subsequent posts are downvoted because you are creating a straw man out of the OP's request to find a woman in STEM for their daughter to meet.
Suppose that we are trying to sample a distribution that is, say, 90% male and 10% female. If we do that with a fair sampling, and take 5 samples, chances are that we will end up with no females in the sample. Someone observing the sampled distribution would draw the conclusion that there are no women in the population from which the samples are drawn.
The solution is to not sample fairly, because to do so results in oversampling the common cases and undersampling the rare cases. Instead, you construct your sample such that it samples the rare cases with an artificially higher probability. You of course needs to take this into account when interpreting the samples, but that's fine.
So for the topic at hand: if you want to expose someone to the widest possible range of viewpoints, sampling fairly is an inefficient thing to do. Instead, you need to split the samples into several strata, be they gender, cultural background, wealth, anything you can think of, and then make sure that all parts of those distributions are represented in your sample. Otherwise, with a limited number of samples, you'll never encounter the rare instances.
In other words, you need to "carefully structure inequality in", as you say.
Because role models are a great thing thing for a young person to have. Why is it a problem for him to want a female role model for a female child? Why do you think that "wanting his daughter to meet a female engineer" represents inequality? Do you think that it would somehow be more equal for women to only have male role models?
You seem to be going to great effort to misunderstand me.
By saying "I think young people should have access to everyone, not just people demographically like them," you seem to have heard "I think young women should only have access to people unlike them."
A call for inclusion has been misrepresented as a call for exclusion.
.
"Why is it a problem for him to want a female role model for a female child?"
For the same reason that it would be a problem to only want male role models for male children. It reinforces existing problems and stereotypes, prevents social connections across demographics, limits group knowledge cross pollination, and limits the students' access to whoever is the best mentor available in the case that that mentor does not match them demographically.
.
"Why do you think that "wanting his daughter to meet a female engineer" represents inequality?"
Does this actually need to be explained?
> A call for inclusion has been misrepresented as a call for exclusion.
In terms of gender, cisgender men by far the norm, they have no problem being represented. Women in general are not as well represented, someone looking for a women as a role model would have to look harder to find someone. To that end, a highly represented group doesn't need special consideration to be included, they are heavily included already.
> For the same reason that it would be a problem to only want male role models for male children. It reinforces existing problems and stereotypes, prevents social connections across demographics, limits group knowledge cross pollination, and limits the students' access to whoever is the best mentor available in the case that that mentor does not match them demographically.
Nobody is arguing that role models should be limited. Indeed, if this person's daughter pursues STEM they will likely have a man as a role model at some point since they are well represented. Groups of people that are not as well represented will be harder to come across so it is not a bad idea for someone to seek out different people.
> Does this actually need to be explained?
It does to a certain degree, as it seems that you feel that the extra search and effort to find a woman role model detracts from the dominant group.
"Nobody is arguing that role models should be limited."
The entire tree I'm responding to is.
The father wants to make sure his daughter gets access to both male and female role models at which point she can choose one or two or all or none of them if she wants - that is the complete opposite of _limiting_ role models. People replying to you think it's okay for him to seek out a female engineer specifically because if he doesn't try, she's ending up with a male role model (not a bad thing) out of a pool of only men right now (the bad thing). He's not saying "my daughter will ONLY have female role models or else" or "men can't be role models for my daughter" or "the woman I find from this Ask HN must be my daughter's role model". He's also not asking for male role models because he thinks they make bad role models for women, rather that they're very common as half the men in his social circle can act as one for his daughter. I would also fully expect him and others to care just as much about finding a similar potential role model had he had a son instead of a daughter.
Personally, most of my role models were male, but it would have been nice to encounter more women along the way. I have different conversations with other women than I do with men that aren't my husband in the tech industry. It's also a coping mechanism when I deal with sexism that men don't fully understand because they're not used to or aware of it. (I recognize that the complete opposite happens in some fields and I don't approve of any of the sexism, I just don't see what's wrong with doing what you can and taking advantage of what you can if you need to.)
I agree. :(
.
"He's not saying "my daughter will ONLY have female role models or else"
Yeah, I didn't claim he was. What I actually said was "making this selection explicitly by a demographic feature that isn't germane is limiting." It doesn't have to be universal.
If you go to the store and say "I'm going to try a strawberry drink," that's limiting, even if it's only applied to that one store trip.
Everyone seems to be trying to stretch what I said into an infinitive I had no intent of, which isn't actually present in my speech, in order to argue with the infinitive.
It's simpler than that.
Kids don't get a plethora of mentors. I think it's problematic to screw up the first mentorship by adding a criterion that is unnecessary and not particularly productive.
I mean reduce it to absurdity. "I want to give my child access to four mentors, one each from the four elements of the Western Zodiac, to give them the chance to figure out which element they like best."
Except that's dramatically limiting - it constrains which sets of mentors can be made available. If you have Charlie, who's an Aries, you can't also have Dave, who's a Taurus, because they're both fire signs. (They probably aren't; I don't actually know astrology.)
And when you hook it on something we all explicitly don't care about, like astrology, then suddenly the problem becomes really obvious, because it isn't taboo to think it over. "Oh hey, I shouldn't be adding arbitrary constraints to what can be proferred, then observing the range of those constraints as if it's some form of diversification, because constraints are always a reduction against wild card."
.
"He's also not asking for male role models because he thinks they make bad role models for women"
I wish people would stop making assumptions about the author's opinions then stuffing words into his mouth this way.
I asked that guy his opinion. Not everybody else reading the thread. You aren't mind readers and you don't know if this is what he meant.
.
"I would also fully expect him and others to care just as much about finding a similar potential role model had he had a son instead of a daughter."
I have a hard time reading this, because it seems to me like you're saying you expect his son to be proferred male role models, in the same post as where you're talking about how he doesn't limit who's offered.
Again: I am a man, and I modelled my professional self on a woman. I think that to offer male children preferential access to male role models perpetuates the broken networking and disallows men to learn from women.
I don't understand why this is not obviously a problem.
.
"Personally, most of my role models were male, but it would have been nice to encounter more women along the way."
And yet you want to make sure this girl gets childhood mentored by a woman.
I wonder if you're just taking this from the position that a person has several childhood mentors in their life?
.
"It's also a coping mechanism when I deal with sexism that men don't fully understand because they're not used to or aware of it."
Which is another great reason that we shouldn't be hiding male mentors from having access to those vanishingly rare female students.
.
"The father wants to make sure his daughter gets access to both male and female role models at which point she can choose one or two or all or none of them if she wants - that is the complete opposite of _limiting_ role models."
I don't know that I actually agree here.
If I had a boy, and I wanted to arrange for him one male and one female role model, and it turned out that the two best available were two women, I'd have limited him.
Unfortunately, despite that I'm trying to argue for inclusion and for helping female students, I'm about to be downvoted again :(
For all the HN articles about parent seeking role models for their children, are we really saying that "parent looking for male role model" is highly represented on the HN?
Or is it that no parent will ever need to look for a male role model outside their own social circle?
I don't understand why we all talk about the gender problem in engineering, then continue it by isolating female students from male teachers. There is no isolation between male students and female teachers, or same gender students and teachers.
If we want to move towards equality, why carefully structure inequality in?