News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:4chan demands 4chan.com domain name by pbhjpbhj on Monday March 31, 2014 @11:59AM (#7502264)
>Just because you own something DOESN'T give you impunity to 'waste' it as you see fit. //

Sure it does. IF you own it.

>These are greedy people just speculatively buying stuff without any real interest. //

This is capitalism. The more damaging domain as you suggest is real-estate. Online the problem becomes simply "oh example.com wasn't right, example.org ... oh, ya, there it is". That might be a very minor annoyance for some people for a couple of seconds.

The problem I see with the "they're not creating a mall" argument is that to the logical conclusion that means that if you have a swimming pool and aren't using it as much as the public feel you should that it can be confiscated. Or, say, you have 2 cars - well clearly you can't drive both at once; repossession by the state, et cetera.

Now I've got some pretty communist sensibilities but unless we're going to implement the whole system and treat all properties in this way (I'd really like to use one of the many, many over-priced vacant commercial premises in our city) then I can't see how you can really move on this?

Re:4chan demands 4chan.com domain name by Shinkei on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:43PM (#7502960)
>if you have a swimming pool and aren't using it as much as the public feel you should that it can be confiscated. Or, say, you have 2 cars - well clearly you can't drive both at once; repossession by the state, et cetera

This has nothing to do with what I said. Neither a swimming pool nor a car is a scarce resource. Now if you owned the only bridge to an island and didn't allow people to use it, or charged them extortionary rates... then we can begin the debate.

>Sure it does. IF you own it.

I'll tell you what, go let your house collapse from disrepair, attempt to assert mineral rights in your backyard and then pour raw sewage onto your land.... we'll see if the zoning code enforcement, county lawyers and EPA respectively come knocking or not. Despite your assertion, there is very little that we actually own in the real property market. This is because it is in the public interest to have the many protections that we have.

Re:4chan demands 4chan.com domain name by nness on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @01:35AM (#7506345)
Economically speaking, everything is a scare resource. But more importantly, a unused domain does not cause any damage, as say a derelict house would. I don't find the metaphors compatible.
Re:4chan demands 4chan.com domain name by number_six on Monday March 31, 2014 @02:32PM (#7503249)
URLs are not a scare resource. Having a specific (and in this case marketable) one is (and really only if that URL already has market value). I could make the same argument that MY car is a scare resource. Any car is not scare but MINE is.

If I already have a pool where you wanted one, you have to put yours somewhere else. If my car is parked the spot you want at the store, you park somewhere else. If I bought the last car of the type you wanted, you have to buy a different one.