So the real question to ask is: does a marginal increase in liquidity outweigh the financial cost? I'd argue that it is a tax on society with no real benefit. I've started to hear about auction's to improve the markets which is interesting and saves us from the millions (billions?) of dollars that HFTs pocket for themselves.
[1] http://quant.stackexchange.com/questions/1658/has-high-frequ...
It is quite normal to take a spread in any industry - an orange seller steps between you and the farmer, for example. I would argue your broker does a lot less for you than a farmer, or high frequency market maker. HFT is generally known to shrink the spread, making trading cheaper for you than it would be without them. They still take a profit, because they take a risk.
I'd recommend reading a little about market structure - and preferably not from those with a narrative to sell.
Let's simplify this: I have a stock to sell, I'm asking $100, you want to buy and offer $95.
How does a HFT decrease the spread while keeping a portion of the transaction itself as profit?
Matt looks at the bid ask spread and decides it would be profitable to make a market in that stock. So he simultaneously asks at $99.99 and bids at $95.01. If Sally and Bob were to come back now they each would get a better deal and Matt would make $4.98 on the deal.
For Matt to continue doing this that $4.98 needs to cover the risks he is taking, his operational costs, and some profit. An HFT is much more efficient at this than Matt driving down the operational cost & potentially calculating the risk more accurately.
Katsuyama realized that his orders traveled along fiber
optic lines and hit the closest exchange first, where high
frequency traders would get a glimpse, and then use their
speed advantage to beat him to the other 12 U.S. public
exchanges and 45 private trading venues. HFT algorithms
could then buy the shares Katsuyama wanted, and then sell
them to him at a slightly higher price. [1]
I don't know if this is illegal or not, but I'll eat my hat if anyone gets prosecuted.[1] http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/03/31/us-markets-hft-fla...
He was taking advantage of multiple exchanges in order to hide his order flow, because as a natural consequence of market laws large orders move prices. He is just upset that other folks were better at finding his order flow than he was at hiding it.
FTFY
Same shit.
Trade execution/optimization is actually where most of the differentiation is in current HFT systems as the speed race has become so efficient.
Just remember that this is happening at very fast speeds, by participants that have mind bogglingly high risk levels.
But this latency is not about seeing other peoples orders before they enter the market, it is about reacting to market data quickly as it is disseminated to everyone.
The thing is, there are multiple markets not just one. So when you place an order to buy 100 shares of IBM, that order gets sent to many places to try to find the best offer to fill you.
If a HFT can see you submit that order to 1 market, and then beat you to the other 4 markets and buy up all the shares before you, that's frontrunning. That would be illegal if your broker did it, but HFT is not your broker, and just has the advantage of being faster than your broker.
What makes you say it's "not true"? What evidence do you have of that?
Once that order hits the market it is public signalling data that should impact the prices on every other market. That some traders are more efficient at responding to that public signalling data than others is not an issue and in fact is a large part of why the markets are as efficient as they are.
But given the simplistic nature of the discussion it is more accurate to say that in general HFT don't see your order before it hits the market than it is to say they do.
Now technically they write it off as helping you as they group small orders together and execute them, but that doesn't mean these market makers are making a profit off the transaction.
But they can actually see you attempting to buy stock, step in front of you, buy it before you, and then try to resell it to you for a higher price? That's bad behavior and reduces confidence in the free market. There needs to be regulation around things like that.