News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Bing Censoring Questions About Microsoft? by jacquesm on Saturday August 08, 2009 @08:45AM (#749239)
The thing that really surprises me about all this is the surprise. Bing was not set up with Chinese walls in place (they way it should have been done) and has been produced by a company that sees every communication with others as a marketing effort (this may be a good thing, I'm not sure).

They'll do everything they can to portray themselves in a good light.

For instance when you search on bing for microsoft vs stacker the wikipedia page that specifically adresses the lawsuit is not even in the top 10 search results, whereas it is arguably the best page on the subject on the web. Coincidence ? Possible. Probable ? I don't think so.

Bing has its uses, but to get objective information about its owners you'd have to look elsewhere.

The interesting thing with all this is that people are now so conditioned to find stuff using search engines that if a search engine does not list a page it might as well not exist.

Re:Is Bing Censoring Questions About Microsoft? by socillion on Saturday August 08, 2009 @09:40AM (#749291)
"Bing" "microsoft vs stacker wikipedia". The first result is a wikipedia page on disk partitioning. Google the same, you get as the first three results wikipedia pages on Stac Electronics and MS-DOS, and as the third result this HN page.

As you can see, Google did what you wanted. However, the litigation was between Stac Electronics and Microsoft, so now try "microsoft vs stac wikipedia". Bing: returns wikipedia category "microsoft criticisms" and the third result is "microsoft litigation". Google: returns the wikipedia pages "stac electronics" and "microsoft litigation".

The conclusions I draw from this is that Bing and Google just have very different algorithms, relatively speaking. Wikipedia appears to have a much lower ranking in Bing than Google, at least in cases where there isn't a page with a very similar name. Here are two searches to compare: http://www.bing.com/search?q=microsoft+vs+stac http://www.google.com/#q=microsoft+vs+stac

While I understand why people bash MS, as well as Google (I agree with most of it), I think sometimes its best to take an unbiased look. I cannot see any attempt by MS to remove useful results; the first one is the original text of the lawsuit!

Re:Is Bing Censoring Questions About Microsoft? by jacquesm on Saturday August 08, 2009 @11:01AM (#749360)