News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In new case, Supreme Court revisits the question of softw... by rayiner on Saturday March 29, 2014 @04:57PM (#7493895)
To be precise, the case isn't about software patents. Its about whether taking an unpatentable business method (per Bilski) and implementing it on a general purpose computer makes it patentable. The answer will likely be no, but that won't invalidate software patents. The appellant wants to make it seem that way, "if you deny our patent it will invalidate all software patents," but thats not the best characterization. What will happen instead is that the Supreme Court will distinguish software patents generally from the patent at issue in this case. What will be interesting, in my opinion, is how they draw the distinction.

The "abstract idea" line drawing is complicated from both sides, however. Say you develop a clever algorithm for doing transmission power control for a WiFi radio. If you implement it on an ASIC, that's almost certainly patentable. But what about an FPGA? Or a general purpose processor? If software patents are categorically invalid, you end up being able to patent things in ASICs that can't be patented if done on a GPP. If they are valid, that doesn't help when someone tries to patent something like a mechanism for hedging risk.

I think the real issue is looking at whether the algorithm embodied in a patent is a general concept, or a narrow domain specific design. In other words, you shouldn't be able to patent the concept of transmission power control. But you should be able to patent a specific method for doing transmission power control they arises out of capital intensive research.

Re:In new case, Supreme Court revisits the question of softw... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:29PM (#7494057)
> Its about whether taking an unpatentable business method (per Bilski) and implementing it on a general purpose computer makes it patentable.

TBH, I'm not terribly familiar with what can and can't be patented as per business methods. But technically all things that can be computed, can be computed by enough people doing the arithmetic. Computers just make this much faster.

So if I have 300 people...I dunno, collating wedding invitations, and come up with a way of doing it in software, that's not patentable?

However, a clever algorithm for computational imaging is arguable patentable, but anybody who knows matrix math can probably do it manually.

So is it really a discussion over the magnitude of the assist to humans doing the grinding computations by hand and where that line is drawn? Or to your example, some software running on a general purpose CPU can often be implemented as DSPs or some other specialized hardware, it's obviously no longer software I suppose once it's a DSP, even if the method for doing the computation is the same.

Re:In new case, Supreme Court revisits the question of softw... by rayiner on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:41PM (#7494114)
I mean, your examples really capture the debate at issue in the case. Trying to draw lines based on whether the idea is implemented in software or hardware is just arbitrary.

The real question is: what sort of algorithms do we want people to be able to patent? This is an economic question, not a legal one. At what point does the benefit from disallowing free riding out weigh the cost of granting the temporary monopoly? The problem with the law is that it sidesteps this question. Its based on an 19th century notion of invention, whereas the real value of patents is protecting investment into R&D.

Re:In new case, Supreme Court revisits the question of softw... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:47PM (#7494134)
Right. And I think that's a useful consideration to use. I've worked on some algorithms in the past that were the result of a few million dollars in R&D. We decided not to patent because of the gray areas involved, but instead kept the algorithms protected by distributing only compiled code (as is pretty common in industry). But good solid protection for that kind of investment would be a useful thing to have even if it's a software patent.

One-click shopping? I believe there was lots of effort put into engineering it, but not so much on the R&D side.

Is a patent examiner qualified to implement whatever decision is made on where that line is? I think it's still going to remain a minefield for a very long time.

Re:In new case, Supreme Court revisits the question of softw... by _delirium on Sunday March 30, 2014 @01:32PM (#7496988)
> based on an 19th century notion of invention

I think this is one reason the courts have also not had much luck finding any useful & principled theories of invention to apply. The law assumes a kind of classical "eureka!" theory of invention, where there is normal work and then the occasional Invention, which few scholars these days think is how technological advances actually happen. So if the courts were to try to read a scholarly book on either the history or current state of technological advances and try to make use of its concepts (courts sometimes do that kind of thing, if they can find something that will help them make a principled distinction) there would just be a big mismatch in basic assumptions and framework. So they don't, and instead are stuck with trying to make the best of a kind of cobbled-together theory of what constitutes an invention vs. a non-invention. And at this point, absent Congress significantly rewriting patent law, there isn't really much they can do except continue that process of accretion, by doing line-drawing in the gray areas of the existing case law when an opportunity arises.

Re:In new case, Supreme Court revisits the question of softw... by WildUtah on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:20PM (#7493999)
What will be interesting, in my opinion, is how they draw the distinction.

They don't have to draw a distinction, of course. The last time a finance patent came before the Supreme Court in Bilski in 2010, there were two theories about why the patent in suit wasn't valid under 35 USC §101. Four judges agreed with each theory, leaving only Justice Antonin Scalia to decide. Scalia joined with the conclusion of each side and the theory of neither, leaving the situation even more confused than before.

Most likely the exact same thing will ensue this time.

Re:In new case, Supreme Court revisits the question of softw... by sthu11182 on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:40PM (#7494107)
With the Federal Circuit punting it to the Supreme Court, I don't they will leave it that vague. The Supreme Court does not like bright line rules for patents, I think they will come up with a balancing, multi-factor test.
Re:In new case, Supreme Court revisits the question of softw... by Joeri on Sunday March 30, 2014 @04:35AM (#7495597)
If it seems unclear where the boundary line for patentability should lie, then it seems reasonable to apply caution and only allow patenting of that which necessitates it to ensure invention occurs at all. From what i can tell, that would eliminate 95% of patents. There is an argument to be made that patents harm innovation in nearly all industries, not just the software industry.
Re:In new case, Supreme Court revisits the question of softw... by thaumasiotes on Sunday March 30, 2014 @06:35AM (#7495784)
For things like business methods patents, the idea isn't that we need to get innovation to occur when it wouldn't otherwise. The idea is that we want to get it published when it otherwise wouldn't be, so that the knowledge isn't lost after the people who knew it die.

It baffles me why we have a patent system (to address precisely this problem) and also legal protections for "trade secrets".