News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by hdevalence on Saturday March 29, 2014 @10:41AM (#7492362)
More importantly, why does NVidia, who contribute practically nothing to Free graphics development (drivers or the rest of the graphics stack) think that the Wayland developers have any obligation to make Wayland work well with their secretly-developed blobs?

If NVidia wants to have input, they could hire people to work on Wayland. Otherwise: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxHqi8tx048&t=0m28s

Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by teacup50 on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:25PM (#7492756)
> More importantly, why does NVidia, who contribute practically nothing to Free graphics development (drivers or the rest of the graphics stack) think that the Wayland developers have any obligation to make Wayland work well with their secretly-developed blobs?

NVidia could also just not support Linux at all, which would certainly create even more of an uphill battle for Free graphics development and Linux.

Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by Morgawr on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:46PM (#7492848)
That would be a pretty terrible PR move by nVidia. While I hate the fact that they don't open source their stuff, I have to give them props because their blobs drivers work really well on Linux too.

Abandoning Linux is definitely the wrong move, especially now that the gaming community is thriving.

Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by pekk on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:24PM (#7492994)
Terrible PR among the tiny minority of Linux users.

Most people are using Windows or Mac and most of those are either completely ignorant, completely indifferent or actively hostile to Linux

Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by Morgawr on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:28PM (#7493012)
You're not too familiar with the gaming community and the noise they can generate, are you? Just look at the Oculus deal, if you're in the gaming industry you definitely don't want to piss off gamers, no matter how much of a minority they can be.

This said, Linux is thriving a lot these days and is gaining a huge momentum as far as gaming goes. The community is constantly growing, the tools are all coming to Linux, SteamOS is right behind the corner, more and more companies are targeting the Linux platform, etc etc.

Bailing out of the Linux ecosystem now would be a terrible and shortsighted move on behalf of nVidia.

Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by cookiecaper on Saturday March 29, 2014 @04:37PM (#7493824)
What are we supposed to learn about the power of gamers from the Oculus deal? They can whine on forums and cancel their pre-orders? That has been the only visible "negative" consequence of the Oculus/Facebook deal thus far.
Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by gravitasaxe on Sunday March 30, 2014 @12:53AM (#7495280)
Cancelled preorders, permanent PR damage, several dozen projects have been canned & fear has replaced confidence in consumers & devs alike when talking anything Oculus now. Not the rule but it's prevalent. You downplaying the impact is just plain stupidity.
Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by cookiecaper on Sunday March 30, 2014 @01:56AM (#7495368)
I mentioned canceled pre-orders and I don't think that was unanticipated. I don't know how many were canceled, but with Facebook's coffers backing Oculus VR now, I must say I don't think they're overly concerned. My understanding was that the DKs were being sold primarily to finance further development and prototyping (and in particular to provide proof to suppliers that sufficient volume would exist), which is now a non-issue since they now have essentially as much money as they want, and can order x million units to get bulk pricing regardless of consumer demand.

The only major project that's been canceled was Minecraft, which Luckey privately pointed out was complete and utter vaporware anyway. I have a DK1 and I can tell you that most "Rift projects" were one-off tech demos that mostly weren't maintained, and no one will miss. If OVR continues to develop a good product, people will continue to develop for their platform, whether Facebook owns them or not.

What PR damage, outside of the group that they expected would be unhappy? It's all over the head of people who didn't know what Oculus was before the acquisition. I don't think people who aren't part of the industry really care, because they don't know anything about it. To the extent that it was covered by mainstream outlets, it was because Facebook bought another company, not because they were outraged that the dream of Oculus VR was being destroyed by FB.

Fear hasn't replaced confidence in all consumers and developers. Logical persons may have their opinions and predictions, but no one is justified in anything beyond "wait and see" until something actually happens.

I'm not downplaying the impact of the ire of the gaming community. I just don't think there's been a noteworthy one other than the vast amount of fruitless rage that's filled tech forums recently. Perhaps we disagree, but I don't think my assertions are "plain stupidity".

Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by zanny on Saturday March 29, 2014 @02:39PM (#7493374)
Thankfully, Linux has alternatives right now. And if you want free drivers, they aren't on the table anyway.

If Nvidia dropped off the face of the Earth in Linux support everyone would just buy AMD discrete or Intel integrated parts and not bat an eye. And both of those companies have dozens or hundreds of developers working in the FOSS space. And for some reason, they also get my money, where I purposefully avoid Nvidia products (I don't buy their Tegra APUs, I'd never buy a computer with one of their graphics accelerators, etc).

Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by iwwr on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:38PM (#7494090)
I guess you don't consider gaming a worthwhile endeavor on Linux?
Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by zanny on Saturday March 29, 2014 @07:50PM (#7494496)
I have no problem running most games under radeonSI. Only ones I have that don't work are Natural Selection 2 and Metro Last Light, which is mostly waiting on GL 3.3 in LLVM 3.5.

For example, DOTA2 / Portal 2 / TF2 all run at ~60 fps with high / ultra settings on my 7870.

There is nothing about driver openness that would impede their ability to run OpenGL games besides the version support, and that is rapidly being remedied.

Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by baggers on Saturday March 29, 2014 @08:22PM (#7494575)
or laptops apparently
Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by blinkingled on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:11AM (#7492471)
Exactly. Nvidia has got away with crap for far too long. And given the rise of Intel and AMD GPUs which come with fully OSS drivers, they need to get their heads out of sand and realize that they can't get away with it anymore and they need to either invest resources in getting their GPUs supported under Linux - be it Android or Desktop - or at least make their specs open like AMD. (The way they supported Tegra on Android is also similarly crappy - look at how many popular Tegra Android phones or tablets were released post the Nexus 7 2012.)
Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by cookiecaper on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:51PM (#7492858)
They can get away with it because their drivers actually work. The OSS drivers are improving, but it's taken them a half-decade or more to come even within 70% of Windows performance parity. nVidia's drivers have performance parity on day 1, and generally, far fewer show-stopping bugs.
Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by zanny on Saturday March 29, 2014 @02:42PM (#7493396)
Really, FOSS driver development has been confined to the last 2 years. AMD has a half dozen developers in Mesa, and I think Intel has around 20. They have pushed it from Core Profile 2.1 to 3.3 in 2 years, and will probably have it at 4.0 or 4.1 by years end.

Before that, AMD wasn't making free drivers, and Intel didn't care about their integrated graphics as much and never had higher GL support on them. They have come pretty far in a short time frame, and by the time GL 5 comes out (I assume, the one with the low level primitive support to match DX12) Mesa should only be a version behind or so.

Also, I wouldn't really agree Nvidia drivers work. I had a GTX 285 in an older machine I put Ubuntu on, and their blob didn't work with resume / suspend at all. Dunno if they'd work now, I just switched that system to Nouveau, which... works with suspend flawlessly. And manages fan speeds a lot better than the blob, too.

Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by cookiecaper on Saturday March 29, 2014 @04:10PM (#7493738)
AMD's been making free drivers for seven years. http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=826&num=1

I said the last half-decade to be generous. It's taken this long to finally get some of the older cards to a mostly usable state for 3D gaming (usually the point of a consumer-grade 3D graphics card).

Mesa has been picking up new GL versions which is good, but it's taken a really long time.

Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by blinkingled on Saturday March 29, 2014 @08:25PM (#7494588)
>AMD's been making free drivers for seven years.

It takes lot of time and effort to get GPU drivers usable with all features. I would say they actually did a great job hiring OSS people, contributing documentation after lengthy legal reviews and they kept up with most older and newer GPUs. And they now have dynamic power management! That's great progress for me.

Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by cookiecaper on Saturday March 29, 2014 @10:04PM (#7494822)
You're fooling yourself if you don't think they could've done better. There's no reason they had to start from scratch. Bridgman constantly stated the the free drivers were intended for basic functionality and free software development purposes only, and that AMD would continue to provide proprietary drivers for people who needed performance.

ATi started the free drivers in a last-ditch move of desperation to inflate sales in whatever small way possible when they were on the ropes. They'd hoped that this would get some of the *nix geeks to make significant buys. They only sponsored 2 developers if I remember right.

I don't mean to look a gift horse in the mouth, but I don't think they really deserve all that much credit. Seven years is far too long to start skirting Windows performance parity, and please note that most newer hardware is still way behind. The open-source AMD drivers primarily remain of interest to people who want to develop free software or whose cards stopped working on the proprietary drivers. When I tried last September, you still couldn't reasonably play games with open-source radeon drivers on newish hardware.

Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by a8000 on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:28AM (#7492530)
The last time I tried to use an AMD video card with 3d acceleration under Linux it was a horrible experience. Nvidias binary drivers just work out of the box even with the most recent hardware and have OpenGL 4.3 support. Has the situation changed with AMD cards?
Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by rcxdude on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:51AM (#7492614)
It works pretty well for me using the OSS drivers. Better experience than any of the binary drivers (NVIDIA and AMD), and the performance and features are good enough for gaming via WINE (though still not quite as good as the binary drivers AFAIK). I think the current pain points are support for the latest hardware and power saving for laptops.
Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by zanny on Saturday March 29, 2014 @02:45PM (#7493409)
Kernel 3.13 got full dual graphics ACPI shutdown on the discrete part, and they have had DPM enabled on all parts since 3.12. Should be good now on the power saving end.
Re:Nvidia working on Wayland support for binary driver by jamesaguilar on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:57PM (#7493146)
I don't see where nvidia acts as if Wayland devs have any obligations here. All he said was that their driver would not work after this change. The only thing this obligates Wayland devs to do is not change this if they want nvidia to support wayland.