Re:Tr.im is now in the process of discontinuing service
by judofyr on Sunday August 09, 2009 @08:46PM
(#751626)
The problem with URL shorteners is that you now have two servers which can go down.
Re:Tr.im is now in the process of discontinuing service
by tlrobinson on Sunday August 09, 2009 @10:40PM
(#751778)
Not only that, but if it's an "original" URL that's broken but at least well formatted you at least have a hint of where to look, for example in the Google cache, archive.org, or elsewhere on the original domain.
Shortened URLs give you no hints as to where the original document was located.
Re:Tr.im is now in the process of discontinuing service
by calambrac on Sunday August 09, 2009 @10:58PM
(#751804)
Dude, you keep saying that "it's the same problem we've always had", but it simply isn't. You seem like a smart guy otherwise, so I don't know why you persist in making this assertion. The difference is simple: url shorteners introduce a middle man, another point of failure or abuse, and one that can't be fixed by the person who made the link (because they may forget the original target and not know who to contact) or the person who manages the target (because they can't set up a redirect from the old url).
Re:Tr.im is now in the process of discontinuing service
by jacquesm on Monday August 10, 2009 @03:04AM
(#752133)
Adding a link to a chain, any chain will make a it weaker:
Either the link is as strong as all the other links then you have a new element that can fail, which is bad, or your link is weaker than the other links in the existing chain and now the whole chain is weakened to the strength of the new link.
The alarmist rants I've seen against URL shorteners are simply making this argument without realizing that there is no "new" problem in need of solving, only an old one that we already handle fairly well. Though given the level of irrational rhetoric I've been seeing in these discussions (example here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=713998) I'm not sure there's any point trying to argue with it.