Your argument that the US is the best place to start a business is not in any way "self-evident", and you have provided no source or proof.
So say some journalists.
Their methodology seems sound.
"We determined the Best Countries for Business by looking at 11 different factors for 134 countries. We considered property rights, innovation, taxes, technology, corruption, freedom (personal, trade and monetary), red tape, investor protection and stock market performance. Forbes leaned on research and published reports from the Central Intelligence Agency, Freedom House, Heritage Foundation, Property Rights Alliance, Transparency International, the World Bank and World Economic Forum to compile the rankings."
http://www.forbes.com/sites/kurtbadenhausen/2011/10/03/the-b...
Given Forbes' own editorial slant, I don't think it's entirely unreasonable to look at these rankings as a simple coatrack for Forbes argument that the US corporate tax rate should be lowered.
If you could find the methodology document for Forbes ranking --- anything similar to the World Bank's ranking, which is itself not totally great, would be helpful --- I'd be grateful. This topic comes up a lot on HN.
It's really not self-evident that the vast majority of successful companies are started in the US?
Do you think those people starting companies would do any worse, if we placed them in, say, Denmark?
EDIT:Or maybe Israel, which has the highest density of start ups worldwide? I'd be curious to see the per capita numbers of countries.
Yes. Facebook, Apple, Google, Tesla, etc. would never have happened in Denmark. I'm really glad my parents did the annoying work of immigrating to the SF Bay Area from Germany when I was a kid. Otherwise I would have wasted years of my life doing it myself.
Did you watch the Elon Musk interview posted here the other day? He said more-or-less the same thing: it was really obvious, growing up in South Africa, that California was the place to be to make things happen.
Edit: I don't know much about Israel. They seem to be doing a pretty good job, based on what little I do know. It doesn't sound like they're at SF Bay Area levels yet, but making progress: http://aleph.vc/the-israel-venture-capital-index/
The US is set up to achieve the maximum amount of runaway breakout successes at the expense of average of quality of life.
The EU is set up to achieve the maximum amount of reasonably sustainable business providing for a decent quality of life.
Each type of business is much easier to start on the respective continent.
For the record, the discussion started with VKontakte, which is definitely not in the "median small business" category.
And let's not get started on the different possible definitions of "quality of life" ;)
In Germany, which is the prime example of the EU model in that sense, there is even a word for that kind of business: Mittelstand (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mittelstand)
> And let's not get started on the different possible definitions of "quality of life" ;)
Good point; the EU definition would probably be having a roof over your head and ample free time to enjoy the bread and games in good health ;)
I just think the reason they ARE lagging behind is because US is considered the default country to go for starting a business, without second thought.
EDIT:I should probably clarify - I meant the US is viewed as the best, hypothetically, not necessarily implying action.
Edit: changed to unlikely.
Edit: In case it wasn't apparent, my "ever any doubt" question was rhetorical hyperbole. Any statement, no matter how self-evident, will have some people contradicting it.
Edit2: See mtrimpe's comment below; Forbes is probably optimizing for small business in their analysis instead of startups with potential for high scalability.