News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by rkalla on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @10:27AM (#7515704)
Did the timelines seem awfully aggressive to anyone? (June 1 service stops, July 31 all data is erased)

For a service that we were suppose to be syncing our lives to, that seems like a really abrupt, customer unfriendly ramp-down.

I would have expected something more like:

  1. April 1 - no new accounts.
  2. May 1 - can no longer add files to your existing account.
  3. May - Dec - nagged/reminded constantly to pull your files down.
  4. Dec 31 - All accounts closed, data "erased"
  5. [BONUS] March '15 - Data actually erased to provide a few months of emergency 
  recovery for the few folks that didn't know and are emailing frantically that 
  their family photos are up there.
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by jonknee on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @11:02AM (#7515980)
Almost everyone will have at least one completely up-to-date copy of their files. It's just a matter of signing up for a competing service and re-uploading. Four months seems like a long enough time to accomplish that.
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by diminish on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @11:09AM (#7516039)
For something as important as "file storage" 12 months would be a safer option to make sure everyone was alerted and reacted. Or Ubuntu may keep the files as torrents/tars after that for up to 12 months and ask for a payment of for download.
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by brewdad on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @11:57AM (#7516414)
The problem with an extended shutdown is that it eliminates any sense of urgency to act. If I know I only have 2 months to find a new provider, I'll start searching and migrating now. Give me a year, and I'll ignore the problem for 10 months before acting.
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by simias on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @01:16PM (#7517131)
Freezing the accounts would be enough to create this sense of urgency, you wouldn't be able to modify or upload new files on the system. You would have to look for an alternative at that point...
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by hrjet on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @01:21PM (#7517181)
Yeah, but it is better to cover for the users who won't be aware soon rather than the users who are aware but wouldn't care soon enough.
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by diminish on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @01:38PM (#7517368)
yeah that's what i meant. People in special conditions who won't check their emails may lose all files... freezing in 4 months and keeping for 12 months may ensure nothing valuable is lost.
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by yaph on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @12:07PM (#7516507)
It's not only about file storage. Ubuntu One offered a Web service to programmatically access the files. Imagine you've developed an application that interfaces with Ubuntu One and is mission critical for your business.
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by jarek on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @12:22PM (#7516637)
Then you've learned a valuable lesson about how to design applications that are mission critical for your business.
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by jonknee on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @02:39PM (#7517935)
I bet you can count the number of people who did that on one hand. They're not shuttering the service because it was popular. They are open sourcing the code though, so you can run your own version and not change any code.
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by pekk on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @01:57PM (#7517567)
Not essentially different from if you developed your business application on a PaaS which went bust or raised prices. These things happen unless you keep them in mind
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by Marazan on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @05:07PM (#7519032)
Two months notice plus two months of shutdown time? Luxury. If you want to see abrupt then MochiMedia's 2 weeks notice announcement that they were going away and taking with it probably the largest ad network for Flash games along with metrics, highscore systems, versioning, distribution and more was abrupt!
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by fzltrp on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @02:53PM (#7518042)
Everyone will wait the last second to get their data back (and complain about the cramped service) anyway. And it's not like an OS upgrade which could potentially break your apps or lose your data. It's just a mattee of pushing the sync button to get all your data back on your local drive. People will largely have time to find an alternative solution or buy a small storage device until EOS. Afaic, Ubuntu is pulling the plug on a very good service in a reasonable fashion: we should be thankful they kept it running for so long.
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by schmichael on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @01:52PM (#7517507)
It was barely used and very easy to replace with free services like Dropbox. I'm sure the few users it did have are savvy enough to migrate off within the relatively short time frame.
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by vii on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:32AM (#7529682)
The cost of switching is generally very low and it's quite likely that most people with data in the UbuntuOne system that they wanted to keep were already using another service like DropBox simultaneously.

The biggest cost here is to the Ubuntu reputation. They stand on the promise of LTS releases: with the quick timeline for removal of support from what could be a critical piece of customer infrastructure they signal that they are willing to sacrifice relationships for convenience.

Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by k_bx on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @11:17AM (#7516105)
I don't think they are going to erase data from your devices, so I don't see a reason doing such a strange migration.
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by rkalla on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @11:40AM (#7516277)
Oh, no I wasn't implying they were going to launch a campaign of evil and despair against their users :)

Regardless, for an online backup/sync service, I think a very compassionate ramp-down plan is on the order of 6 months with a few secret months of emergency recovery in the cases where people "forgot their child birth pictures were on there!" and the like.

If it wasn't a "backup your life" service, sure, a more aggressive ramp-down is fine... but for a service that tried for a few years to convince you to stick you life in it, I think it's overly aggressive.

I can't imagine their burn rate is _so high_ that it is not something they could have funded for a few extra months.

Anyway, just my opinion... a few of you have pointed out "how long does it take to move your data?" -- sure, if you are paying attention, have a stable/non-metered connection in a 1st world country and are always ontop of things the moment they happen... you are right, a few days maybe.

I am thinking of that small 10-15% of stragglers that miss the emails, miss the announcements and legitimately have important information sitting in One and don't realize it's gone until too late.

I'm pre-emptively feeling compassion for them :)

Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by reidrac on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @10:34AM (#7515760)
Apparently that's for free users, for annual subscribers "[...] the service will remain available until 1 June and data available for a further two months".

Not that it changes things a lot, but two months is definitely better than one. They probably have data to back their decision.

EDIT: I misread the post, there's not difference. Sorry for the noise.

Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by claudius on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @10:41AM (#7515814)
1 June through 31 July is two months?
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by keithpeter on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @10:44AM (#7515854)
61 days inclusive. I imagine the sync client will be producing a countdown in notification area and generally nagging the user each day.

Disclaimer: not an Ubuntu One user.

Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by reidrac on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @10:45AM (#7515859)
You're right, thanks. I misread the blog post.
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by ekianjo on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @09:07PM (#7520206)
You're not familiar with most online services out there? Most of the time you get only weeks if not days before you can do anything about your data. This is actually better than most.
Re:Shutting down Ubuntu One file services by WayneS on Thursday April 03, 2014 @09:45AM (#7522718)
You seem to be assuming someone is using Ubuntu One.