News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by noonespecial on Saturday March 29, 2014 @10:53PM (#7494989)
Its all sunshine and roses until "the meeting" in which Carmack says "I've started this awesome feature that I feel defines the future of the product and..." a hand goes up and a suit says "that really doesn't fit with 'our vision' for where we want Oculus to go". Game Over.
Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by nnq on Sunday March 30, 2014 @05:58AM (#7495716)
You kind of forget who you're talking about. One doesn't just say that to John Carmack :)

For a team of new-comers, without both real engineering experience and real business experience, maybe the consequences of the Facebook acquisition could have went the way you imagine, but lots of the Oculus guys are heavyweights and when someone says something that goes against their vision they need to have solid arguments, and even if their arguments will be right, they need to consider that even throwing those arguments at them comes with a huge real risk (of having a team fracture and a bunch of very smart guys leaving the company) and huge real cost (the real productivity decrease that comes from pushing a team in a direction they don't want to go to, and of wasting the big-brains' time in meetings and arguments instead of product development - these kinds of "productivity penalties" ca very well allow a competitor to come up with a better idea before them!).

Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by grannyg00se on Sunday March 30, 2014 @09:46AM (#7496124)
I find that very difficult to imagine. JC isn't some mid level manager with a pet project in mind. He's one of the founding technical leads in the company FB just acquired. He has high political capital as well as personal financial independence. A close minded brush off like that would be likely to get that suit fired.
Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by forgottenpass on Sunday March 30, 2014 @10:28AM (#7496220)
It'd be easy to believe that, because it is reassuring in a way that calms anxieties about the future of Oculus.

But you only have to look back to Doom 3 to see the cracks in that idea. Many design decisions of that game were unpopular when it was released, and over the following years it came out that those decisions were driven by technical aspects of the engine. Where rather than the engine sacrificing for the design, design sacrificed for the engine.

So it'd be easy to make the less immediately appealing argument that they should push back on Carmack's vision when they think it's gone off the rails.

Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by dvogel on Sunday March 30, 2014 @11:37AM (#7496453)
links? As I remember it, most of the issues were around the fixed frame rates that were an attempt to unify PC development with console development. Perhaps I am confusing Doom 3 for another game though.
Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by forgottenpass on Sunday March 30, 2014 @12:12PM (#7496602)
The poster child is the flashlight, sounds stupid now but I remember how much shit it stirred back then. The rest I don't remember off the top of my head, and don't feel like scrubbing through days and days of Bombcast to find.

"Carmack has also admitted that the flashlight was not attached to the weapons in the original version of Doom 3 due to performance issues" ... http://www.dsogaming.com/news/john-carmack-speaks-30fps-on-c...

Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by jfoster on Sunday March 30, 2014 @02:37AM (#7495437)
Your comment assumes that Zuckerberg and the people at Facebook will be incompetent at nurturing an employee like John Carmack and the other talented Oculus VR folk.

If they're smart, they will allow him pretty much free reign, and then put some resources behind his projects to help them mature. (think Sergey Brin or Andy Rubin at Google)

Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by grey-area on Sunday March 30, 2014 @03:21AM (#7495501)
No, it just assumes that the interests of a large corporation which is entering the phase where it needs to show revenue growth every quarter and satisfy shareholders are not aligned with those of a small company attempting to build an experimental product in a completely new field. This is an old story and the outcome is almost always the same (large corp buys small corp, promises to change nothing and stay hands off, circumstances change, large corp looks for projects to downsize or cut). Google has many examples of acquisitions, how many are running in a hands off way now?

On top of that, Facebook has shown itself to be untrustworthy many times from a dev and user perspective (beacon, FB credits etc), so if Carmack wants to avoid that and produce something without intrusive advertising for example, they may well clash.

None of this means it was a bad idea to sell for oculus, just that selling is ceding control completely to the vision of the larger company in the long term.

Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by jamesaguilar on Sunday March 30, 2014 @03:45AM (#7495529)
Facebook does not need to satisfy any shareholder except one.

I mean, hacker news likes to freak out about fiduciary duty and "omg, corporations are obligated to make maximum profit." But realistically, almost no big corps run that way (almost all engage in some charity, many have foundations, etc.), and there is near-zero legal possibility of minority investors forcing them to. This is because investors have almost no say unless it is obvious you are trying to screw them -- normally a subset of them -- or unless there is no plausible way a course of action could make money.

Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by grey-area on Sunday March 30, 2014 @03:56AM (#7495545)
I've always thought the fiduciary duty argument was silly (and I'm not HN :), so I agree with you there, but that doesn't change the broader point - when you sell a company, it is no longer yours, and the interests and politics of a large corp with public shareholders and revenue targets are not those of a smaller acquisition.
Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by jamesaguilar on Sunday March 30, 2014 @04:22AM (#7495574)
I wasn't trying to challenge the broader point. I was trying to challenge the specific claim that some folks are making that Facebook Must ruin Oculus because balance sheet, which is nonsense. Although on re reading your comment I can see I replied too soon and you are not one of those.
Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by pizza234 on Sunday March 30, 2014 @05:08PM (#7497934)
> But realistically, almost no big corps run that way (almost all engage in some charity, many have foundations, etc.)

Engaging in charity and supporting foundations is not related to the "generosity" of the a corporation (who runs it); charity and foundations can be PR and tax-saving strategies.

Drug cartels engage in charitable donations; that doesn't make them generous.

HSBC (just picked a random one) supports charities. It also launders money for the drug cartels and is generally involved in illegal money transactions.

I can pick virtually any big corporation involved in corruption/crime scandals and I'm pretty sure they routinely make charitable acts and/or have their foundations and as well.

I certainly don't say that any corporation is corrupt, but the link with foundation/charities and morality of a corporation just doesn't exist.

Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by brg on Sunday March 30, 2014 @08:10PM (#7498618)
Tax write offs do not work like you seem to imply. There is no net financial gain to any charitable donation . Consider a dollar of profit. If kept on the ledger as profit, a corporation pays around fifty cents of that dollar in tax. If donated that dollar of profit is not taxed, but the corporation now had lost a dollar instead of 50 cents.
Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by ivanca on Monday March 31, 2014 @04:51AM (#7500376)
See through the cracks: The charity may be owned by a friend of the stockholders or managers. If the donation is reported by some media outlet it may as well recover the money; sometimes is mostly help their own agenda such as...

- A real state company that helps an organization that seeks to prevent the construction of new buildings (because it destroys the forest/parks) but in reality they just want to keep the price of their own stock as high as possible.

- A clothes company that support anti-fur organisations, only because the rival brand is the target of such protesters.

- An alternate reality where Shell supports anti-Exxon campaigns done by Greenpeace.

Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by mark_integerdsv on Monday March 31, 2014 @02:02AM (#7499899)
...a larger advertising company of the most cynical variety.
Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by avenger123 on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:01PM (#7495013)
Why is this a big problem? If your scenario plays out after VR is really viable because of the extra millions that Facebook puts into the product, so be it.

At this point, the awesome feature issue isn't even really on the table based on my understanding. Getting the technology to be stable and solving all the issues with it is the main focus. I don't see Facebook getting in the way of that. If that does become an issue, Facebook will have earned the right after having likely spent millions in the three digit range to get it going.

Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by amirmc on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:17PM (#7495065)
"Facebook will have earned the right after having likely spent millions in the three digit range to get it going."

This is true. That's exactly why people find it sad.

Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by girvo on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:50PM (#7505878)
Would they also be sad if Occulus never pulled it off due to financial constraints?
Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by noonespecial on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:26PM (#7495091)
My fear is that Carmack will know how to make VR really viable but will be prevented from doing this by his new short-sighted managers.

If this happens even a tiny bit, it will kill the passion in the entire team and Facebook's VR will become a gimmick more like Cue-Cat than a world-changing new platform.

Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by mst on Sunday March 30, 2014 @10:47AM (#7496270)
Or Carmack and Abrash will say "fuck it" and find an organisation (Valve perhaps :) that won't prevent them.

The technical minds should have a fair chunk of leverage here simply because of how much of the capacity to evolve the product in truly exciting ways will reside in their head.

Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by pekk on Sunday March 30, 2014 @11:59AM (#7496546)
> Or Carmack and Abrash will say "fuck it" and find an organisation (Valve perhaps :) that won't prevent them.

When Facebook owns all the IP? Don't be silly.

Re:Wrong and Right Reasons To Be Upset About Oculus – with C... by sseveran on Sunday March 30, 2014 @12:28PM (#7496663)
Abrash just left Valve.