News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mt. Gox CEO Karpeles refuses travel to U.S. for questioning by logfromblammo on Thursday March 27, 2014 @02:40PM (#7482432)
It is equally cute to believe that someone will not lie to you just because you made him promise not to. The actual threat is that if you lie in court, and get caught, you will be thrown in a cage by men with guns.

An oath is not necessary for that. It suffices to say, "If you misrepresent the facts here, we will punish you for it in addition to whatever may be decided in this case. Do you understand?" and for the witness to say "Yes".

If a fact as stated in a deposition is discovered to actually be false, the armed men and iron bars do come into play. Don't make the mistake that just because they are not physically present and visible at the time that the threat of them is not important while someone is being deposed.

I can't tell if you are an apologist for the system, eliding over its obvious flaws, or someone genuinely clueless about theories of trust.

Either way, some cross-disciplinary study of the development of moral behavior in primates may be useful. Imagine asking young children of varying ages whether they took the cookie from the table in the room with the hidden camera, and asking the follow-up question about whether they were lying or not.

After having done so, you may realize that most court procedures operate on the principle that people make moral choices based upon fear of retribution after getting caught. This is entirely unsuitable for people at different stages of moral development from the median, such as children, retarded adults, sociopaths, geniuses, sociologists, atheists, autistics, and philosophers. The implied courtroom intimidation tactics just don't work.

There are several reasons why. Telling the truth as you know it is not an absolute defense against being punished anyway. The only information the court may have about something may be what you tell them. The measure for credibility is not how true something is, but how believable it is. The punishment for lying may be less than the punishment for telling the truth. My cartel enforcer can punish me to a greater extent than the court's enforcers. Etcetera.

Re:Mt. Gox CEO Karpeles refuses travel to U.S. for questioning by gamblor956 on Thursday March 27, 2014 @08:17PM (#7484430)
I'm a former criminal defense attorney with a background in cognitive science. I speak from experience.

Almost everything you just wrote is a fantasy view of the US judicial system, morality, and cognitive development, and psychology which doesn't actually exist in the real world.

Re:Mt. Gox CEO Karpeles refuses travel to U.S. for questioning by logfromblammo on Friday March 28, 2014 @03:44PM (#7489528)
It appears as though you are saying your argument holds more strength because of who you are (or were), and who I am not. Is that not an ad hominem, appeal to authority, and judgmental language?

It could be true. Were we arguing formally, I might ask you to prove your (negative) statement instead of just nakedly asserting that everything I said is wrong.

I was referring to Kohlberg's stages of moral development, assuming that the common criminal, as encountered by the justice system, would be at a very low stage, on par with very young children. The justice system's overwhelming focus upon punishment and deterrence seems to align with that assumption.

The system itself can only accomodate people between stages one and four. If, for whatever reason, someone decides that the law is an ass, and goes to stage five or six with a personal philosophy that is fundamentally incompatible with social norms, there is really nothing the system can do to accomodate him.

A catch-and-punish-by-lawful-authority model does nothing to prevent crimes by people who have arrived at a sociopathic morality model by introspection. IF Karpeles is such a person, the actions taken in civil court are completely pointless, as he would never voluntarily submit to the authority of what he would see as a system morally inferior to his own.

You can't really know how to deal with people at stage five or six without knowing the foundation principles of their morality. It could be literally anything. There is no reliable way for a cooperative society to enforce conformity on someone who has rejected society's common set of rules for another based on original thought.