News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In new case, Supreme Court revisits the question of softw... by rayiner on Saturday March 29, 2014 @10:11PM (#7494841)
The purpose of patents isn't to incentivize innovation. Its to protect capital intensive R&D from the free rider effect and to allow the fruits of R&D to be the subject of transactions. Crowd funding in this context is a joke. Wake me up when someone crowd funds a blockbuster anti-cancer drug or disease resistant crop. We're talking capital investments that start with a 'b'. Nobody is going to fund that if the results can be easily copied (eliminating ROI), whether we're talking about traditional investors or crowd funders.

A great example is the Spaceship One patents. The arrangement there was that Scaled Composites would do the R&D, and Paul Allen would invest, and companies like Virgin would commercialize. Having a property right that can be the subject of transactions is tremendously valuable for these sorts of arrangements.

Re:In new case, Supreme Court revisits the question of softw... by wnoise on Sunday March 30, 2014 @12:50AM (#7495276)
The purpose of patents absolutely is to provide incentives for innovation. What you describe as the purpose (protecting capital intensive R&D from free riders) is merely the method.

To the extent that the method does not result in the purpose, the patent system is a failure.

Re:In new case, Supreme Court revisits the question of softw... by panabee on Sunday March 30, 2014 @12:01AM (#7495171)
i'm not sure why you say patents aren't supposed to encourage innovation: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patent. they exist to encourage invention by ensuring someone cannot copy your r&d efforts. after all, the purpose of r&d is to innovate and discover. i didn't say patents would be abolished immediately or for all sectors. pharma products, in particular, require hundreds of millions of dollars and cannot get crowdfunded right now. but if we're to ever eliminate patents, crowdfunding will play a central role.
Re:In new case, Supreme Court revisits the question of softw... by dctoedt on Sunday March 30, 2014 @07:10AM (#7495835)
> The purpose of patents isn't to incentivize innovation.

That's directly contrary to the text of the U.S. Constitution, article I, section 8, clause 8, which gives Congress the power: "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries."

The Supreme Court's canonical explanation of patents' constitutional purpose was written by Justice Clark, for a unanimous Court, in Graham v. John Deere Co. of Kansas City, 366 U.S. 1 (1966): [1]

==BEGIN QUOTE==

... The clause is both a grant of power and a limitation. This qualified authority, unlike the power often exercised in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries by the English Crown, is limited to the promotion of advances in the "useful arts." It was written against the backdrop of the practices—eventually curtailed by the Statute of Monopolies—of the Crown in granting monopolies to court favorites in goods or businesses which had long before been enjoyed by the public. See Meinhardt, Inventions, Patents and Monopoly, pp. 30-35 (London, 1946).

The Congress in the exercise of the patent power may not overreach the restraints imposed by the stated constitutional purpose.

Nor may it enlarge the patent monopoly without regard to the innovation, advancement or social benefit gained thereby.

Moreover, Congress may not authorize the issuance of patents whose effects are to remove existent knowledge from the public domain, or to restrict free access to materials already available.

Innovation, advancement, and things which add to the sum of useful knowledge are inherent requisites in a patent system which by constitutional command must "promote the Progress of . . . useful Arts."

This is the standard expressed in the Constitution and it may not be ignored. ...

==END QUOTE==

Id. at 5-6 (emphasis in original, extra paragraphing added.)

As 'wnoise correctly points out down-thread, protecting capital-intensive R&D from free riders is not an end in itself, but merely a means for achieving that end.

[1] http://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=9105652591497305.... The decision was 7-0; two justices (Stewart and Fortas) took no part, which usually means they recused themselves because of conflicts of interest such as personal business investments in one of the parties.

Re:In new case, Supreme Court revisits the question of softw... by rayiner on Sunday March 30, 2014 @09:11AM (#7496061)
You're right that's the stated purpose of patents. But that rationale arose before we had a solid understanding of modern economics. I'm talking about the rationale for patents in that context. Its prevention of free riding. Just as Posner would say the purpose of the tort system is to shift the cost of exercising care to the party that can bear it at least cost, or the purpose of environmental laws is to internalize negative externalities, etc.
Re:In new case, Supreme Court revisits the question of softw... by dctoedt on Sunday March 30, 2014 @09:22AM (#7496078)
Point taken -- maybe a better phrasing would be that the purpose of the patent system is to try to mitigate disincentives to innovation, viz., the free-rider problem.