I vehemently disagree regarding grades. Grades are the stupidest measure of engineering ability. Paper tests are meaningless except as a measure for the most basic levels of competence in mathematics and physics. We are talking about people who push the state of the art. These people are often very annoyed by tests, since it is idiotic to use an extremely distant proxy (i.e. a test) for an ability like like engineering when it's much simpler (and infinitely more satisfying) to just practice engineering itself.
The only measure of an engineer's skill is his ability to built elegant systems. This cannot be taught through a course. It must be learned through iteration, and repetitive failure.
There is one point though which I think you're not giving enough; schools like MIT and Standford are all about connections and networking. You go to an MIT or a Stanford to have a pedigree, and it opens doors and opportunities which wouldn't be there if you hadn't gone there.
I think the only thing worse than using grades as a measure of mastery is using an inflated grading scale. :P
This can be taught through a course if said course requires you to build an elegant system. Many courses in engineering schools are project-based.
MIT pushed me to my limits, and taught me how to systematically accomplish what I previously thought were impossible tasks. All while maintaining a principled sense of rigor and focus. A lot of people who are "smart" just ace high school and never are truly challenged. Harvard has insane grade inflation, because the students there are used to getting As. [1]
The world has enough billionaires, but not enough fearless engineers. I've found it surprisingly easy to connect billionaires when you genuinely need it-- not just because you got drunk with them in your 20s.
[1] http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2013/12/3/grade-inflation-...