News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Homeopathic remedies recalled for containing real medicine by KumarAseem on Thursday March 27, 2014 @09:02AM (#7480059)
I have no idea on how they do those clinical studies which say that there is no difference between a placebo and actual homeopathic medicines. And what I read of USA, I have doubts that these studies are really done by independent personnel and not by those who get directly/indirectly paid by companies like Merck, J&J, etc.

I myself take homeopathic medicines for various ailments (small or big) and have seen improvement in my physical condition every time. Also a lot of people I know rely on homeopathy and not one has ever said that it did not give the desired results. The only factor is that the doctor should be able to diagnose the patient properly and have enough knowledge to understand how each chemical interacts with the body and with other chemical to be able to make a compound that will help the body in overcoming the disease. Homeopathy is as much about the medicines as it is about the knowledge and experience of the doctor.

Re:Homeopathic remedies recalled for containing real medicine by aestra on Thursday March 27, 2014 @09:41AM (#7480283)
>I have no idea on how they do those clinical studies which say that there is no difference between a placebo and actual homeopathic medicines.

So read up on them. Here's a good place to start: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy it is very well researched and you can review the papers yourself.

Also:

http://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/homeo.html

http://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/6860/has-most-pe...

http://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/1915/has-there-e...

>I have doubts that these studies are really done by independent personnel and not by those who get directly/indirectly paid by companies like Merck, J&J, etc.

Oh come on!! Do you really think the National Science Foundation[1] is a Merck shill? or the scientific journal Bioethics?[2]

[1] http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/seind02/c7/c7s5.htm#c7s5l2

[2] http://www.dcscience.net/Smith-response.pdf

>have seen improvement in my physical condition every time

Please note, the types of things homeopathy is prescribed for are self limiting. Your body will heal over time without intervention, so yes! You will feel an improvement! The remedy you took has nothing to do with it though.

Re:Homeopathic remedies recalled for containing real medicine by KumarAseem on Thursday March 27, 2014 @11:42AM (#7481049)
"Please note, the types of things homeopathy is prescribed for are self limiting. Your body will heal over time without intervention, so yes! You will feel an improvement! The remedy you took has nothing to do with it though."

Not exactly. The medicine course brought the illness down to a level where i could really not make out if I still have the problem or not. The problem again surfaced to a very lesser extent after 3 years of finishing the course. What I am talking about is Sinusitis and there is no treatment of it in allopathy apart from operation and the allopathic doctors themselves say that after operation it will again return in 1-2 years.

Why I said that I do not believe the tests that are done by US agencies because most of the tests that are done by US agencies come out to be heavily influenced by the private sector companies who have their business interest in those studies incase the result come out that go against what they claim after few years when skeletons tumble out. I do not reside in US so my opinions are based on what I read in major newspapers.

So you can downvote me to any extent but I have experienced the results on myself and have seen the difference and hence highly doubt those studies. And when I say the doctor really matters that is because you can go for the same illness to many doctors and the medicines that some will give you will show less/no effect at all. So the experience level and understanding of different chemicals and their bonding really does matter.

Re:Homeopathic remedies recalled for containing real medicine by aestra on Thursday March 27, 2014 @12:02PM (#7481186)
First of all, I accidentally omitted the word "generally" which was meant to be there. What I meant to say was "Please note, the types of things homeopathy is prescribed for are GENERALLY self limiting. Your body will heal over time without intervention, so yes! You will feel an improvement! The remedy you took has nothing to do with it though."

> What I am talking about is Sinusitis and there is no treatment of it in allopathy apart from operation and the allopathic doctors themselves say that after operation it will again return in 1-2 years.

Completely and totally incorrect.

http://consults.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/05/25/the-best-treatm...

>The best treatment, first line, is nasal irrigation with saline solution to just move the stuff along. If you took all the people in the world who say they have chronic sinusitis, and you put them all on nasal saline irrigations, a big proportion would not have any symptoms anymore.

>After that would be medications, like steroids, which are anti-inflammatory drugs. And if you can actually culture bacteria from a patient’s sinuses and know what you’re treating, antibiotics are appropriate. Decongestants, when appropriately used for a limited duration, are incredibly effective at relieving the obstruction and letting the sinuses drain.

>The sinusitis patients who do well are the ones who really abide by using the neti pot or the saline irrigation bottles. And whether we add additional medications or not to the saline, it’s that mechanical flushing and lavage that really has a tremendous effect. Because it’s getting rid of the mucus, getting rid of all the inflammatory cells and whatever bacteria are there.

The vast majority of sinusitis cases resolve on their own within 10 days. The cause of most cases is a viral infection.

Chronic sinusitis can be caused by asthma or allergies, which are known to spontaneously reverse with age. Or pollutants, etc, which can be removed from your living environment, even on accident.

Sinusitis surgery is far from the first line of treatment.

Sinusitis surgery isn't just one surgery, it is tailored to the individual patient and their causes and symptoms. for example, removal of infected, swollen, or damaged tissue if that is what is causing it. Can remove some bone if the sinuses are unusually small, or polyps if that is what is causing it. While it is true that sinusitis can reoccur after surgery, it is far from guaranteed. "Will again return in 1-2 years" is absolutely stupid and false. It depends a lot on the patient, their immune system, the type of surgery, the cause, and importantly, post-op care. Not to mention luck!

I had a chronic cough for years, caused by post nasal drip. No medications helped at all, I tried all of them. Nobody could figure out what was even causing it. One day though, it resolved completely by itself. I still do get mild flareups once in a great while for a week or two though. People have even been known to spontaneously recover from cancer. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spontaneous_remission

The other interesting thing is in the case of cervical cancer. The Human papillomavirus virus (HPV) can cause precancerous changes in the cervix. Mostly, these changes just reverse themselves. When you get an abnormal pap test, as long as the changes aren't very advanced, the course of action is "wait and see" to see if your body fixes the problem. In the vast majority of the cases it does, only a few with abnormal pap test will go on to develop cervical cancer. I had an abnormal pap with "low grade changes" several years ago. My heart skipped a beat when I heard the news. Guess what? We just retested me in a year and I was good to go. My body fixed itself.

>I have experienced the results on myself and have seen the difference and hence highly doubt those studies.

That is extremely flawed reasoning. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anecdotal_evidence

For example, if everytime I had a cold I did 25 situps in the morning. My cold always went away. I can not then conclude that 25 situps in the morning is a cure for the cold.

Please review the cited studies (See the GP) for bias.

Re:Homeopathic remedies recalled for containing real medicine by KumarAseem on Thursday March 27, 2014 @03:56PM (#7482991)
My problem was not that developed in a month or two but was there from a long time and it took couple of months after I started taking the medicine to get cured and I could see the effect on myself on a weekly basis (It wasn't that one day I woke up and found that I am cured).

And you mean to say that just because my mind thought that what I am taking is real medicine hence my body developed the immunity to fight back the bacterial growth by itself? It is not necessary that what people do not understand now does not mean that it is wrong/flawed/fake. We are not so advanced to know each and everything about chemistry and biology and human body.

I have seen multiple results and have also tested myself by stopping the medication and again starting it and seeing the results for numerous other ailments, hence my belief stands.

Re:Homeopathic remedies recalled for containing real medicine by aestra on Friday March 28, 2014 @09:43AM (#7487136)
>My problem was not that developed in a month or two but was there from a long time

Yes, and this is called chronic sinusitis, which is what I posted about.

>It wasn't that one day I woke up and found that I am cured

Real medicine is the same way.

>We are not so advanced to know each and everything about chemistry and biology and human body.

Correct, however we know enough to know that homeopathy is bull-fucking-shit.

>I have seen multiple results and have also tested myself by stopping the medication and again starting it and seeing the results for numerous other ailments, hence my belief stands.

As I said before, this is false reasoning. See my GP.

Re:Homeopathic remedies recalled for containing real medicine by KumarAseem on Friday March 28, 2014 @11:41AM (#7487895)
So if I was taking Fake/No medication, then I should believe that my body developed the ability to fight and stop the disease without any the help of any external agent just because my brain was thinking that I am taking real medication?
Re:Homeopathic remedies recalled for containing real medicine by brazzy on Thursday March 27, 2014 @09:11AM (#7480111)
You and the people you know are being scammed, spending your money for nothing. You see improvements because your body is recovering all on its own - it's pretty good at that.

Homeopathic "medicines" contain no chemicals that interact with the body or form compounds, which is exactly why anyone who isn't a complete idiot should immediately understand that it's all a bunch of bullshit.

Your homeopath peddler (who does not deserve to be called "doctor") understands absolutely nothing about your body, he has merely memorized a bunch of arbitrary meaningless rules.

Re:Homeopathic remedies recalled for containing real medicine by LinXitoW on Thursday March 27, 2014 @09:12AM (#7480117)
Homeopathic remedies have been shown to be no more effective than placebos. The thing is, placebos actually are effective to some degree. So the problem isn't that homeopathy isn't effective, it's that the entire premise of why they are effective is total BS, and people are getting ripped off.
Re:Homeopathic remedies recalled for containing real medicine by ekianjo on Thursday March 27, 2014 @09:11AM (#7480116)
> I myself take homeopathic medicines for various ailments (small or big) and have seen improvement in my physical condition every time.

That's exactly the Placebo effect that you are describing.

Re:Homeopathic remedies recalled for containing real medicine by mikeash on Thursday March 27, 2014 @09:40AM (#7480279)
Understand that you are drinking plain water when you take a "homeopathic medicine". It is indistinguishable from the stuff that comes out of your tap.