News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by rayiner on Sunday March 30, 2014 @12:31PM (#7496676)
> Being nosy is the part that didn't end well.

Neither did being obnoxious, I imagine: "I told them that it was an early stage startup; I’m doing this because I feel it’s a way to make the world around me better, to bring people joy through better food."

I don't condone the violence and abuse of authority, obviously. But imagine being a cop, and having to deal with this at 1 am after a long day at work.

Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by jellicle on Sunday March 30, 2014 @12:47PM (#7496763)
And yet your reply condones the violence and abuse of authority. Why is that?

Here's the basic rule: as a police officer, you must be polite, fair, kind, and law-abiding, even if the public you deal with is rude, nasty, entitled, somewhat drunk, and otherwise unpleasant. Period. If you can't do that, you're in the wrong profession. And if the profession permits people who can't do that, the profession has systemic issues that need to be corrected.

Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by nemo on Sunday March 30, 2014 @01:15PM (#7496909)
If you walk in the street you might get hit by a car. I don't condone a driver hitting you, but reality is what it is.

Cops have to constantly deal with the worst elements of society doing the worst things imaginable. It'd be great if they didn't get hardened, but the reality is they often do. Expecting cops to be polite and kind to the drug addicted guy beating his wife because she isn't turning enough tricks to support his habit is probably an unreasonable expectation. Until we've fixed society, cops aren't going to change.

Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by jjoonathan on Sunday March 30, 2014 @01:46PM (#7497041)
> It'd be great if they didn't get hardened

"Hardened" suggests the officers are immune to bullshit. The officers' behavior suggests the exact opposite.

Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by nemo on Sunday March 30, 2014 @04:19PM (#7497740)
Hardened has nothing to do with being immune to BS. It means that they adopt the mindset needed to do a job that involves potentially getting killed, potentially dealing with murders, murderers, rapists, and similar things that require hardening psychologically to handle working with. That mindset doesn't make them immune to BS, it makes them able to do their job. It also makes them the kind of person you don't want to have interactions with professionally, so if they tell you to leave an area, you leave the area and don't linger and piss them off pointlessly. Hanging out and obstructing/distracting them from their work is the kind of BS they have no tolerance for, which is what the guy in this article was doing out of mind-bogglingly profound ignorance.
Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by jjoonathan on Sunday March 30, 2014 @09:00PM (#7498843)
Then how about we call it "oversensitized" or "embrittled" instead of "hardened"? They are far more fitting terms for what you just described.

Not only is the "Colonel Jessup hypothesis" total baloney (note how the deputy at the end saw what happened as the mark of a rookie), but accepting it glorifies moral failure and belittles the efforts of officers who have managed to develop a thick hide along with the integrity to judiciously wield the authority they have been given.

Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by nemo on Sunday March 30, 2014 @11:08PM (#7499347)
"Hardened" was the first term that jumped to mind, though the more I thought about this, and after reading the police report, the more I understand the police's motives and generally agree with their response (it might be they were too harsh physically, but they had good reason to be physical, and the guy fully deserved to be arrested).

While I feel bad for the guy for getting himself into trouble, we had a situation where a guy called 911, the first responders showed up, and the guy had such a sense of entitlement that he acted like he was still in charge of the situation, and because of that misbehaved in a few serious ways. Probably the fact that he was drunk played into his foolishness, but by his own account and the account of the police report, the cops had a drunk guy and his friend interfering with the first responders' work, the police asked them to step back, they were belligerent to the police about it and refused to step back, when the police tried to move him he resisted physically, so the cop put a lock on him, cuffed him, and arrested him. When a drunk is interfering with first responders, disobeying lawful orders, and physically resisting efforts to move out of the scene what else are they going to do? They ordered him to leave, he was belligerent, they pulled him away, he resisted, so they pinned him, cuffed him, and off to jail he went. Maybe they were too forceful, but all we have are the memories of the angry drunk guy prone to fits of screaming by his own account - no medical records or corroboration, and the cops actually made sure there was surveillance of the incident preserved.

They treated him pretty harshly in the jail, but by his own account he was screaming and acting out. It's not a real shocker that the drunk screaming guy misbehaving in jail is going to suffer for it.

There are legitimate cases of serious police abuses. This is more a case of a drunk fool getting himself in trouble by acting like an entitled clown and not complying with the officers' requests to give the first responders space to work.

Even with his annotations, the police report shows what was missing from the story: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/779439/police_report_ann...

Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by jjoonathan on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:03PM (#7505702)
> and after reading the police report, the more I understand the police's motives and generally agree with their response

Wow. Are you and I reading the same report? I'm able to understand the police's motives, but that's the problem. It was reasonable for them to clear bystanders away from the EMTs, but it was unreasonable for them to resort to physical force so quickly after encountering hesitation that a) posed no threat to the EMTs and b) could have been easily addressed without violence. I don't think police SOP should be "1) make demand, 2) attack civilian that hesitates due to objections with demand." Some situations allow time for rational conversation, this was one of them, and the police rejected that possibility (which had a lower likelihood of resulting in bodies flying into the EMT's workspace) in favor of using force.

Sgt. Espinoza used Woosley's passive insistence on getting his phone back, which explicitly did not interfere with the wellbeing of the patient or the actions of the EMTs, as a justification for employing violent compliance techniques. If Sgt E doubted W's ability to get his phone back without interfering (not unreasonable), he should have volunteered to do it on W's behalf rather than violently subduing him for what to me looks like entirely reasonable hesitation (reasonable in the moral sense, not in the maximize-probability-of-avoiding-arrest sense).

Partensky's case is more difficult to assess without a video recording. It's conceivable that P's hesitation justified violent escalation (as opposed to a more rational but slower approach with higher P(success)) but I doubt it.

> This is more a case of a drunk fool getting himself in trouble by acting like an entitled clown and not complying with the officers' requests to give the first responders space to work.

It took two to tangle, and I believe the police were unambiguously in the wrong, whatever you think of W and P.

Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by nemo on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @10:29PM (#7520545)
Woosley's behavior wasn't solely passive resistance according to the report. He was resistant until the cops tried to move him (reasonably), at which point he flipped. The cops put the drunk guy freaking out in an arm lock at that point. Could they have handled things more ideally? Probably, but they didn't do anything particularly wrong given what they were dealing with.

Parentsky was a drunk guy insisting he was a medic and pushing his way past the cops. He was told by the police and EMTs to get clear of the scene. The guy was buzzed and acting like a complete fool, trying to push his way through the cops when they blocked him. There was a scuffle, one of the cops got a minor injury from the scuffle, and Parentsky was cuffed. Then when he was in jail he acted like a drunk fool and started screaming.

If they were sober I'd probably look at it differently, but having dealt with enough drunk idiots, I recognize that they don't generally respond to reasoning. The cops were dealing with a couple drunk guys interfering with the EMTs doing their job. I think they handled the situation as best as they could given what they were dealing with.

Parentsky's bizarre self-justification sounds like a stringing of excuses and railing over narcissistic injury.

Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by tptacek on Sunday March 30, 2014 @07:49PM (#7498517)
What you're saying about the pressures on police officers is true, but the conclusion you draw from it is not. It is not actually the case that police officers must be managed in such a way that their professionalism is degraded by contact with the worst parts of society. One can think of many kinds of management interventions that could mitigate this problem --- or, for that matter, read books about modern police patrolling and the day-to-day work life of police officers to see good ones already written down.
Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by cpach on Monday March 31, 2014 @04:45AM (#7500361)
I'm not sure what you're hinting at. Do you have any specific articles/books to recommend on this subject?
Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by tptacek on Monday March 31, 2014 @11:51AM (#7502201)
I liked Moskos "Cop In The Hood", as a quick easy read; a lot of the rest of what I've read are cop blog posts or policy papers.

Two good example of problematic management techniques:

* All-car patrols, where police officers are either locked into their squad cars or, if out of the car and not eating lunch, in some kind of scuffle, so that their only contact with the locals is bad.

* Triage coverage, where units from all around the city are swung to hotspot areas in the city (in Chicago, for instance, alternately the west side or the south side), so nobody puts down roots with the community.

There are others.

A theme to all the recommendations I've heard is that they cost money. It costs money to allocate patrols so that officers can take the time to be on foot and retain the same neighborhood coverage they had before. It costs a lot of money to allocate enough officers to simultaneously and permanently cover the hotspot neighborhoods.

Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by cpach on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @02:23PM (#7510513)
Interesting! Apparently I don’t read enough police blogs :) I’ve put the book on my ”to read” list.
Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by rayiner on Sunday March 30, 2014 @12:52PM (#7496790)
Asserting that the reaction was predictable and in some sense understandable isn't the same as condoning it. This is the real world, and it's unavoidable that the sorts of people who are going to sign up to police the streets in the face of aggressive hobos and violent gang-bangers aren't going to be the most staid and self-controlled.
Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by diminoten on Sunday March 30, 2014 @12:55PM (#7496812)
I disagree. As a police officer, you must be fair and law-abiding. Why must they be kind and polite?
Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by dragonwriter on Sunday March 30, 2014 @01:03PM (#7496860)
Because one of the key challenges of law enforcement is securing community cooperation. Law enforcement cannot be effective when hey are seen by the community as a hostile gang of thugs, and politeness is just a name for adherence to social standards than signal that you are part of the community and not a hostile outsider.
Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by diminoten on Sunday March 30, 2014 @01:18PM (#7496930)
Sometimes, yes. Other times, such as when a robbery is in progress, or when an accident has just occurred and you've arrived on the scene, polite and kind aren't very important.

Fair and law-abiding become much more important in these situations. Once the danger has passed, kind and polite can be important again.

Re:Good Samaritan Backfire by ForHackernews on Sunday March 30, 2014 @12:42PM (#7496730)
Yeah, I'm surprised and almost impressed by how much he manages to come across as a total wanker in his own account where he's presumably trying to cast himself in the best possible light.