News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mozilla CEO Eich says gay-marriage firestorm could hurt F... by coldtea on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @06:05AM (#7514506)
>While I don't feel comfortable lynching someone based on contextually irrelevant beliefs, most of us see gay rights as an issue principally comparable to issues of slavery and suffrage. It's the denying of rights to "other people" for dubious reasons.

Only "being free" and "choosing your government" is a right, whereas mariage is a made-up custom, and as such it has historical connections to certain morals and can also be seen as a religious related practice for some.

>If the CEO of another tech company was revealed to have political interests in slavery, would we feel the need to tip-toe so carefully?

If states still had slavery (in the same way states prohibit gay marriage), then yes, we would. Far from being a solved issue, it was something put on vote. If it's one vote, then it's undemocratic to demonize one side of the ballot.

Furthermore, if you're so fired up about civil issues, how about a few that are important to me: the death penalty and gun control. Should a CEO be fired for being pro/against those?

How come a gay man's right to marriage (an antiquated institution if I ever saw one, and a kitchy fair with tons of made up customs for straight and gay men alike) is more important than a 15 year old kids right not to be institutionally murdered in TX, or some other state?

Seems to me some issues have better marketing, and people just go with the flock to the acceptable crusades, and if they have to lynch one or two that are against the flow in the process, so be it.

Re:Mozilla CEO Eich says gay-marriage firestorm could hurt F... by corin_ on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @06:11AM (#7514536)
(I'm not one of the people who has downvoted you.)

My personal feeling - speaking as a gay man and therefore somewhat personally linked, but also as somebody who has not once suffered bullying or mistreatment because of it - is that there are two crucial reasons gay marriage should be legalised, and neither are to do with "made up customs".

Firstly the legal side: inheritance law, hospital visitation rights, insurance, etc. etc.

Secondly, the impact it has on how people view homosexuality. A step towards equality is a step towards not seeing gay kids bullied, gay teens killing themselves, gay adults being harassed in the work place, etc. And that's a huge deal in my opinion.

Re:Mozilla CEO Eich says gay-marriage firestorm could hurt F... by tomp on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @06:19AM (#7514567)
I think both of your points are important, but in an ideal world, I would go in a slightly different direction, and a bit further. First, I think that marriage is actually two distinct concepts - religious and legal. Since marriage was originally defined by religion, I don't see a problem if religion retains the right of defining marriage - a union between a man and a woman.

Legally, however, gay marriage doesn't solve all the problems. Ideally, "civil unions", granting all the rights above, would be allowed between any number of mutually-consensual partners - e.g. Mormon polygamy, Hippy communes, ... This would also bring additional recognition and acceptance to these people.

Re:Mozilla CEO Eich says gay-marriage firestorm could hurt F... by sjwright on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @07:23AM (#7514782)
> Since marriage was originally defined by religion

I don't think this is true, and anyway it's completely irrelevant. The post-1950s definition of marriage is a result of secular progress, and was definitely not defined by religion.

> I don't see a problem if religion retains the right of defining marriage - a union between a man and a woman.

I see a huge problem, which is that "religion" isn't an entity. If you want religion to have the right to define marriage, you must allow pro-gay churches to define it the way they see fit, too.

(I should add that as an atheist, I would fully support laws limiting religious weddings to a union between a man and a woman. I'm not interested in dragging religions kicking and screaming into the 21st century.)

Re:Mozilla CEO Eich says gay-marriage firestorm could hurt F... by MetaCosm on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @07:02AM (#7514717)
Sure, I agree with you on all points. That doesn't mean that marriage equality doesn't solve any issues. It solves one. Solving one problem is exponentially better than solving zero.

As for Mormon polygamy and hippy communes -- absolutely! As long as it is willing, consenting adults, I am all for it! But, right now, lets take this small step.

Re:Mozilla CEO Eich says gay-marriage firestorm could hurt F... by hamax on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @06:29AM (#7514598)
> Since marriage was originally defined by religion

This is not actually true. Marriage is a very very old concept.

Re:Mozilla CEO Eich says gay-marriage firestorm could hurt F... by sjwright on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @06:52AM (#7514691)
Marriage defined as a voluntary expression of love and commitment between equals is very, very, very modern.

It wasn't long ago that marriage was also widely accepted as an asset for parents to sell. It was relatively recent that monogamy wasn't assumed, and that the maximum number in such unions was two.

Re:Mozilla CEO Eich says gay-marriage firestorm could hurt F... by mercurial on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @07:33AM (#7514815)
What does it have to do with religion, though?
Re:Mozilla CEO Eich says gay-marriage firestorm could hurt F... by sjwright on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @09:07AM (#7515187)
Nothing, if you're asking me.
Re:Mozilla CEO Eich says gay-marriage firestorm could hurt F... by mercurial on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @09:39AM (#7515404)
I mean, the original point was that marriage was originally a religious concept (which is, AFAIK, incorrect). Whether the motivation for the union is love or material interests is a different issue, though it is also an interesting point.
Re:Mozilla CEO Eich says gay-marriage firestorm could hurt F... by tomp on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @06:37AM (#7514633)
So is religion.
Re:Mozilla CEO Eich says gay-marriage firestorm could hurt F... by sjwright on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @06:58AM (#7514704)
Marriage certainly predates the Abrahamic religions.
Re:Mozilla CEO Eich says gay-marriage firestorm could hurt F... by coldtea on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @09:15AM (#7515240)
Religion predates the Abrahamic religions too.
Re:Mozilla CEO Eich says gay-marriage firestorm could hurt F... by sjwright on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @05:17PM (#7519096)
For what reason did you feel compelled to make that blindingly obvious point?
Re:Mozilla CEO Eich says gay-marriage firestorm could hurt F... by MetaCosm on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @06:40AM (#7514649)
TL;DR: Of he can be (and IMHO should be) criticized, he is on the wrong side of history. He made a public statement (money as speech), and now the community can (and will) hold him accountable for it.

The bottom line is -- being homophobic is starting to reach the same point in popular culture as racism and sexism. Our society as a whole is becoming far less tolerant of such nonsense, being against gay marriage is treated like being against interracial marriage. Even 61% of young Republican leaning 18-29 year olds are in favor of marriage equality.

It follows a similar trend to interracial marriage (slow start, then a rapid increase in acceptance). In 1986, less than 35% of American's "approved" of interracial marriage. A mere 5 years later, the number was about 50% .. and 20 years later that vast majority approve of interracial marriage, with more than 30% having a family member involved in an interracial relationship.

That is when it hits home for people, when a friend of family member comes out (today, being in love with the same sex... in the 80s, being in love with another race) -- it becomes personal, and when it becomes personal, you can no longer abstract 'those' people -- now it is your friend, your sister, your cousin, the best man at your wedding, etc.

You can rail against marriage being crap (it is, I agree) -- but that isn't the point. If you are against marriage, I am with you 100% -- lets get rid of it as a government regulated institution! But, if it is around, it has to be an option for all. I think it is far too close to religion to be certified by government, but that ship has sailed long ago... gotta work within reality.

Also, undemocratic to demonize one side of the vote, are you kidding? That is the oldest democratic tradition!

As for why it gets more "marketing" than the death penalty and gun control. It gets more "marketing" than the death penalty because it touches more peoples lives. It gets FAR less "marketing" than gun control, gun control just has lots of marketing on both sides, a massive constitutional question, and is not trending towards consensus... marriage equality unequivocally is trending towards consensus... it will be a decided issue before it ever has the "marketing" of gun control.

While I am freaking ranting... this quote is idiocy "Beliefs that are protected, that include political and religious speech, are generally not something that can be held against even a CEO." -- NO. Just NO. If you believe something that society finds laughable or horrible (Lizard people run the world, X race is superior, Z are bad at math, the Holocaust didn't happen, etc)... and you support it out loud, with money, in public. Of COURSE it can be held against you -- you don't have a goddamn right to that job, and part of your job is to be the face of the company.

/rant