All the console makers have been deciding what can be made for their systems for a long time. I'm sure the process can be quite arbitrary and unfair, but at the very least, it reflects some effort to have a curated library of games.
Personally, I'd prefer to see App Stores that had a much more curated experience (for all categories, not just games) than a "swap meet" type of experience, but that's just me. These days I find the App Stores incredibly painful to use due to the amount of duplicate junk in their inventories.
I find most of my mobile downloads and purchases these days come from recommendations by sites I trust.
Consoles have traditionally had a large barrier to entry. You couldn't just buy a MacBook and a $99 developer account and make NES or PlayStation games. Having an SDK that costs $25,000 in combination with an approval process to even consider you eligible to buy it is a big filter.
Bad idea. How do they decide who stays and who goes when it comes to clones? The 'best' game? The first game?